Private Islands: Legal Freedom Or Lawless Lands?

Owning a private island is a dream for many, but it comes with a set of legal considerations. While purchasing an island means owning the land, it does not equate to owning a newly-created government. Every piece of land in the world falls under the jurisdiction of a country and its laws, implying that private islands are subject to the laws of the country they are bought from. This means that the owner cannot create their own laws or secede from the country, unless they can raise an army or gain recognition from a larger power as a sovereign nation.

Private islands are subject to the laws of the country they are bought from

Owning a private island is a dream for many, but it's not as simple as just buying the land. While purchasing a private island means you own the land, it does not mean you own a newly created government. Private islands are subject to the laws of the country they are bought from.

Every piece of land in the world has been claimed and added to a country's jurisdiction, which means that choosing an island should also depend on the country the owner wouldn't mind being subject to. This means that the island in question would follow the same laws as set by the country that owns it, and no additional laws, rules, or guidelines can be set by the owner of the private island.

For example, if you buy an island off the coast of the United States, it will still be subject to US laws and regulations. You would need to abide by US building codes, zoning laws, and environmental regulations. You would also need to pay taxes on the island, as you would for any other property.

There are some exceptions to this, such as the Principality of Sealand, an abandoned British fort in the North Sea that was outside of Britain's territorial waters. However, these cases are rare and often not recognised by other nations.

In addition to legal considerations, there are also practical challenges to owning a private island. Accessing the island can be difficult and expensive, and you would be responsible for providing your own infrastructure such as plumbing, electricity, and fresh water.

Overall, while owning a private island can be a tempting prospect, it's important to remember that it comes with the same laws and regulations as any other piece of real estate.

Private island owners cannot make their own laws

Private island ownership is an appealing prospect for many, but it does not equate to owning a personal kingdom where one can make their own laws. While owning a private island may offer a sense of autonomy, it is crucial to understand that every piece of land in the world falls under the jurisdiction of a country, and private islands are no exception.

When purchasing a private island, it is essential to recognise that the island is governed by the laws of the country from which it was bought. The notion of creating one's own country on a private island, while tempting, is not a realistic option. Any attempt to secede from the original country and establish sovereignty is met with significant challenges and is rarely successful.

Private island owners must abide by the laws and regulations of the country that has jurisdiction over the island. This includes complying with building codes, zoning laws, environmental regulations, and other legal frameworks. While owners can establish rules and impose fines for violations, they do not have the authority to enact laws or enforce punishments beyond what is permitted by the governing country.

Additionally, private islands often come with existing residents, further complicating the matter. In such cases, the owner does not have absolute power over the entire island, as the residents retain their rights to the land they occupy. The concept of owning a private island does not equate to owning a newly created government. It is essential to understand that private island ownership does not grant the power to make and enforce one's own laws.

Furthermore, the example of the "Republic of Minerva" illustrates the challenges of attempting to establish sovereignty over a private island. Michael Oliver, an American real estate mogul, tried to create an artificial island near Tonga and declare independence. However, his efforts were swiftly thwarted by the Tongan government, demonstrating the limitations of private island ownership and the authority of existing nations over such territories.

Private islands are not sovereign nations

Every piece of land in the world has been claimed and added to a country's jurisdiction, and private islands are no exception. This means that a private island will follow the same laws as set by the country that owns it, and the owner cannot set their own laws or guidelines.

For example, the private island of Lanai, one of Hawaii's smallest islands, is mostly owned by Larry Ellison, who purchased it for roughly $300 million. However, a sliver of the island is still owned by the state of Hawaii, meaning Ellison's purchase was not reflective of the total price for every piece of Lanai land.

Another example is Swains Island in the Tokelau archipelago, which has been owned by the family of Eli Hutchinson Jennings since 1856. In the 1950s, after a labour dispute between the Jennings family and workers on its copra plantation, a form of local government was established for the island, but the Jennings family's ownership of the entire island was affirmed.

In rare cases, a private island may be outside of a country's territorial waters, like the "Principality of Sealand," established on abandoned British forts in the North Sea. However, even in these cases, the island may not be recognised as a sovereign nation by other countries.

Private island owners must pay taxes

Private island ownership is an alluring opportunity that not many people in the world commit to, and many believe only celebrities can afford it. The process of buying a private island is similar to buying any other real estate, but there are additional considerations like accessibility and utilities.

Taxation

Private islands are subject to taxation, as they are usually under the ownership of a sovereign country. The amount of tax and the type of payments depend on the location of the island and the country it technically belongs to. For example, the US has a strict and rigid tax system, while other countries may require different payments at varying intervals.

Other Considerations

It is important to note that owning an island does not equate to owning a newly-created government. All land in the world, except for North Sentinel Island, is claimed and governed by a country, meaning the island will follow the laws of that country. Therefore, the owner cannot set their own laws, rules, or guidelines.

Additionally, before any construction on the island, an environmental survey must be conducted, which can cost around $50,000. Building permits may also depend on the size of the land, and if there is too little land, a permit or survey may not be possible, preventing any construction.

In conclusion, while owning a private island may be a dream for many, it comes with certain responsibilities, including tax obligations, adherence to existing laws, and considerations regarding construction and development.

Private island owners may need to abide by environmental regulations

Private islands are subject to the laws of the country they are located in. This means that private island owners cannot make up their own laws and must abide by the laws of the country that owns the island. This includes environmental regulations.

Before any construction on a private island, an environmental survey must be conducted, which can cost upwards of $50,000. This survey will identify any potential ecological concerns, as many islands have fragile environments. The results of this survey may impact what can be built on the island and where.

In addition to the environmental survey, private island owners must also comply with state and federal environmental regulations. These regulations can impose limitations on water and sewage systems, solid waste disposal, electricity generation, hydrocarbon storage, and the protection of endangered species and habitats. Compliance with these regulations is crucial to ensuring the sustainable development of the island.

Furthermore, the laws of the country in which the island is located will also dictate the ownership structure of the island. In some cases, the government may own a portion of the island, such as the foreshore or beaches, making it publicly accessible despite the private ownership of the land. This can impact the development and usage of the island, especially if there is a right to roam.

Overall, while owning a private island can provide substantial control over the property, owners must still abide by the environmental regulations and laws of the governing country. These regulations are in place to protect the natural environment and ensure the responsible development and use of the island.

Frequently asked questions