Delaware Corporation Law: California Compliance And Considerations

The Delaware General Corporation Law (DGCL) is a statute of the Delaware Code that governs corporate law in the U.S. state of Delaware. It is considered a corporate haven due to its business-friendly laws compared to most other U.S. states. However, the DGCL only applies to the internal affairs of corporations, such as the relationship between stockholders and directors or officers. So, does the DGCL apply to corporations operating in California?

California-incorporated companies vs. Delaware-incorporated companies

When deciding where to incorporate a business, there are several factors to consider, including the costs of incorporation, corporate laws, and tax requirements. While it may be tempting to incorporate in the state where your business is physically located, there are advantages and disadvantages to both California and Delaware incorporation that should be considered.

Costs of Incorporation

Incorporating in California has a higher initial filing fee of $145 compared to Delaware's $98. Additionally, California imposes a relatively high annual franchise tax with a minimum of $800, while Delaware's franchise tax depends on the total number of authorized shares of capital stock. For example, a company with 1 million authorized shares would pay $400 annually in Delaware. However, if a Delaware corporation is conducting business in California, it must qualify to do business in California and pay the minimum franchise tax of $800.

Corporate Laws

California and Delaware have different corporate laws that can impact the protection of board members, shareholders, and investors. Delaware's corporate laws, such as the Delaware General Corporation Law (DGCL), are well-known for being pro-business, modern, and flexible. Delaware courts have a reputation for offering strong protection to board members against shareholder lawsuits and providing limited protection against hostile takeovers. In contrast, California offers more protection to minority shareholders and has more unpredictable court decisions.

Delaware's Chancery Court, a leading business law court, specializes in hearing only Delaware business entity cases, contributing to more predictable legal outcomes. Delaware's Secretary of State's office is also known for its efficiency and user-friendliness in processing filings.

On the other hand, California's Revised Uniform LLC Act (RULLCA) allows California courts to void contracts under the "manifestly unreasonable" standard, giving them broad discretion. In contrast, the Delaware LLC Act does not have this exception and must respect the Operating Agreement under all circumstances.

When it comes to corporate changes like mergers, acquisitions, or IPOs, California requires the majority of each class of stock to effect a change, while Delaware law allows all classes to vote together. This makes Delaware the preferred choice for investors as it prevents a single class from blocking exit options.

Tax Requirements

Delaware has a reputation for being a tax haven. It does not have a sales tax or an intangible personal property tax, and businesses do not have to pay income tax or file a business license if they do not operate in the state. In contrast, California imposes higher franchise taxes and does not offer the same tax advantages as Delaware.

In conclusion, the decision to incorporate in California or Delaware depends on various factors, including the size and nature of the business, tax considerations, and the level of protection desired by the owners and investors. Delaware is often the preferred choice for larger companies and those seeking venture financing due to its business-friendly laws and predictable legal outcomes. However, California may be a more convenient and cost-effective option for startups or smaller companies, especially if they do not plan to seek venture financing in the near future.

California's corporate tax laws vs. Delaware's corporate tax laws

California and Delaware have distinct differences in their corporate laws, taxes and fees, privacy protections, and business environments.

Corporate Laws and Legal System

Delaware has a well-established and flexible body of corporate law, which is considered the gold standard in US corporate law. The state's highly respected Court of Chancery, which does not use juries, focuses exclusively on business disputes, providing a streamlined and predictable legal process for corporations.

California also has a robust body of corporate law, but it is generally viewed as more protective of employees and shareholders than Delaware law. California does not have a specialized business court, which could lead to longer and less predictable litigation processes.

Taxes and Fees

In California, all corporations are subject to a minimum franchise tax of $800 per year, regardless of income or activity level. If a corporation is based in California, it will also be subject to state corporate income tax.

Delaware, on the other hand, does not impose income taxes on corporations based in other states or countries. If a business incorporates in Delaware but doesn't do business there, it is not subject to state corporate income tax (although there is a mandatory franchise tax, ranging from $175 to $200,000 per year, depending on the type and size of the corporation). However, a Delaware corporation conducting intrastate business in California must file a statement of qualification in California and pay the minimum franchise tax of $800.

Privacy Protections

Delaware provides greater privacy protections to corporations as it does not require businesses to list officer or director names in the formation documents. This level of privacy is not available in all states, including California, which requires corporations to disclose the names of directors and officers in their annual Statement of Information.

