Labor Laws: Do Teachers Have Worker Rights?

Teachers' rights and protections are a complex and varied area of law, with differences between public and private school teachers, and between unionized and non-unionized teachers. Teachers' unions, which have existed for over 150 years in the US, play a critical role in securing benefits and shaping education policy. Teachers' rights are derived from state and federal constitutional provisions, state and federal statutes, and state and federal regulations. While labor laws do apply to teachers, there are some notable exemptions. For example, under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), teachers are exempt from minimum wage and overtime protections if their primary duty is teaching. Additionally, some states prohibit certain types of collective bargaining for teachers, especially in public schools. Despite these exemptions, teachers have a range of rights and protections, including freedom of expression and association, academic freedom, and protection against unreasonable searches and seizures.

Teachers' unions and their role in fighting for educators' rights

Teachers' unions are a type of labor union that has been fighting for the rights of educators for over 150 years in the US. They use collective bargaining agreements (CBAs) to protect their members and secure benefits for teachers.

Over the years, teachers' unions have helped educators gain rights such as fair working conditions, compensation, pay equality, and access to various benefits. They also play a role in shaping education policy, ensuring that educators can fulfill their job duties. For example, the National Education Association (NEA) played a critical role in shifting the focus from federal policies like the No Child Left Behind Act towards alternatives like the Every Student Succeeds Act of 2015.

Teachers' unions also provide protection for teachers against the arbitrary exercise of power by administrators and school boards. They act as a check on administrative power, ensuring that teachers' rights are protected and advocating for sound education policies. This is especially important when administrators are non-educators, as teachers need a voice in the decision-making process for school reform to be successful.

In addition to protecting teachers' rights, teachers' unions also support teacher professionalism. In the past, unions have fought against discriminatory pay practices and unfair dismissal practices, such as teachers being fired for getting married or pregnant. They have also played a role in educating emancipated slaves and native Americans, fighting against child labor laws, and championing women's suffrage.

However, some critics argue that teachers' unions hinder school reform and protect incompetent teachers. There are also concerns that teachers' unions in some states are advocating for controversial platforms in schools, such as gender transition for children and Palestinian violence against Israel.

Despite these controversies, teachers' unions continue to play a critical role in shaping education and protecting the rights of educators in the US.

Teachers' exemption from minimum wage and overtime pay protections

Teachers are exempt from minimum wage and overtime pay protections if their primary duty is "teaching, tutoring, instructing, or lecturing to impart knowledge". This includes regular academic teachers, kindergarten or nursery school teachers, teachers of gifted or disabled children, teachers of skilled and semi-skilled trades and occupations, driving instructors, flight instructors, home economics teachers, and vocal or instrument music teachers.

Educational establishments include elementary school systems, secondary school systems, institutions of higher education, and other educational institutions. Teachers in these settings are exempt from minimum wage and overtime protections if their primary duty is teaching and they are employed by an educational establishment.

The exemption applies regardless of where the teaching takes place, to whom the knowledge is being imparted, or the number of hours worked per week. For example, a part-time faculty member of an educational establishment whose primary duty is to provide instruction through online courses to remote non-credit learners would still be exempt from minimum wage and overtime protections.

Athletic coaches employed by higher education institutions may also be exempt from minimum wage and overtime protections if their primary duty is providing instruction to student-athletes in how to perform their sport. However, if their primary duties are recruiting students to play sports or visiting high schools and athletic camps to conduct student interviews, they would not be exempt.

Teachers are exempt from minimum wage and overtime protections under Section 13(a)(1) of the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). This section also provides an exemption for employees in bona fide executive, administrative, and professional positions, as well as certain computer-related occupations.

Teachers' constitutional rights and protections

Teachers' unions are a type of labor union that fights for the rights of educators. While labor unions are not mentioned in the US Constitution, Article I grants Congress the power to regulate commerce among the states, and the Constitution also protects the right to assemble and speak freely—both critical to union activities.

Teachers in public schools have constitutional rights and protections, including:

• Substantive and procedural due process rights, including the right to receive notice of termination and the right to a hearing.
• Freedom of expression and association, provided by the First Amendment. This includes the right to free speech, which teachers do not forfeit when they accept employment. However, teachers may not promote a personal or political agenda in the classroom.
• Academic freedom, a limited concept recognized by courts based on principles of the First Amendment.
• Freedom of religion, with certain restrictions. For example, teachers are free to practice a religion but cannot preach it in the classroom.
• Protection against unreasonable searches and seizures of their personal property by school officials.
• Freedom from self-incrimination.
• Certain privacy rights. However, courts will often support disciplinary action taken by a school district when a teacher's private life affects their integrity or effectiveness as a teacher.

Teachers' contracts and the law

Teachers' contracts are vital documents that outline educators' rights, duties, and terms of employment. They are legally binding agreements between a teacher and a public school or school system.

Teaching contracts consist of four different components to be considered legally valid:

• Offer: A proposal or statement made by one party (the offeror) to the other party (the offeree) expressing a willingness to enter into a contract
• Acceptance: The agreement by the offeree to the terms of the offer
• Mutual Assent: When all parties involved agree upon the terms of the contract
• Consideration: Something of value that each party agrees to give or do for the other (can be a service, money, or a promise)

What Contracts for School Teachers Include

The employment contract contains important details such as:

• The duration of employment
• The teacher's obligations
• The expected compensation
• Good causes or just causes for termination
• The procedure for nonrenewal or revocation
• The expectation of performance evaluations
• Other terms and conditions

Nonrenewable Teaching Contracts

New teachers might be under a probationary "nonrenewal" contract. This contract can be ended without the need for detailed explanations or notice. Nonrenewal contracts end once their specified date or duration is over. For example, the contract may expire at the end of the school year. After the period ends, the parties can create a new contract or actively agree to a continuing contract.

Teacher Handbook as a Contract

A teacher's handbook can sometimes act like an implied contract. There have been cases where teachers have successfully claimed that the rules in the handbook granted them certain rights as if it were a contract. However, this is rare because most teachers' handbooks clearly state they aren't contracts.

Breach of Teacher Contract

Breaches of teacher employment contracts can occur because of the fault of either the employer or employee. School administrators, the board, or the teacher may breach the contract. For example, a teacher may breach a contract by resigning from the district before the end of the contract term.

The usual remedy for breach of contract between a school district and a teacher is monetary damages. If a school district has breached a contract, the teacher will usually receive the amount they would have received under the contract, less the amount they receive (or could receive) by attaining alternative employment.

Teachers' freedom of expression and association

In the US, public school teachers do not forfeit all of their First Amendment rights when they accept employment. This was established in the 1968 case of Pickering v. Board of Education, where the Supreme Court ruled that an Illinois high school teacher had a First Amendment right to send a letter to a local newspaper. The Supreme Court held that the school had unconstitutionally restricted the teacher's First Amendment rights to speak on issues of public importance.

In Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District (1969), the Supreme Court reiterated that teachers possess First Amendment rights. It wrote:

> It can hardly be argued that either students or teachers shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.

However, it is important to note that teachers' freedom of expression is not absolute. There are some restrictions, such as not being able to materially disrupt the educational interests of the school or undermine authority. Additionally, teachers must ensure that the content they teach is relevant to and consistent with their responsibilities, and they cannot promote personal or political agendas in the classroom.

The First Amendment also protects teachers from religious discrimination by school districts. Teachers may exercise their religious rights, but there are restrictions, especially in public schools, which cannot teach religion through the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. For example, a teacher can be a practicing Christian, but they cannot preach Christianity in the classroom.

Frequently asked questions