South Korea: Common Or Civil Law?

does south korea practice common law

South Korea's legal system has evolved over time, influenced by various cultural and historical factors. The country's legal traditions have been shaped by a mix of Buddhism, Confucianism, and Christianity, and its legal system has been influenced by Japanese, European, and American legal traditions. South Korea has a civil law system, which means that it does not follow common law practices like stare decisis or relying on precedent. Instead, judicial decisions are made on a case-by-case basis, and Korean judicial opinions tend to be brief and lack detailed reasoning for the conclusion. South Korea's judicial system is independent and comprises three tiers, including district courts, high courts, and a Supreme Court. While the country introduced a jury system for criminal cases in 2008, it differs significantly from common law systems, and judges ultimately decide all questions of law and fact.

Characteristics Values
Type of law system Civil law system with American law characteristics
Influences Japanese, European, common law principles, and US commercial law
Court system Three-tiered, independent judicial system
Jury system Jury trials for criminal cases only, introduced in 2008
Judges Rule independently and cannot be removed from office except in cases of impeachment, criminal acts, or incapacity
Appeals Losing party can appeal within 14 days of judgment
Employment law Mandatory rules of law apply even when a foreign law governs the employment contract
Data protection Act on the Protection and Use of Location Information, E-Commerce Act, Act on Real Name Financial Transactions and Confidentiality, and more
Foreign investment Foreigners intending to invest must report certain investments to the Minister of Trade, Industry and Energy in advance

lawshun

South Korea's legal system

South Korea has a civil law system, which has been historically influenced by Japanese and European laws and common-law principles. More recently, US law has influenced South Korean commercial law. South Korea is governed mainly by federal laws, but local governments also have some autonomy and can enact self-governing ordinances with binding power.

The South Korean legal system effectively dates from the introduction of the original Constitution of the Republic of Korea and the organisation of South Korea as an independent state. The Constitution has been revised several times, most recently in 1987, at the beginning of the Sixth Republic. The 1987 Constitution officially codified judicial independence in Article 103, which states that "Judges rule independently according to their conscience and in conformity with the Constitution and the law."

The judicial system of the Republic of Korea is composed of the Supreme Court of Korea, the Constitutional Court of Korea, six High Courts, 13 District Courts, and several courts of specialised jurisdiction, such as the Family Court and Administrative Court. In addition, branches of District Courts and Municipal Courts may be established. South Korean courts are organised and empowered in Chapters V and VI of the Constitution of the Republic of Korea.

South Korea has a three-tier court system, including district courts at the trial level, high courts at the initial appellate level, and a Supreme Court where appeals from the high courts are heard. In criminal cases, a defendant may be tried by a judge or a jury. In 2008, South Korea introduced a limited jury system for criminal and environmental cases. However, all questions of law and fact are decided by judges.

South Korea's legislative body for nationally applicable statutory law is the National Assembly, also known as the legislature. The executive branch consists of the president, the cabinet, and 22 ministries.

lawshun

South Korea's civil law system

Japan's long domination of the Korean peninsula during the early 20th century significantly influenced the country's legal system. Japan imposed civil law practices, drawing from the 19th-century civil law traditions of France and Germany. This historical influence led to the development of a mixed civil law and customary law jurisdiction in South Korea.

The South Korean judicial system is structured with the Supreme Court at the apex, followed by six High Courts, 13 District Courts, and specialised courts such as the Family Court and Administrative Court. The 1987 Constitution codified judicial independence, guaranteeing that judges rule independently and cannot be removed from office except for specific reasons. South Korean courts follow an inquisitorial system, where judges actively investigate the facts of a case, and decisions are rendered based on evidence and law.

lawshun

Common law influences

South Korea has a civil law system, which has been historically influenced by common law principles, as well as Japanese and European laws. More recently, US law has influenced South Korean commercial law.

During the early 20th century, Russia attempted to dominate Korea but was defeated by Japan in the Russo-Japanese War of 1904-1905. Japan occupied Korea after the war, first as a protectorate in 1905, and then as an annexed possession in 1910. Korea remained a Japanese possession until the end of World War II. During this period of occupation, Japan imposed civil law practices influenced by the civil law traditions of 19th-century France and Germany.