Business Environment

California is known for its vibrant entrepreneurial environment, particularly in Silicon Valley and the San Francisco Bay Area, which are hubs of venture capital, innovation, and entrepreneurship. California also has strong laws in place to protect minority shareholders from unfair treatment.

Delaware, on the other hand, is favored by large corporations due to its historically better franchise tax rules and stronger protection for board members against derivative suits. Delaware law also offers limited statutory protection against hostile takeovers and provides greater flexibility to corporate governance and efficiency for business filings.

In summary, both states offer advantages for corporations, but the choice between incorporating in California or Delaware depends on the specific needs, future plans, investor requirements, and other factors unique to each business.

California's corporate disclosure laws vs. Delaware's corporate disclosure laws

California and Delaware have distinct corporate disclosure laws, which apply to corporations registered in their respective states.

California's Corporate Disclosure Laws:

California requires corporations to disclose specific information to the Secretary of State, including details about their officers, directors, and business operations within the state. This involves filing a statement every two years, known as the "Publicly Traded Corporate Disclosure Statement." This statement includes information such as the names and addresses of the corporation's CEO, secretary, CFO, and directors, as well as the addresses of its principal executive and business offices in California. Additionally, domestic corporations must disclose the number of vacancies on their board.

For publicly traded corporations, California's disclosure requirements go beyond federal securities laws. The California Corporate Disclosure Act mandates additional disclosures, including information about the corporation's independent auditor, audit report, compensation of directors and top executives, preferential loans to directors, bankruptcy filings, fraud convictions, and violations of securities or banking laws.

Delaware's Corporate Disclosure Laws:

Delaware's corporate law, on the other hand, is known for its flexibility and focus on internal corporate affairs. It does not address certain aspects of business law, such as competition law, labor law, or securities disclosure law. However, Delaware does require corporations to disclose certain information, such as the names and addresses of directors, which are included in the annual franchise tax report.

While Delaware generally requires less disclosure compared to California, it is important to note that federal laws, such as the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA), still apply to Delaware corporations. The CTA mandates the disclosure of beneficial owners and individuals with substantial control over the company, regardless of the state of formation.

In summary, California's corporate disclosure laws focus on transparency and public access to information, while Delaware's laws prioritize flexibility and the protection of internal corporate affairs. California requires more frequent and detailed disclosures, especially for publicly traded corporations, whereas Delaware's disclosure requirements are more limited in scope and frequency.

California's corporate governance laws vs. Delaware's corporate governance laws

California and Delaware have distinct approaches to corporate governance laws, and understanding these differences is crucial for businesses operating in these states or considering expansion.

Delaware Corporate Governance Laws:

Delaware's General Corporation Law (DGCL) is the foundation of its business-friendly environment. The DGCL offers flexibility and efficiency in corporate governance, attracting numerous businesses, including a significant number of Fortune 500 companies. Here are some key aspects of Delaware's corporate governance laws:

• Lax Corporate Taxes: Delaware's approach to corporate taxes is a significant draw. Corporations that do not operate in Delaware are exempt from paying income taxes to the state, unlike many other states.
• Flexible Governance: The DGCL provides maximum flexibility for stockholders and corporations in managing their affairs. It is designed as an enabling statute, allowing company-specific procedures and minimal mandatory provisions.
• Stable and Predictable: Delaware's constitution requires a super-majority vote to amend the corporation law, resulting in stability and predictability valued by managers and investors. Amendments are carefully considered, ensuring the law remains current and responsive to the needs of Delaware corporations.
• Specialized Court System: Delaware's Court of Chancery, comprising one Chancellor and six Vice-Chancellors, specializes in business disputes. This court's expertise ensures expedient handling of cases and greater predictability of outcomes.
• Limited Disclosure: Delaware corporate law provides greater anonymity by not requiring public disclosure of directors' or officers' names and contact information. However, the US Corporate Transparency Act (CTA) now requires all US companies to disclose beneficial owner information, including Delaware corporations.
• Internal Affairs Doctrine: Under this doctrine, Delaware law governs the internal affairs of Delaware corporations, even if they operate in other states. This includes the relationship between stockholders, directors, and officers, ensuring consistent compliance regardless of physical headquarters.
• Flexible Board Structure: A Delaware corporation can have a single director, regardless of the number of stockholders. This differs from California, where the number of directors is tied to the number of stockholders.
• Director Transaction Approval: Delaware law allows a board to approve transactions in which directors or officers have a personal interest, provided certain conditions are met, including disclosure and fair approval.
• Stockholder Rights: The DGCL sets out stockholder rights, including notice requirements for meetings, the ability to take action by written consent, and voting procedures. Delaware does not mandate cumulative voting for director elections, unlike California and some other jurisdictions.

