Copyright Laws: Global Reach And International Application

Copyright laws vary from country to country, and there is no such thing as an international copyright that automatically protects an individual's work worldwide. Each country has its own unique copyright laws that govern intellectual property within that country. This means that a copyright held in one country may not be valid in another. However, countries may have treaties with each other that outline how they will recognize each other's copyrights. These treaties aim to ensure uniformity among member states, but enforcement can vary. For example, while the US has statutory damages, other countries may have weaker enforcement mechanisms. To seek protection for work in another country, it is advisable to consult an attorney versed in the laws of that country.

International copyright conventions and treaties

International copyright laws are not standardised and vary from country to country. There is no such thing as an international copyright that will automatically protect an individual's work worldwide. However, several international treaties encourage reasonably coherent protection of copyright from country to country. These treaties set minimum standards of protection which each signatory country then implements within the bounds of its own copyright law.

The oldest and most important of these treaties is the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works (also referred to as the Berne Convention). Signed in 1886 (but since revised many times), it has been ratified by nearly 180 countries. The Berne Convention requires protection for all creative works in a fixed medium to be automatic and to last for at least 50 years after the author's death. Photographic works are tied to a minimum of 25 years, while cinematographic works are protected for 50 years after the first showing, or 50 years after creation if it has not been shown within 50 years. The Berne Convention also allows for the rule of the shorter term, stating that "the term shall not exceed the term fixed in the country of origin of the work". Not all countries have applied this rule, however.

The Buenos Aires Convention (Third Pan-American Convention) was signed by most North and South American countries. It allows for the protection of all creative works as long as they contain a notice informing that the creator claims copyright on it. The Buenos Aires Convention also instituted the rule of the shorter term, where the length of the copyright term for the work in a country was whichever was shorter – the length of the term in the source country, or the protecting country of the work. All Buenos Aires countries are now also parties to the Berne Convention, but elements from Buenos Aires are still used in the modern era, such as the rule of the shorter term.

The WIPO Copyright Treaty (WCT) and the WIPO Performances and Phonograms Treaty (WPPT) were established in 1996. WCT makes clear that computer programs and databases are protected by copyright and recognises that the transmission of works over the internet and similar networks is an exclusive right within the scope of copyright, originally held by the creator. WPPT provides additional protection for distribution rights and adds the right to control rentals of computer programs, cinematographic works, and phonograms.

The Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) is administered by the World Trade Organization. It includes a number of provisions related to the enforcement of IP rights, saying that national laws have to make the effective enforcement of IP rights possible, and describing in detail how enforcement should be addressed. TRIPS attempts to ensure that no member country provides better protection to its own nationals than to foreigners seeking protection within the state. Further, any protection granted to the nationals of another state must be granted to all foreign nationals.

National laws and copyright protection

Copyright law can vary from country to country, and there is no international copyright that will automatically protect an individual's work worldwide. This means that the copyright an author holds in one country may not be valid in another. Each country has its own unique copyright laws that govern intellectual property within that country. A country's copyright laws only apply to works created and used in that country.

The duration of copyright, what material is subject to copyright protection, who is considered the author of a copyright, and what formalities must be followed to demonstrate authorship can differ between countries. For example, in the United States, original works of authorship that are eligible for copyright are protected automatically under national copyright law. This automatic protection may not extend to other countries with different copyright laws and norms.

To address this issue, international copyright conventions and treaties have been established to provide more certainty and understanding about the levels of copyright protection in different countries. These treaties outline obligations for member countries to implement in their national laws. For instance, the Berne Convention of 1971, which the US is a signatory to, is the main copyright treaty designed to protect literary and artistic works. Its provisions are largely similar to those found under US copyright law.

However, it is important to note that copyright law is territorial, and the enforcement of copyright infringements can vary widely between countries. While most countries offer protection to foreign works through international treaties, the ability to enforce copyright infringements in the form of damages can be challenging, as some countries may have weaker enforcement mechanisms or lack official copyright registration systems.

Therefore, if you plan to seek protection for your work in another country, it is advisable to understand the copyright laws of that country and consult with an attorney versed in its legal system before publishing your work.

Original works and copyright eligibility

Copyright laws vary from country to country, and there is no international copyright that automatically protects an individual's work worldwide. Original works of authorship that are eligible for copyright are protected automatically under national copyright law in some countries, such as the United States. However, this automatic protection may not extend to other countries with different copyright laws and norms.

To determine if a work is eligible for copyright protection, it must meet certain criteria. Firstly, it must be original, meaning it is independently created by a human author and has a minimal degree of creativity. The threshold for creativity is low, and even a slight amount will suffice. For example, the Supreme Court has held that a work must have a "spark" and "modicum" of creativity. However, certain things are not considered creative, such as titles, names, short phrases, and slogans.

Secondly, the work must be fixed in a tangible medium of expression, such as being written down, recorded, or sculpted. This means that it is captured in a sufficiently permanent form that can be perceived, reproduced, or communicated for more than a short time.

Thirdly, the work must fall under the category of authorship, which includes literary, musical, pictorial, graphic, sculptural, audiovisual, and sound recordings, as well as many other types of creative works.

It is important to note that copyright laws are territorial, and each country has its own unique copyright laws. The copyright held in one country may not be valid in another. Therefore, it is advisable to consult an attorney versed in the laws of a particular country before seeking protection for your work there.

The Berne Convention

The convention also enforces a requirement that countries recognise the rights held by the citizens of all other parties to the convention. This is known as the principle of "rule of the shorter term". Under this rule, if a work is protected for a shorter term in the country of its origin, that shorter term will apply in all countries party to the convention.

International copyright law and U.S. law

International copyright law is not based on statutes but on treaties. There is no such thing as an international copyright that will automatically protect the work of an individual author worldwide. Therefore, to determine the protection a work has in a particular country, one must consider the national laws of that country.

The United States is a signatory to several International Copyright Treaties and Conventions, including the Berne Convention, the WIPO Copyright Treaty, and the WIPO Performances and Phonograms Treaty. U.S. law follows the requirements of these treaties, and in judicial proceedings, the local law of the jurisdiction is applied, as the jurisdiction's statutes are presumably in compliance with the treaties' requirements.

The Berne Convention of 1971 is the main copyright treaty designed to protect literary and artistic works. Its provisions are largely the same as those found under U.S. copyright law. The WIPO Copyright Treaty provides additional protection for distribution rights and the right to control rentals of computer programs, cinematographic works, and phonograms. WIPO also makes similar restrictions to those in the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), which generally restricts parties from circumventing digital copyright protections.

The WIPO Performances and Phonograms Treaty was designed to create uniformity in the protection of intellectual property. It ensures that no member country provides better protection to its own nationals than to foreigners seeking protection within the state. It also ensures that any protection granted to the nationals of one state is granted to all foreign nationals.

There are some key differences between U.S. and international copyright laws. Countries other than the U.S. recognize the protection of an author's moral rights, which include the author's parental and dignitary rights, associated with the author's right to control what others do to their works or how their name is used. To ensure compliance with international treaties, the U.S. added Section 106A to the Copyright Act, but its scope is arguably narrower than the moral rights protected in other countries. The fair use defense to copyright infringement under U.S. copyright law is also much broader than international fair use provisions.

Frequently asked questions