Indian Law: For Hindus Or All?

does indian law only acknowledge hindus

The Indian Constitution guarantees freedom of religion as a fundamental right, and India is officially a secular state. However, the term Hindu law has been used historically to refer to the code of laws applied to Hindus, Buddhists, Jains, and Sikhs in British India, and the Indian legal system has a history of religious segregation. While the Indian Constitution prohibits discrimination based on religion, it also provides for special rights for religious minorities, leading to a complex relationship between the Hindu majority and other religious groups, particularly Muslims.

lawshun

Definition of 'Hindu' in Indian law

The term "Hindu law" emerged during colonial rule in South Asia when British colonial officials decided, in consultation with Mughal rulers, that a European common law system would not be implemented in India. Instead, Hindus in India would be governed by "Hindu law", and Muslims by Sharia law. This decision led to the construction and implementation of Hindu law as a blend of customary and legislative law.

In modern scholarship, Hindu law refers to the legal theory, jurisprudence, and philosophical reflections found in ancient and medieval Indian texts. It is one of the oldest known jurisprudence theories, dating back three thousand years, and is based on Hindu religious texts. The ancient Indian term for law in these texts is "Dharma", which signifies behaviours considered in accord with "rta", the order that makes life and the universe possible. Dharma encompasses duties, rights, laws, conduct, virtues, and the 'right way of living'.

The definition of a Hindu under Indian law is addressed in the Hindu Marriage Act of 1955, which provides a provisional definition. According to Section 2(1)(a) of this Act, a Hindu is a person who follows Virashaiva, Lingayat, or believes in Brahmo, Prarthana, or Arya Samaj. Section 2(1)(b) includes Buddhists, Sikhs, and Jains within the definition of Hindus. Furthermore, the Act specifies that anyone who is not a Muslim, Parsi, Christian, or Jew is considered a Hindu. Similar definitions are provided in other legislative acts, including the Hindu Succession Act of 1956, the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act of 1956, and the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act of 1956.

The Indian Constitution also provides a legal clause defining who is considered a Hindu, mentioned under Article 25 (2)(b), Explanation II. Additionally, the Indian legal system includes general laws that apply universally to all individuals, regardless of their religious affiliation.

lawshun

Religious tolerance in India

India has a long history of religious tolerance and a culture of acceptance. The country is home to almost all major religions, with a diverse range of cultures co-existing in relative harmony. This composite nature of Indian society is a direct result of the Indian way of thinking, which values pluralism and the idea that "the manyness of reality" as Mahatma Gandhi, one of India's greatest leaders, famously stated.

The Hindu religion, which forms the majority in India, is based on the concept of monism, or advait vad, which means that the divine reality is one, but manifested in different ways. This belief in the fundamental unity of the divine accords equal positions to all human beings, fostering an environment of tolerance and mutual respect. The Bhagavad Gita, one of Hinduism's holy books, maintains that all paths lead to the same summit, further reinforcing the idea of religious tolerance.

Historically, India has been a welcoming place for different religions and cultures. For example, the Sufis, who came from Central Asia, settled in various Indian cities and peacefully spread the message of Islam. They converted large numbers of Hindus to Islam, and this process was accepted without objection. This spirit of tolerance was also advocated by revered religious leaders like Swami Vivekananda, who believed in Hindu-Muslim unity and saw the future of India as a harmonious blend of Vedanta (Hindu philosophy) and Islam.

However, despite this long-standing tradition of tolerance, there have been reports of religious intolerance and violence. In 2007, the All India Catholic Union reported 190 attacks on Christians, including homicides, armed assaults, sexual harassment, and lynchings. These attacks occurred even during private worship within homes and churches. Such incidents highlight the need for continued vigilance and efforts to uphold religious tolerance in India.

The Indian Constitution has attempted to address religious diversity through legal definitions and clauses. For example, it provides a definition of who is considered a Hindu under the Hindu Marriage Act and other legislative statutes. Additionally, it includes provisions like Article 141, which mandates that a verdict passed by the Supreme Court is binding and considered the law of the land, helping to create a uniform legal framework for all citizens regardless of their religious beliefs.

How Patrick Henry Earned His Law License

You may want to see also

lawshun

Religious nationalism in India

The term "Hindu law" emerged when British colonial officials decided, in consultation with Mughal rulers, that European common law would not be implemented in India. Instead, Hindus would be ruled under Hindu law and Muslims under Sharia law. This decision sustained pre-colonial religious and political conflicts well into the nineteenth century.

Hindu law, as a historical term, refers to the code of laws applied to Hindus, Buddhists, Jains, and Sikhs in British India. In modern scholarship, it also refers to the legal theory, jurisprudence, and philosophical reflections found in ancient and medieval Indian texts.

The Indian Constitution has provided a legal definition of who is a Hindu, which is mentioned under Article 25 (2)(b), Explanation II. The Hindu Marriage Act of 1955 also provides a definition:

> "a person is said to be a Hindu by religion who is a follower of Virashaiva, Lingayat, or a believer of Brahmo, Prarthana, or Arya Samaj, whereas [...] persons who are Buddhists, Sikhs and Jains by religion within the purview of Hindus."

