Induced Demand: Subways And The Law's Relevance

Induced demand is an economic phenomenon where an increase in supply leads to a decline in price and an increase in consumption. In transportation planning, induced demand, also called induced traffic, refers to the increase in traffic that results from the expansion of transportation systems. The concept of induced demand challenges the traditional wisdom in transportation planning, which assumes that expanding roadways will alleviate congestion. However, induced demand suggests that increasing roadway capacity will only lead to higher traffic volumes as drivers are incentivized to use their personal vehicles. This phenomenon has been observed in numerous cities, including Los Angeles, New York, and Seoul, and has significant implications for transportation planning and policy.

So, does the law of induced demand also apply to subways?

Induced demand is not a law of physics

Induced demand is a term used in economics to describe the phenomenon where an increase in supply leads to a decline in price and an increase in consumption. In transportation planning, induced demand, also called "induced traffic" or consumption of road capacity, is used in the debate over the expansion of transportation systems and is often used as an argument against increasing roadway traffic capacity as a cure for congestion.

There are two effects that get lumped together under the heading of "induced demand":

Effect 1: Road building alters travel behaviour

When road capacity is expanded, the cost of driving to a location is reduced in terms of time, aggravation, or inconvenience. According to economic principles, when the cost of something is reduced, people will consume more of it. This effect is not unique to roads and can be observed with other goods and services.

Effect 2: Road building alters the development pattern

Over time, development in areas that are now better served by roads becomes more profitable and attractive. People are more interested in living further away from where they work if the commute time is reduced. This effect is fairly unique to roads and significantly alters the development pattern of a city or region, inducing more driving over the medium to long term.

While induced demand is backed up by research, critics argue that it is not always taken into consideration in planning. Some critics accept the premise of induced demand but argue against its interpretation, stating that induced demand is actually a good thing and that past data cannot be applied to present circumstances due to changing transportation trends. They argue that induced demand can keep up with population growth, move traffic out of neighbourhoods, and improve the quality of life by allowing people to adjust the timing of their trips.

Induced demand is not infinite

Induced demand is a term used to describe the phenomenon whereby an increase in supply results in a decline in price and an increase in consumption. In transportation planning, induced demand is also referred to as "induced traffic" or the consumption of road capacity. It is often used as an argument against increasing roadway traffic capacity as a cure for congestion.

The concept of induced demand is not infinite. While it is true that increasing the supply of roads may initially reduce congestion and increase consumption, there are limits to this effect. The number of people who will adjust their travel routines in response to increased road capacity is finite, not infinite. Additionally, induced demand can also consist of new travel, such as trips that individuals would not have otherwise made. However, there is a limit to how much road capacity can be increased before it becomes impractical or detrimental to a city's development.

Furthermore, induced demand has negative externalities that should be considered. Building more roads can lead to urban sprawl, alter development patterns, and encourage automobile dependency. It can also have environmental impacts, such as increased air pollution and accident rates.

While induced demand can increase consumption and reduce congestion in the short term, it is not a long-term solution. The effects of induced demand reach a saturation point, and further road expansion may lead to negative consequences for a city's development and livability. Therefore, it is essential to consider the limits of induced demand and explore alternative solutions to congestion, such as public transportation, congestion pricing, and toll lanes.

Induced demand is not limited to roads

Induced demand is a phenomenon observed in economics, whereby an increase in supply leads to a decline in price and an increase in consumption. In transportation planning, induced demand is also called "induced traffic" or consumption of road capacity. It is often used as an argument against increasing roadway traffic capacity as a cure for congestion.

Bicycle Lanes

Building more bicycle lanes will likely result in more cyclists. This is because cycling becomes a safer and more viable option for those who were previously deterred by unsafe road conditions. However, the impact of induced demand on bicycle lanes is different from that on roads. Bicycle lanes can induce adjacent development based on their recreational value, but they do not significantly alter the development pattern of an entire region.

Public Transit

Induced demand also applies to public transit. When a new subway line is added, some drivers may switch to using public transportation. However, this does not necessarily reduce road congestion, as new drivers replace those who switched. Nonetheless, public transit expansion can have a positive impact by allowing more people to move around.

Film-Induced Tourism

Destinations featured in films or television series may experience an increase in tourist visits. This is supported by regression analyses, which suggest a correlation between destinations that actively encourage filming and subsequent tourism success. Film-induced demand illustrates that when the supply of media exposure increases, the number of visitors also tends to rise.

In conclusion, induced demand is a concept that goes beyond road construction. It can be observed in various domains, including transportation and tourism. While induced demand on roads may lead to more traffic, induced demand in other areas, such as bicycle lanes and public transit, can have positive effects by providing alternative modes of transportation and satisfying latent demand.

Induced demand is not immediate

Induced demand is a term used in economics to describe the phenomenon where an increase in supply leads to a decline in price and an increase in consumption. In transportation planning, induced demand, also called "induced traffic" or consumption of road capacity, is often used as an argument against increasing roadway traffic capacity as a cure for congestion.

The concept of induced demand is not limited to roads and can be applied to other goods and services as well. When a road is expanded, it can lead to two different effects that are often lumped together under the heading of "induced demand".

The first effect is that, in the near term, expanding a road causes drivers to alter their travel patterns and use it more. This effect is not unique to roads and can be observed with other goods and services as well. When you expand road capacity, you reduce the cost of driving, not just in monetary terms but also in terms of time, aggravation, and inconvenience. According to economic principles, when you reduce the cost of something, people will consume more of it.

The second effect is that, in the medium to long term, expanding a major road will alter the pattern of development in a city or region, which in turn induces more driving. This effect is fairly unique to roads. When you build a new road or expand an existing one, you make some destinations more accessible, while in theory, not making any destinations harder to reach. Over time, development in the areas that are now better served by roads becomes more profitable and attractive. As a result, people are willing to commute longer distances, and the demand for driving increases.

While induced demand can lead to an immediate increase in road usage as drivers take advantage of the additional capacity, the full effects of induced demand, particularly the impact on development patterns, may take longer to materialize. Therefore, it is important to recognize that induced demand is not just an immediate phenomenon but also has long-term implications that can shape the growth and development of a city or region over time.

Induced demand is not necessarily bad

Furthermore, induced demand is not unique to roads and can occur with other goods and services as well. It is a fundamental concept in economics, where an increase in supply leads to a decrease in price and an increase in consumption. This is consistent with the economic model of supply and demand. Therefore, it is not surprising that induced demand occurs in the context of road expansion as well.

However, it is important to recognize that there are negative consequences of induced demand, particularly in the context of road expansion. As more roads are built, people may be incentivized to drive more, leading to increased traffic congestion. Additionally, road expansion can pull people away from alternative modes of transportation such as public transit, bicycling, or walking, which can have negative environmental and health impacts.

In conclusion, while induced demand is not inherently bad, it is important to carefully consider the potential positive and negative impacts when making decisions about road expansion. It may be more beneficial to invest in alternative modes of transportation, such as subways, buses, or bicycle lanes, which can also induce demand but may have more positive effects on the overall transportation system and quality of life.

Frequently asked questions