Understanding Homestead Law And Civil Judgment Complexities

The Homestead Law, enacted during the Civil War in 1862, allowed any adult citizen or intended citizen who had never borne arms against the US government to claim 160 acres of surveyed government land. Claimants had to live on and cultivate the land. While the Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976 ended homesteading, additional homesteading laws have been passed over the years, and Alaska allowed homesteading until 1986. Today, most states have homestead exemptions, and these vary in their rules and protection limits. For example, in California, a homestead exemption protects a certain dollar amount of equity in a debtor's homestead from judgment creditors. In Florida, the homestead exemption provides no limit to the value of certain real property that can be protected from creditors, although acreage limits may apply.

Homestead exemption limits by state

A homestead exemption is a legal provision that shields a home from creditors following the death of a homeowner's spouse or the declaration of bankruptcy. It also provides tax relief for surviving spouses and blocks the forced sale of a primary residence.

Homestead exemption laws vary by state, with some states offering more protection than others. Here is a list of homestead exemption limits for each state in the US:

• Alabama: $15,000
• Alaska: $72,900
• Arizona: $150,000
• Arkansas: Unlimited
• California: $300,000 to $600,000
• Colorado: $250,000 to $350,000
• Connecticut: $75,000
• Delaware: $125,000
• Florida: Unlimited
• Georgia: $21,500
• Hawaii: $20,0000
• Idaho: $100,000
• Illinois: $15,000
• Indiana: Unlimited
• Iowa: Unlimited
• Kansas: Unlimited
• Kentucky: $5,000
• Louisiana: $35,000
• Maine: $47,500
• Maryland: $22,975
• Massachusetts: $500,000
• Michigan: $30,000 to $45,000
• Minnesota: $450,000
• Mississippi: $75,000
• Missouri: $15,000
• Montana: $250,000
• Nebraska: $60,000
• Nevada: $550,000
• New Hampshire: $100,000
• New Jersey: No homestead exemption
• New Mexico: $60,000
• New York: $82,775 to $165,550
• North Carolina: $35,000
• North Dakota: $100,000
• Ohio: $136,925
• Oklahoma: Unlimited
• Oregon: $40,000
• Pennsylvania: No homestead exemption
• Rhode Island: $500,000
• South Carolina: $58,255
• South Dakota: Unlimited
• Tennessee: $5,000 to $7,500
• Texas: Unlimited
• Utah: $20,000
• Vermont: $125,000
• Virginia: $5,000 to $10,000
• Washington: $125,000
• West Virginia: $25,000
• Wisconsin: $75,000
• Wyoming: $20,000

Some states, such as Florida, Texas, and South Dakota, offer unlimited financial protection against unsecured creditors, although acreage limits may apply. Other states, like New Jersey and Pennsylvania, do not offer any homestead protection.

Does the homestead law apply to all creditors?

Homestead laws protect a homeowner's primary residence from creditors and insolvency proceedings. However, the protection offered by these laws varies from state to state.

In some states, the homestead exemption provides unlimited financial protection against unsecured creditors, although acreage limits may apply. For example, Florida and Texas have no limit to the value of certain real property that can be protected from creditors, as long as the property does not exceed half an acre in a municipality or 160 acres elsewhere.

In other states, the exemption is capped at a prescribed dollar amount, which can range from $5,000 to $550,000. This limit is not for the home's value but for the homeowner's equity. A homeowner cannot be forced to sell their property to satisfy creditors if their equity is less than the limit, but creditors may force a sale if the equity exceeds it.

It's important to note that homestead protection does not apply to secured creditors, such as the bank holding the mortgage. The protection also does not extend to certain types of debt and liens, including mortgages, tax liens, mechanic's liens, domestic support obligations, and HOA liens.

To qualify for homestead protection, the property must be the debtor's primary residence and must be located within the state where protection is claimed. The owner must also be a "natural person" residing in the applicable jurisdiction, meaning an individual rather than a corporation or LLC.

How does the homestead law affect bankruptcy?