California Corporate Governance Laws:

California's corporate governance laws differ from Delaware's in several ways, and it is important for businesses to understand these distinctions:

• Disclosure Requirements: California requires corporations to file a statement of information listing their officers and directors, which is publicly accessible. This contrasts with Delaware's limited disclosure requirements.
• Emergency Flexibility: California's Corporations Code provides some flexibility during states of emergency, allowing corporations to modify lines of succession, relocate offices, and adjust board meeting procedures. However, shareholder approval requirements remain in place during emergencies.
• Cumulative Voting: California mandates cumulative voting for director elections, giving minority shareholders a stronger voice. Delaware, on the other hand, does not require cumulative voting.
• Compliance with Multiple Jurisdictions: Companies operating in California and incorporated elsewhere, such as in Delaware, must navigate the requirements of both states. While internal affairs fall under the incorporated state's jurisdiction, employment law and other regulations vary by the state of operation.
• Bylaws and Articles of Incorporation: California allows bylaws to contain provisions for managing ordinary business affairs during emergencies, as long as they don't conflict with the articles of incorporation.
• Board Meeting Notices: During emergencies, California corporations may provide board meeting notices in any practicable manner if the usual methods are unavailable. This flexibility ensures that meetings can take place even under challenging circumstances.

California's corporate compliance regime vs. Delaware's corporate compliance regime

California and Delaware have distinct corporate compliance regimes, which differ in several key aspects. Here is a comparison of the two:

California's Corporate Compliance Regime:

California's corporate compliance regime is governed by the California Secretary of State and imposes several requirements on businesses operating within the state. Some key features include:

• Business Registration and Licensing: Businesses must register and form their entities online through the California Secretary of State's portal. This includes corporations, limited liability companies, limited partnerships, and general partnerships.
• Annual and Biennial Requirements: California businesses must meet specific annual or biennial requirements, such as filing a Statement of Information. The frequency of these filings depends on the type of entity and jurisdiction of formation.
• Agent for Service of Process: California requires the designation of an agent for service of process, who is responsible for accepting legal documents if the business is sued. This agent must be an individual residing in California or a registered corporate agent.
• Compliance with Labor Laws: California has strict labor laws, and businesses must disclose any outstanding judgments related to violations of wage orders or labor code provisions. This information is included in the Statement of Information.
• Tax Requirements: Most businesses in California must pay a minimum franchise tax of $800 annually. There are also various other tax obligations that businesses must adhere to.
• Climate Accountability: California has recently adopted the Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act (CCDAA) and the Climate-Related Financial Risk Act (CRFRA), which require companies with specific revenue thresholds to publicly report their greenhouse gas emissions and disclose climate-related financial risks.

Delaware's Corporate Compliance Regime:

Delaware's corporate compliance regime is known for its business-friendly environment and has attracted many companies, including a significant portion of Fortune 500 companies. Some key features include:

• Lax Corporate Taxes: Delaware has a lax approach to corporate taxes. Companies that are incorporated in Delaware but do not operate in the state are not subject to Delaware income taxes.
• Flexible Corporate Governance: Delaware provides greater flexibility in corporate governance. For example, it allows for a single director regardless of the number of stockholders, while California requires a certain number of directors based on the number of stockholders.
• Court of Chancery: Delaware has a unique Court of Chancery, which specializes in handling business disputes. This court does not use juries, and cases are decided by a Chancellor with expertise in business disputes, leading to expedient and predictable outcomes.
• Limited Disclosure Thresholds: Delaware corporate law provides greater anonymity for corporations as it does not require the public disclosure of directors' or officers' names and contact information.
• Annual Maintenance Requirements: Delaware imposes only two annual maintenance requirements: paying franchise taxes and maintaining a registered agent. Failure to comply can result in penalties and possible administrative dissolution of the company.
• Initial Costs and Efficiency: Delaware offers low initial costs for forming a corporation, and businesses can take advantage of expedited filing processes, making it attractive to venture capitalists.

In summary, California's corporate compliance regime focuses on transparency and accountability, especially in areas like labor laws and climate disclosures. On the other hand, Delaware's regime emphasizes flexibility, efficiency, and limited disclosure, making it attractive to businesses seeking a stable and predictable legal environment.

Frequently asked questions