Fusion And The Law Of Conservation Of Energy: Friend Or Foe?

Nuclear fusion reactions appear to violate the Law of Conservation of Energy as mass is converted into energy. However, according to Einstein's equation E=mc^2, the total energy (mass + energy) before and after the fusion remains constant, thus conserving energy. This means that nuclear fusion does not violate the Law of Conservation of Energy.

Nuclear fusion and mass-energy equivalence

Nuclear fusion reactions appear to violate the Law of Conservation of Energy, as some of the mass involved is converted into energy. However, this is not the case when the concept of mass-energy equivalence is considered. This concept, which emerges from Einstein's Theory of Relativity, means that mass and energy are interchangeable, and the law is upheld as long as there is no net loss between the two.

The mass-energy equivalence is derived from Einstein's famous equation, E=mc^2, where E is energy, m is mass, and c is the speed of light. This equation demonstrates that mass can be converted into energy and vice versa, without violating the Law of Conservation of Energy.

In nuclear fusion, the mass of the resulting atom is less than the sum of the masses of the original atoms. The "missing" mass is converted into energy, meaning that the total energy (mass + energy) before and after the fusion remains constant, thus conserving energy.

For example, the energy emitted by the sun is due to the collision of hydrogen nuclei and the formation of helium nuclei. While this process may seem to violate the Law of Conservation of Mass, when mass-energy equivalence is considered, the law is upheld. The "missing" mass is simply converted into energy, as described by Einstein's equation.

Therefore, nuclear fusion and mass-energy equivalence are closely related. Nuclear fusion provides a practical example of how mass-energy equivalence operates, demonstrating that mass can be converted into energy without violating the fundamental laws of physics.

Einstein's equation: E=mc^2

Nuclear fusion does not violate the law of conservation of energy. In nuclear fusion, the mass of the resulting atom is less than the sum of the masses of the original atoms. This "missing" mass is converted into energy according to Einstein's equation:

> E=mc^2

Where:

• E is energy
• M is mass
• C is the speed of light

This equation shows that energy and mass (matter) are interchangeable and are different forms of the same thing. The total energy (mass + energy) before and after the fusion remains constant, thus conserving energy.

The History of E=mc^2

Einstein was the first to propose the equivalence of mass and energy as a general principle, and his equation first appeared in one of his annus mirabilis papers, published on 21 November 1905. The formula and its relationship to momentum were later developed by other physicists.

Prior to Einstein's theory of special relativity, mass and energy were viewed as distinct entities, and the energy of a body at rest could be assigned an arbitrary value. In special relativity, the energy of a body at rest is determined to be mc^2. Thus, each body possesses mc^2 of "rest energy", which can be converted to other forms of energy.

Applications of E=mc^2

The mass-energy equivalence principle is fundamental to many fields of physics, including nuclear and particle physics. It is also used in the modelling of nuclear fission reactions and implies that a great amount of energy can be released by nuclear fission chain reactions.

Law of Conservation of Mass

The Law of Conservation of Mass, discovered by Antoine Lavoisier in 1789, states that the mass of a closed system remains constant over time. In other words, mass can neither be created nor destroyed, only changed from one form to another. This means that the mass of an element at the beginning of a reaction will equal the mass of that element at the end of the reaction.

For example, in the chemical reaction where one molecule of methane (CH4) and two oxygen molecules (O2) are converted into one molecule of carbon dioxide (CO2) and two of water (H2O), the total mass of the products is equal to the total mass of the reactants. This is because the number of molecules resulting from the reaction can be derived from the principle of conservation of mass: as there are initially four hydrogen atoms, four oxygen atoms, and one carbon atom, the number of water molecules produced must be exactly two per molecule of carbon dioxide produced.

The Law of Conservation of Mass is of great importance in progressing from alchemy to modern chemistry. Once early chemists realised that chemical substances were only transformed into other substances with the same total mass, they could embark on quantitative studies of these transformations.

However, nuclear fusion reactions do appear to violate the Law of Conservation of Mass. This is because certain parts of mass are converted into energy, and so the total mass of the products is not equal to the total mass of the reactants. Nevertheless, the concept of mass-energy equivalence, which emerges as a consequence of Einstein's theory of relativity, means that the Law of Conservation of Mass and the Law of Conservation of Energy are special limiting cases of the Law of Conservation of Mass-Energy. As mass is now considered a form of energy, mass and energy can be converted back and forth as long as there is no net loss between the two.

Total energy (mass + energy) before and after fusion

Nuclear fusion is a reaction in which two or more atomic nuclei combine to form one or more atomic nuclei and neutrons. The mass of the resulting atom is less than the sum of the masses of the original atoms. The "missing" mass is converted into energy according to Einstein's famous equation, E=mc^2, where E is energy, m is mass, and c is the speed of light. This means that the total energy (mass + energy) before and after the fusion remains constant, thus conserving energy.

The energy analysis of a nuclear fusion event involves evaluating the masses before and after it and taking the difference. The decrease in mass used in the Einstein relationship represents the energy yield Q. For example, using deuterium fusion with a neutron yield, the units GeV/c^2 represent the masses of the constituents. The reaction becomes:

2 x 1.8756 GeV/c^2 -> 2.8084 GeV/c^2 + 0.9396 GeV/c^2 + 0.00327 GeV/c^2

The difference in mass expressed in energy units represents the energy yield Q of the nuclear fusion reaction, which in this case is Q = 3.27 MeV. While the energy yield is very small compared to the masses of the nuclei involved in the fusion, it is nevertheless a very large energy yield.

Nuclear fusion reactions can be exothermic or endothermic. A nuclear fusion process that produces atomic nuclei lighter than iron-56 or nickel-62 will generally release energy and is thus exothermic. The fusion of nuclei lighter than these releases energy, while the fusion of heavier nuclei results in energy retained by the product nucleons, and the resulting reaction is endothermic.

The total energy (mass + energy) before and after a nuclear fusion reaction remains constant, thus conserving energy. This is because the "missing" mass, which is the difference in mass between the reactants and products, is converted into energy. This means that nuclear fusion does not violate the law of conservation of energy.

Nuclear fusion and the violation of the Law of Conservation of Energy

Nuclear fusion does not violate the law of conservation of energy. In nuclear fusion, the mass of the resulting atom is less than the sum of the masses of the original atoms. The "missing" mass is converted into energy according to Einstein's equation, E=mc^2, where E is energy, m is mass, and c is the speed of light. This means that the total energy (mass + energy) before and after the fusion remains constant, thus conserving energy.

For example, the energy that the sun emits is due to the collision of hydrogen nuclei and the formation of helium nuclei. In this process, a certain part of the mass is converted into energy. According to the law of conservation of mass, during any physical or chemical changes, the total mass of the products should be equal to the total mass of the reactants. However, in nuclear fusion, the conservation of mass is not obeyed due to the conversion of mass into energy.

To address this apparent contradiction, the law of conservation of mass can be redefined to account for the conversion of mass into energy. The modified law would state that during any physical or chemical change, the total mass of the products is equal to the total mass of the reactants, provided that mass has not been converted into energy. This ensures that the total energy, including the mass and energy components, remains constant.

The concept of mass-energy equivalence, as described by Einstein's General Theory of Relativity, unifies the laws of conservation of mass and energy. According to this theory, mass and energy are interchangeable, and the law of conservation of mass-energy states that there should be no net loss between the two. In other words, mass can be converted into energy and vice versa, as long as the total amount remains the same.

In summary, while nuclear fusion may seem to violate the law of conservation of energy at first glance, a closer examination reveals that it does not. The "missing" mass is simply converted into energy, and the total energy before and after the fusion process remains constant, thus upholding the law of conservation of energy.

Frequently asked questions