The homestead exemption is a legal provision that shields a primary residence from some creditors following the death of a homeowner’s spouse or a declaration of bankruptcy. It also minimises property taxes for homeowners.

In the United States, the Homestead Act, enacted during the Civil War in 1862, allowed any adult citizen or intended citizen who had never borne arms against the US government to claim 160 acres of surveyed government land. Claimants had to live on and cultivate the land. Additional homesteading laws were passed in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, and the Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976 ended homesteading, except for Alaska, which allowed homesteading until 1986.

Most states have homestead exemptions, but the rules and protection limits vary. For example, in California, the homestead exemption is the greater of the following:

• The countywide median sale price for a single-family home in the calendar year prior to the calendar year in which the judgment debtor claims the exemption, not to exceed $600,000
• $300,000

These amounts are adjusted annually for inflation.

In Florida, the homestead exemption provides no limit to the value of certain real property that can be protected from creditors. However, the property can't be larger than half an acre in a municipality or 160 acres elsewhere. If the homestead is on a lot that exceeds the size limitations, the homestead protection is allocated pro-rata to the total property value.

In the context of bankruptcy, federal bankruptcy law shields a home from sale if the owner's equity does not exceed $25,150 if the bankruptcy case was filed after April 1, 2019. However, homeowners commonly use the state's limits, which often prove more favourable. For example, in Florida, the homestead exemption is available up to approximately $160,000 unless the debtor occupied their current Florida homestead property, plus any previous Florida homestead properties, for a continuous 40-month period. Joint bankruptcy debtors can protect approximately $320,000 of a jointly-owned homestead.

Can the homestead law be waived?

In the US, a homestead waiver is a document in which the homeowner or spouse of a homeowner gives up their statutory homestead rights under applicable state law. This is often required in certain contracts, such as mortgages, to allow banks to recoup their losses in the event of foreclosure. However, the specific conditions under which a homestead law can be waived vary from state to state.

In Florida, for example, the Constitution protects the homestead upon the death of an owner by precluding its devise when there is a spouse. However, Florida law allows spouses to waive all types of spousal rights, including rights to the homestead, either wholly or partially, before or after marriage. This must be done in writing and signed by the waiving party in the presence of two subscribing witnesses.

In Colorado, a homeowner's association agreement may include a provision that requires each owner to agree that the association's lien on a lot for assessments shall be superior to the homestead exemption provided by Colorado law.

What is the history of the Homestead Act?

The Homestead Act of 1862 was passed by Congress and signed into law by President Abraham Lincoln on May 20, 1862. The Act provided 160 acres of federal land to adult citizens or future citizens who paid a small filing fee and agreed to farm the land for five years. The Act was designed to encourage the settlement of the American West and promote economic growth. Before the Act, opposition from both Southern and Northern legislators prevented its passage. Southerners feared that homesteaders would work to end slavery in new territories, while Northerners worried that cheap land would reduce property values and draw labourers away. However, with the departure of Southern senators in 1861, supporters of the Act were finally able to pass it.

The Homestead Act built on decades of interest and discussion around the distribution of government lands. As early as 1846, Congress was presented with the first homestead bill, and in 1860, a Homestead Act was passed by Congress but vetoed by President James Buchanan. The Act that was ultimately passed in 1862 was a key part of the Republican Party platform and was made possible by Lincoln's election victory and the secession of the Southern states.

The Act took effect on January 1, 1863, and granted land to anyone who paid a small filing fee and agreed to work on and improve the land, including by building a residence, over a five-year period. While the Act was open to all citizens or intended citizens, it was particularly significant for African Americans, as it gave them the opportunity to own land, something that was previously unattainable in the South. The potential for free land attracted hundreds of thousands of settlers to the Great Plains and enticed a wave of thousands of African Americans to migrate from the South.

In total, around 270 million acres were distributed under the 1862 Homestead Act. The Act remained in effect for over a century and the last claim was granted in 1988 for a parcel of land in Alaska.

Frequently asked questions