South Korea's legal system effectively dates from the introduction of the original Constitution of the Republic of Korea and its establishment as an independent state. The Court Organization Act, passed on September 26, 1949, officially established a three-tiered, independent judicial system in the Republic of Korea. The 1987 Constitution further codified judicial independence, guaranteeing that judges could not be removed from office except for impeachment, criminal acts, or incapacity.

South Korea's judicial system is composed of the Supreme Court, the Constitutional Court, six High Courts, 13 District Courts, and several courts of specialized jurisdiction, such as the Family Court and Administrative Court. While South Korea has introduced a limited jury system for criminal and environmental cases, judges decide all questions of law and fact. South Korean courts tend to issue brief judgments that lack detailed reasoning, and the losing party has the right to appeal to the court above within 14 days.

lawshun

South Korea's criminal law system

South Korea has a civil law system, historically influenced by Japanese and European civil law traditions and common law principles. More recently, US law has influenced South Korean commercial law, and South Korea is now a presidential republic.

In criminal cases, the prosecution is required to submit all relevant evidence gathered in the investigation to the court. There is no timeline for submitting evidence to the court, and the first trial is normally held within two to four weeks of the prosecution filing the indictment. The defendant has the right to seek bail, although it is rarely granted for serious crimes or foreigners charged with felonies. Trials are conducted both in writing and orally, with witnesses giving testimony live or in writing, and lawyers presenting their arguments orally and by submitting legal briefs. Foreigners are entitled to an interpreter throughout the trial.

After the trial, the judge renders a judgment based on the evidence presented and the law. Korean judicial opinions tend to be brief and often lack detailed reasoning for the conclusion. If the verdict results in a prison sentence, the time already spent in prison counts towards the sentence. Both the defendant and the prosecutor have the right to appeal the sentence within seven days of the announcement of the verdict. The court of appeals can examine the facts and law, and the parties can submit new allegations and pieces of evidence. After the appellate court makes a decision, the parties can appeal to the Supreme Court.

lawshun

Foreigners' rights

South Korea has a civil law system, historically influenced by Japanese and European laws and common-law principles. However, it does not follow common law practices, and its legal system is a mix of civil law and customary law.

Foreign nationals can acquire South Korean citizenship through naturalization after living in the country for at least five years and demonstrating proficiency in the Korean language. Foreigners seeking naturalization through marriage must meet stricter criteria, including establishing residency for two years.

In 2010, a new amendment offered South Korean citizenship to talented foreigners, regardless of their ethnic background, without the residency requirements for those seeking naturalization through marriage. Amendments between 2011 and 2016 also allowed South Korean citizens to maintain multiple citizenships.

Foreigners intending to invest in South Korea must report certain investments to the Minister of Trade, Industry, and Energy in advance. Foreign investment plans that must be reported include investments resulting in at least 10% ownership of voting shares or total investment capital, with a total investment amount of at least KRW100 million.

Foreigners are entitled to an interpreter throughout criminal trials in South Korea. They are usually kept in detention throughout the investigation and trial process, and bail is not commonly granted. If found guilty, they will generally be deported after serving their sentence.

The South Korean government aims to prevent unreasonable discrimination against foreigners and safeguard their human rights. The government also provides foreigners with education, information, and counselling services to help them adjust to Korean society and understand the basic common knowledge necessary for living in the country.

Sharia Law in Canada: Is It Legal?

You may want to see also

Frequently asked questions

South Korea has a civil law system, which has been historically influenced by Japanese and European laws and common-law principles. However, it is not a common-law country.

South Korea has a three-tiered, independent judicial system. It has a civil law system with American law characteristics, including trial by jury for some matters. South Korea is governed in large part by federal laws, but local governments also have certain degrees of autonomy.

South Korea's legal system effectively dates from the introduction of the original Constitution of the Republic of Korea and the organisation of South Korea as an independent state. The 1987 Constitution officially codified judicial independence, guaranteeing that judges would rule independently according to their conscience and in conformity with the Constitution and the law. South Korean courts are organised and empowered in Chapters V and VI of the Constitution of the Republic of Korea.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment