Texas Abortion Law: Exemption For Rape Victims?

Texas' abortion law, which prohibits physicians from performing abortions once a foetal heartbeat is detected, has sparked much controversy since its enactment in September 2021. Notably, the law includes no exceptions for rape or incest, a decision that has been criticised by many. This omission has led to an increase in rape-related pregnancies in the state, with researchers claiming that Texas leads the country in this regard. The lack of exceptions puts survivors of rape in a difficult position, as they must either carry the unwanted pregnancy to term or seek alternative options, such as travelling to another state where abortion is legal. This has sparked debates about the ethics of the law and the impact it has on the lives of those affected.

Texas abortion law has no exceptions for rape or incest

Texas's abortion law has been the subject of intense debate and legal challenges since it came into effect on September 1, 2021. The law prohibits physicians from performing abortions once a fetal heartbeat is detected, which is usually around six weeks into a pregnancy—a point at which many women are unaware they are pregnant. Notably, the law includes no exceptions for rape or incest.

The absence of exceptions for rape and incest in Texas's abortion law has sparked controversy and criticism. Overwhelming majorities of voters believe that their state should generally allow abortion in specific cases, including rape and incest. The lack of exceptions has also caused divisions among Republicans, not just in Texas but also in other states considering or implementing abortion restrictions.

The impact of Texas's abortion law is particularly concerning given the high number of rape-related pregnancies in the state. A study published in the medical journal JAMA Internal Medicine found that Texas leads the country in rape-related pregnancies among states with total abortion bans. According to the study, 26,313 rape-related pregnancies occurred in Texas during the 16 months after the state legislature banned abortion. This figure represents nearly 45% of all such pregnancies estimated to occur in the nine states with abortion bans that do not make an exception for rape.

The lack of exceptions for rape and incest in Texas's abortion law has had significant consequences for pregnant individuals who are survivors of sexual assault. In many cases, survivors are afraid to report sexual violence to the police due to fear of retaliation or a belief that law enforcement will not be able to help. Additionally, the requirement for law enforcement involvement to document rape and incest creates barriers for survivors seeking abortion care, especially in states like Texas where abortion care is restricted.

The Texas Medical Board has proposed guidance for exceptions to the state's abortion bans, aiming to clarify what qualifies as an exception in medical emergencies. However, critics argue that the guidance falls short of providing clear exceptions and does not adequately protect the lifesaving care that pregnant mothers may require.

Rape victims forced to give birth

The Texas abortion law, which prohibits physicians from performing abortions once a fetal heartbeat is detected, does not include exceptions for rape or incest. This means that rape victims in Texas are forced to carry their pregnancies to term, unless they can access abortion in a state where it is legal or obtain a self-managed abortion.

The absence of exceptions for rape and incest in the Texas abortion law has caused controversy and divided opinions, even among Republicans. While some defend the law on the grounds that Texas will work to eliminate rapists, others argue that this is detached from reality. The situation has been described as "taxing" and "terrifying" for Texans, especially Black women, who already had limited access to abortion and healthcare.

The impact of the law falls disproportionately on marginalized communities, and there are concerns that it will lead to an increase in maternal mortality, particularly among Black and Hispanic women. Furthermore, the requirement for law enforcement involvement in documenting rape and incest creates additional barriers for survivors seeking abortion care.

The Texas abortion law has been challenged in court, with plaintiffs arguing that the vague language of the law endangers women's lives. However, the Texas Supreme Court has upheld the law, stating that it only contains exceptions when there is a life-threatening physical condition. As a result, rape victims in Texas are forced to give birth unless they can access alternative options outside the state.

Rape-related pregnancies in Texas

Texas has a trigger law on abortion that came into effect in June 2022 after the U.S. Supreme Court's Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization decision overturned Roe v. Wade. The law prohibits physicians from performing abortions once a foetal heartbeat is detected, which is usually around six weeks into a pregnancy. There is no exception for rape or incest.

A study published in the medical journal JAMA Internal Medicine in January 2024 found that Texas had the highest number of rape-related pregnancies among the 14 states that outlawed abortion after the Dobbs ruling. The study, which examined data from the FBI, CDC, and Bureau of Justice Statistics, estimated that 26,313 rape-related pregnancies occurred in Texas during the 16 months after the state banned abortion. This figure comprises nearly 45% of all such pregnancies estimated to occur in the nine states without a legal exception for rape.

The study also estimated that 519,981 rapes of women aged 15-45 occurred in the 14 states with abortion bans, with 211,919 of those occurring in Texas, and 64,565 pregnancies resulting from those rapes. The authors of the study noted that the number of rape-related pregnancies in states with total abortion bans indicates that "persons who have been raped and become pregnant cannot access legal abortions in their home state, even in states with rape exceptions."

The lack of access to abortion following the Dobbs decision has been particularly impactful on Black and Hispanic women in Texas, who already had limited access to healthcare. Qiana Lewis-Arnold, a birth justice advocate with the Dallas-based non-profit The Afiya Center, stated that "now folks are facing criminalization and death."

Law enforcement involvement

Texas's abortion ban has no exceptions for rape or incest. However, it does have an exception to protect the life of the mother. The law criminalizes performing an abortion from the moment of fertilization unless the pregnant patient faces "a life-threatening physical condition aggravated by, caused by, or arising from a pregnancy."

In Texas, more than 14,000 rape crimes have been reported since the abortion law took effect last year, according to data from the Texas Department of Public Safety. This has led to a high demand for rape crisis centers, with many reporting that they are struggling to keep up with the demand.

The absence of exceptions for rape or incest in Texas's abortion law has caused divisions among Republicans and has been unpopular in public polling. Despite this, at least a dozen states have followed Texas's lead and implemented similar bans with no exceptions.

Texas abortion law and the Supreme Court

The Texas abortion law, also known as the Texas Heartbeat Bill, prohibits physicians from performing abortions once a fetal heartbeat is detected. The law took effect on September 1, 2021, and sparked heated debates and legal challenges across the nation. The law allows for a pregnancy to be terminated if the woman's life is at risk or if she is at risk of "substantial impairment of a major bodily function". However, there is no exception for rape or incest.

The law has been challenged in the courts, including the Supreme Court, several times. In June 2024, the US Supreme Court declined to hear a bid by the Biden administration to enforce federal guidance requiring hospitals to perform abortions in emergency situations, even in states where it is banned. The Supreme Court's decision upheld Texas' abortion restrictions, which include a health exception for pregnant patients.

In May 2024, the Texas Supreme Court ruled in Zurawski v. State that the state's abortion law was not unconstitutional. The case was brought by twenty women and two doctors who claimed that the law's restrictions caused significant harm by preventing doctors from performing medically necessary abortions. The Texas Attorney General's Office argued that the high bar for qualifying for an abortion is constitutional, while the plaintiffs' lawyers countered that the law's vague language puts women's lives at risk.

The Texas abortion law has also been challenged in lower courts. In August 2023, a Texas judge granted a temporary injunction allowing abortions in cases of medical emergencies, including pregnancies that are unsafe for the mother. This injunction was later appealed by the Texas Attorney General's Office and overturned by the Texas Supreme Court.

The Texas abortion law has been criticised for its impact on women's access to abortion, particularly in cases of rape or incest. A study published in January 2024 found that Texas leads the country in rape-related pregnancies when compared to states with total abortion bans. The study estimated that 26,313 rape-related pregnancies occurred in Texas during the 16 months after the state banned abortion.

Frequently asked questions