Nearly two-thirds of Hindus (64%) say it is very important to be Hindu to be truly Indian. This sentiment is less common among members of other religious groups in India, with 27% of Muslims, 25% of Buddhists, 23% of Muslims, 18% of Sikhs, and 15% of Christians agreeing.

Hindu nationalism in India has a linguistic dimension. A majority of Hindus (59%) feel that being able to speak Hindi is very important to being truly Indian, and about half (51%) say being Hindu and speaking Hindi are both very important. Hindu college graduates are less likely to connect language and religion with national identity.

Hindu nationalism is strongly reflected in political behavior. About half of Hindus who voted in the 2019 election say they voted for the ruling BJP (49%), and support for the BJP is higher among those who say that being Hindu and speaking Hindi are very important to being truly Indian.

The Sangh Parivar's ideology is dubbed Hindutva ("Hinduness"), which is a national-cultural rather than a religious category, seen as synonymous with the idea of India.

lawshun

Freedom of religion in India

Freedom of religion is a fundamental right guaranteed by Article 25–28 of the Constitution of India. The constitution provides for freedom of conscience and the right of all individuals to freely profess, practice, and propagate religion; it also mandates a secular state, requiring the state to treat all religions impartially and prohibits discrimination based on religion. The Indian Constitution also provides a legal clause regarding who is a Hindu, which is mentioned under Article 25 (2)(b), Explanation II.

However, there have been numerous instances of religious intolerance resulting in riots and mob violence. In recent years, the Indian government has been criticised for introducing and enforcing discriminatory legislation that disenfranchises religious minorities. For example, in 2007, Himachal Pradesh became the first Congress Party-ruled state to adopt legislation banning illegal religious conversions. As of 2023, 10 out of 28 states have laws restricting religious conversions for all faiths, with penalties for forced conversions for the purpose of marriage.

Historically, the Sikh Gurus built freedom of religion into their faith, such that even while being a persecuted minority under Mughal rulers, they fought for the religious freedom of others. This tradition continued under the Sikh Empire and other Sikh Principalities, where Sikh rulers commissioned several Gurdwaras, Temples, and Mosques for their subjects of various faiths.

The term "Hindu law" emerged during colonial rule in South Asia, when British colonial officials decided that European common law would not be implemented in India. Instead, Hindus would be ruled under "Hindu law", and Muslims under Sharia (Muslim law). This was based on the interpretation of ancient Indian texts, which refer to the term Dharma, meaning more than a code of law.

lawshun

British colonial influence on Hindu law

The term "Hindu law" emerged during the colonial rule of South Asia. In 1772, British colonial officials decided against implementing a European common law system in India, instead ruling Hindus under "Hindu law" and Muslims under Sharia law. The British attempted to find and extract elements of law from old surviving Sanskrit texts, with Western translators equating "dharma shastra" with a "lawbook, code, or institute".

The East India Company, which began as an agent of the Mughal emperor, soon took on political and administrative powers in India. To maintain stability and expedite trade, the Company relied on local intermediaries, mostly Muslims and some Hindus, to navigate pre-colonial religious and political laws and conflicts. This approach was also taken by the British, who adapted to local law practices to exert power.

The early period of Anglo-Hindu Law (1772-1828) was structured along the lines of Muslim law practice. It involved the use of court pandits to aid British judges in interpreting Shastras, and the creation of institutions like the Calcutta Sanskrit College to train these court pandits. This period also saw the emergence of a criminal code that combined laws derived from Muslim and Hindu texts.

From 1828-1855, a series of British acts of Parliament were passed to revise Anglo-Hindu and Anglo-Muslim laws, addressing issues like religious conversion, widow remarriage, and inheritance. This period also saw the abolishment of religious fatwa as a source of law and the introduction of a universal civil code, emphasizing equal treatment for all.

The second phase of Anglo-Hindu law (1864-1947) saw British colonial courts rely more on written law, with a universal criminal code adopted in 1864 and expanded in 1882, overruling pre-existing Anglo-Hindu laws. While personal laws for Muslims remained Sharia-based, Anglo-Hindu law was enacted independently on matters like marriage, divorce, and inheritance, covering all Hindus, Jains, Sikhs, and Buddhists in India.

The British codification of Hindu law has been criticized as a tool of despotism, expropriating Indian history and culture to serve administrative needs. This process involved significant reinterpretation and modification of traditional laws, often leading to a legal system that reflected British colonial interests rather than indigenous practices.

Frequently asked questions

No. India is a secular state, and its constitution guarantees freedom of religion. The country has a large Muslim population, as well as Sikhs, Christians, Buddhists, Jains, Zoroastrians, Indigenous and Irreligious populations.

During the colonial era, the British attempted to establish a homogeneous legal system. In 1772, British colonial officials decided against implementing a European common law system and instead ruled Hindus under "Hindu law" and Muslims under Sharia law. The term "Hindu law" was a colonial construction that encompassed Buddhists, Sikhs, and Jains as well.

Modern Indian laws that pertain to Hindus include the Hindu Marriage Act of 1955, the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act of 1956, and the Hindu Succession Act of 1956. These laws define who is considered a Hindu and outline rules regarding marriage, adoption, and inheritance.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment