Right-To-Work Laws: How Do They Affect Boeing Employees?

Right-to-work laws in the United States give employees the freedom to choose whether or not to join a labor union and pay union dues. While these laws give workers more choice, critics argue that they weaken unions and empower employers. As of 2024, 26 US states have right-to-work laws, and Boeing employees in South Carolina have received free legal aid from the National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation. Boeing has a Code of Basic Working Conditions and Human Rights that includes a commitment to complying with laws pertaining to freedom of association, privacy, and collective bargaining.

Boeing's commitment to human rights and working conditions

Boeing is committed to the protection and advancement of human rights and working conditions in its worldwide operations. The company has developed a Code of Basic Working Conditions and Human Rights that outlines its commitment to fundamental standards that make Boeing a good place to work. This code is derived from policies and practices that Boeing already has in place, as well as working standards and human rights concepts advanced by other groups, such as the International Labor Organization, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and the Global Sullivan Principles.

Boeing's Code of Conduct is provided in 18 languages and outlines the company's commitment to safety, quality, integrity, and transparency. Every year, Boeing employees reaffirm their commitment to ethical behaviour and respecting one another by reading and signing this code. The company also provides a company-wide training called Recommitment, which features real-life examples of compliance issues and consequences. Boeing encourages employees to promptly raise concerns about safety, quality, potential violations of the law, or Boeing policy, and offers several options for doing so confidentially. The company also has a zero-tolerance policy for retaliation against employees who speak up.

In addition, Boeing is dedicated to promoting a diverse and inclusive workplace. The company recognises that having diverse employees, business partners, and community relationships is vital to creating advanced aerospace products and services for its diverse customers around the world. Boeing also prioritises employee safety with its workplace safety program, Go for Zero – One Day at a Time, which aims to eliminate all workplace injuries and ensure a safe environment for all employees.

Right-to-work laws and union membership

Right-to-work laws refer to state laws that prohibit union security agreements between employers and labour unions. In other words, these laws guarantee an employee's right to refrain from being a member of a labour union. Twenty-eight states in the US have right-to-work policies, and these laws also apply to all public-sector unions.

Right-to-work laws mean that union members do not have to pay union dues to be members of the union. In states with these laws, employees can receive the benefits of the union contract without having to pay union dues and fees. Workers can join a union if they wish, but employers cannot force them to do so as a term or condition of employment.

In states without right-to-work laws, workers covered by a union contract can refuse to join the union and then pay the associated fees. In contrast, states with right-to-work laws require union contracts to cover all workers, not just union members.

The National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation has offered free legal assistance to Boeing employees in South Carolina, for example, to help them keep their jobs. This was in response to the potential closing of the Charleston Dreamliner facility and moving production back to Washington State due to demands of IAM union bosses.

Right-to-work laws are derived from legislation forbidding unions from forcing strikes on workers and legal principles such as freedom of contract. Opponents of these laws argue that they enable workers to be "freeloaders", enjoying the benefits of union membership without paying any costs.

The impact of right-to-work laws on union power

Right-to-work laws have a significant impact on union power. These laws prohibit union security agreements between employers and labor unions, allowing employees to refrain from being members of a labor union. While proponents of such laws argue that they protect workers' freedom of association, critics highlight the negative consequences for unions and the economy.

The introduction of right-to-work laws can create a "free-rider" problem for unions, where members opt out of paying dues, undermining unions' financing and ability to organize workers. This has been observed to result in a decline in unionization rates and wages, particularly in industries with initially high unionization rates, such as construction, education, and public administration. The impact is more pronounced for women and public-sector workers, who are overrepresented in highly unionized industries.

Beyond the direct effects on unionization and wages, right-to-work laws have broader economic implications. Unions are vital to strengthening the middle class and improving the economy. By weakening unions, these laws can lead to reduced income for middle-class households, decreased likelihood of employer-provided health insurance and pensions for workers, and a less efficient structure of power in the workplace.

Furthermore, right-to-work laws can hinder state economic growth. In states that have recently adopted these policies, employment growth and business relocations have reversed their previous expanding trends. This suggests that unions and union membership, rather than right-to-work laws, are conducive to broad economic growth.

In summary, right-to-work laws have a substantial impact on union power by reducing unionization and wages, with subsequent negative consequences for the economy, including reduced income, decreased benefits for workers, and hindered state economic growth.

The effect of right-to-work laws on employment and wages

Right-to-work laws allow employees to opt out of joining a labour union and paying union dues. While the laws imply that they provide freedom to workers, critics argue that they weaken unions and empower corporations.

Research shows that states with right-to-work laws experience higher employment rates but lower wages for workers. A study by economists at MIT, Stanford, and the U.S. Census Bureau found that right-to-work laws boost incentive management practices. Another study found that right-to-work laws lead to greater economic inequality by reducing the power of labour unions.

In the five states that adopted right-to-work laws between 2011 and 2017, unionization and wages declined, particularly in construction, education, and public administration. The impact was more pronounced for women and public-sector workers, who are overrepresented in highly unionized industries.

Proponents of right-to-work laws argue that workers should not be forced to join a union if they are not interested. They also believe that these laws attract more businesses to a state, as companies prefer a stable environment without the threat of labour strikes.

Critics of right-to-work laws argue that they encourage free riders, increasing the cost of operating a union. They also claim that businesses will lower safety standards and exacerbate economic inequality if given the choice to do without unions.

Legal protections for Boeing employees

The Boeing Company has developed a Code of Basic Working Conditions and Human Rights that outlines the company's commitment to protecting and advancing human rights in its worldwide operations. This code includes protections for employees against discrimination and harassment, a commitment to providing a safe and healthy work environment, and promoting a workplace that fosters communication, productivity, and creativity.

Boeing also has a Global Compliance organization that works to ensure the company's compliance with applicable global laws and regulations, as well as its own internal policies and procedures. The company provides training to employees on compliance risk areas and encourages a culture of ethical behaviour and transparency.

In addition, Boeing has a whistleblower program, the 'Speak Up' policy, which allows employees to raise concerns about safety, quality, potential violations of the law, or company policy. While there have been reports of retaliation against whistleblowers, Boeing denies these claims and takes action against violators of anti-retaliation policies.

The company also has a Supplier Code of Conduct that outlines expectations for its suppliers, including a commitment to the highest standards of ethical and business conduct.

Boeing employees are also protected by various federal laws and regulations enforced by the U.S. Department of Labor, including the Fair Labor Standards Act, the Occupational Safety and Health Act, and the Family and Medical Leave Act, among others.

Frequently asked questions