The Journey Of A Bill To Law In Ontario

In Ontario, a bill must pass through several stages before it can become a law. The first step is to introduce a bill in the House for its first reading, where the main objectives of the bill are outlined. Following this, the bill is assigned a number and scheduled for a second reading, during which members of the House debate the bill's principles. After the second reading, the bill may be sent for a third reading or to a committee for further examination. Once the examination is complete, the bill is reported back to the House and debated for the final time. If the majority of members vote in favour of the bill, it is sent to the Lieutenant Governor for Royal Assent, who signs it on behalf of the head of state, marking the bill's official passage into law.

First Reading

The first step in the process of a bill becoming a law in Ontario is its introduction in the House for "first reading". This can be done in three ways: by ministers (called a government bill), by a member of provincial Parliament (called a private member's public bill), or by the chair of a standing committee (called a committee bill).

During the first reading, the main objectives of the bill are outlined to the other members of the House. The bill is then assigned a number, and a copy is distributed to each member of the House. The first version of the bill is also posted online for the public to read. At this stage, no amendments to the text of the bill are permitted.

After the first reading, the bill is scheduled for a second reading, usually several days later. This gives members of the House time to study the bill before the upcoming debate.

The first reading is a crucial step in the legislative process as it sets the foundation for the bill's progression through the House. It provides members with an understanding of the bill's objectives and allows for the distribution of information to both members of the House and the public.

The first reading is also significant as it marks the official introduction of the bill in the House. It is the first opportunity for members to hear and consider the proposed legislation. This stage is essential for transparency and ensuring that all members have access to the same information before the subsequent debates and votes.

Second Reading

The second reading of a bill in Ontario is a crucial stage in the legislative process, where Members of Provincial Parliament (MPPs) engage in a thorough debate on the principles and merits of the proposed legislation. This stage provides an opportunity for MPPs to voice their opinions, address concerns, and suggest improvements to the bill before it proceeds further. Here is a detailed overview of the Second Reading stage:

During the Second Reading, MPPs delve into the specifics of the bill, examining its key principles, objectives, and potential impact. Each MPP is allowed to speak only once during this stage, ensuring that a diverse range of perspectives are heard. The debate is structured to encourage a comprehensive evaluation of the bill's merits and to identify areas where modifications may be necessary.

Amendments Not Permitted

It is important to note that, during the Second Reading, MPPs are not permitted to propose amendments to the text of the bill. This stage focuses solely on the underlying principles and intentions of the legislation. Any suggested changes to the wording or specific clauses of the bill will be addressed at later stages, particularly when the bill is reviewed by committees or during the Third Reading.

Vote to Proceed

After the conclusion of the debate, the Speaker of the House calls for a vote to determine whether the bill should advance to the next stage. This vote is a critical juncture, as it decides the fate of the bill. If a majority of MPPs vote in favour of the bill, it will proceed to the next step, which may include referral to a committee or advancement to the Third Reading. However, if the bill fails to garner sufficient support, it may be discontinued or sent back for further revisions before being reintroduced.

Committee Review

In some cases, after a successful Second Reading, the bill may be referred to a Standing or Select Committee for further scrutiny. This committee stage allows for a more detailed examination of the bill, including the consideration of potential amendments. Committees may invite experts, individuals, and groups to provide written or oral submissions, ensuring that a wide range of perspectives are considered. The committee review process can vary in duration, ranging from a few days to several months, depending on the complexity of the bill and the extent of the committee's mandate.

Transition to Third Reading

Once the committee has completed its review and suggested any amendments, the bill returns to the House for further consideration. At this stage, the bill may proceed directly to the Third Reading, or it may undergo additional debate and scrutiny during the Committee of the Whole House stage. The Committee of the Whole House provides another opportunity for MPPs to discuss the bill and propose amendments before the final vote.

In summary, the Second Reading of a bill in Ontario is a vital stage in the legislative process. It involves a rigorous debate among MPPs, focusing on the principles and merits of the proposed legislation. This stage ensures that the bill is thoroughly vetted and provides an opportunity for amendments and improvements before it advances toward becoming a law.

Committee Examination

The committee stage is a crucial part of the legislative process in Ontario, where a bill is scrutinised and can be amended before it proceeds to the next stage. The committee stage can last anywhere from a few days to several months. During this time, the bill is studied in detail, and the committee may call witnesses and invite individuals, groups, and Ministry officials to comment on the bill in writing or in person. The committee may also travel to different locations in the province to receive comments and learn more about the issues. Research Officers attend hearings to answer any research questions and prepare summaries of witnesses' recommendations, which help committee members draft amendments.

Once the committee has heard from witnesses, the bill is examined clause-by-clause, and any amendments are voted on. Each clause of the bill is considered and may be amended or deleted. If amendments are made, the bill is reprinted. After the committee has finished its examination, the bill is reported back to the House. If the committee has made amendments, the House may not proceed further until the bill has been reprinted. The committee then votes on the bill as a whole and whether to report it to the House. The committee stage is an important opportunity to ensure that the bill has been thoroughly reviewed and that any necessary changes have been made before it moves forward in the legislative process.

Third Reading

After the Second Reading, the bill may move directly to Third Reading, but often it is first examined by a Standing or Select Committee. The bill can be in the committee stage for a few days or up to several months. After review by the Committee, the bill is reported back to the House. It may be sent to the Committee of the Whole House or directly to final debate.

During Third Reading, MPPs debate the bill for the last time. Following the debate, the Speaker calls for a final vote about the proposed law. If the majority of MPPs vote to make the bill a law during Third Reading, it is presented to the Lieutenant Governor for Royal Assent. This procedure is called Royal Assent because the Lieutenant Governor is agreeing to the bill on behalf of The King. This last step officially makes the bill a law.

According to the Constitution Act, 1867, the passage of a bill by the Legislature requires the assent of the Sovereign (or her representative). Royal Assent takes place in the House or in the chambers of the Lieutenant Governor. The Office of Legislative Counsel then assigns a chapter number to what has become an Act and it is posted on the Ministry of the Attorney General’s e-Laws website under Source Law.

Royal Assent

Once a bill has passed the third reading stage, it is presented to the Lieutenant Governor for Royal Assent. This is the final step in the legislative process, officially making the bill a law. The Lieutenant Governor may assent to the bill in the monarch's name, withhold assent, or reserve assent. The bill is presented to the Lieutenant Governor for Royal Assent on behalf of the monarch, currently King Charles III.

When a bill receives Royal Assent, it becomes an Act and is given a statute number. The Act may come into force immediately upon Royal Assent, or it can be proclaimed by the Lieutenant Governor at a later date. In some cases, different sections of the Act may come into force at different times. This information is usually specified within the Act itself.

In addition to the provincial process, bills in Ontario must also pass through the House of Commons and the Senate to become federal law. The final step in the federal process is also Royal Assent, which can be given by the Governor General or their deputy in a formal ceremony before both houses of Parliament. Alternatively, Royal Assent can be given by written declaration, as outlined in the Royal Assent Act, S.C. 2002, c.15, s.5.

Frequently asked questions