The Irish Lawmaking Process: From Bill To Law

In Ireland, a bill is a draft law that must be passed by the Dáil and the Seanad (the two Houses of the Oireachtas, or Irish parliament) before it can be signed into law by the President. The process of a bill becoming a law is known as lawmaking, and it involves several stages of drafting, scrutiny, and approval. The Oireachtas, which includes the Dáil, Seanad, and President, is the only institution in Ireland with the power to make laws. This article will outline the key steps and requirements for a bill to become a law in Ireland.

Drafting of the Bill

The drafting of a Bill is a complex and lengthy process that involves multiple stakeholders. Here is a detailed overview of the key steps involved in the drafting process:

Preparation and Research: The process of drafting a Bill begins with extensive research and preparation by civil servants in the relevant government department. They carry out detailed research, consult experts, academics, civil society organisations, and seek input from the public. This stage is crucial as it forms the foundation for the Bill.

Green Paper and Public Consultation: In some cases, the government may publish a Green Paper, which is a discussion document outlining ideas and inviting comments and feedback from individuals and relevant organisations. This stage allows for early input and helps shape the direction of the proposed legislation.

General Scheme or Heads of a Bill: The initial draft of a Bill is known as the General Scheme or Heads of a Bill. It sets out the main objectives, key provisions, and the structure of the proposed legislation. The responsible Minister must get this approved by the government before publication.

Pre-Legislative Scrutiny: The General Scheme often undergoes pre-legislative scrutiny by an Oireachtas Committee. This committee may invite representatives of groups who will be affected by the Bill to meetings and discussions. This provides an opportunity for feedback and input before the Bill is finalised.

Finalisation and Approval: After analysing feedback from consultations and the Oireachtas Committee's report, the government department finalises the Bill. This detailed Bill is then approved by the government at a Cabinet meeting.

Publication and Introduction: Once approved, the Bill is published and formally introduced in the Oireachtas, usually in the Dáil. The sponsoring Minister outlines the purpose and objectives of the Bill.

The drafting process is a critical phase in the journey of a Bill becoming a law. It involves multiple stakeholders, including civil servants, government departments, Oireachtas Committees, and the public. This collaborative process ensures that the Bill is thoroughly researched, scrutinised, and shaped before it moves forward in the legislative process.

Initiating the Bill

Initiating a bill in Ireland involves several key steps, and it's important to note that the process can vary slightly depending on whether the bill is introduced in the Dáil or the Seanad. Here's a detailed overview of the process:

Initiating a Bill in the Dáil

The first step in initiating a bill is to introduce it to the Dáil, the lower house of the Oireachtas (Irish parliament). This is typically done by a Government Minister or a TD (member of the Dáil) who is not part of the Government, known as a Private Member. The bill is then put before the Dáil for a general debate on its principles, and members can suggest amendments and additions. This is known as the Second Stage.

During the Second Stage, the Minister or TD introducing the bill outlines its objectives, and other members contribute to the debate. The Minister or TD introducing the bill speaks last, responding to questions and comments. After the debate, the Dáil votes to decide whether the bill should proceed to the next stage. If the bill is approved, it moves on to the Committee Stage.

Initiating a Bill in the Seanad

Initiating a bill in the Seanad, the upper house of the Oireachtas, follows a similar process. The bill is introduced and undergoes a general debate, with members suggesting amendments and additions. However, it's worth noting that the Seanad cannot amend Money Bills (bills related to taxes or government spending) and can only delay, not stop, their passage.

After the general debate in the Seanad, the bill proceeds to the Committee Stage, where it is examined in more detail. This stage is crucial as it involves scrutinising and amending the bill before it moves closer to becoming law.

The Committee Stage

The Committee Stage is a detailed examination of the bill, typically carried out by an Oireachtas Committee. During this stage, each section of the bill is debated, and members can propose amendments. The relevant Minister is present to discuss the proposed amendments and decide whether to accept or reject them. This stage can be lengthy, as there is no limit to the number of times a member can speak on an amendment.

Once the Committee Stage is completed, the bill moves to the Report Stage, where further amendments may be considered. However, at this stage, members can only speak twice on each amendment, and new amendments cannot be introduced. After the Report Stage, the bill proceeds to the Final Stage.

The Final Stage

The Final Stage is a concluding debate on the bill, where members cannot introduce any further amendments. Instead, they discuss the bill in light of any changes made during the previous stages. Finally, the members vote on whether to pass the bill. If the bill is approved by the Dáil or Seanad, it then moves to the other house to go through the same process.

It's important to note that initiating a bill requires careful preparation, including research and consultations with stakeholders. This process can take time and involves multiple stages, ensuring that the proposed legislation is thoroughly considered before becoming law.

Committee Stage

The Committee Stage is the third stage in the process of a Bill becoming a law in Ireland. During this stage, each individual section of the Bill is debated, often by an Oireachtas Committee in the Dáil. Members of the Committee discuss proposed amendments with the relevant Minister, who decides on whether to accept or reject them. If an amendment is rejected by the Minister, a vote can be called.

The Committee Stage can be lengthy as there is no limit on the number of times a member can speak on an amendment. At this stage, the committee will vote on each individual amendment, as well as on whether each individual section of the Bill should be included.

Once the Bill as a whole has been dealt with, there is a final vote on whether to progress it to the next phase – the Report Stage – and send it back to the Dáil as a whole.

Report Stage

The Report Stage is the fourth stage in the process of a Bill becoming a law in Ireland. It is the last opportunity for members of the Oireachtas to make amendments to the text of a Bill. Members may not bring forward any new amendments; only amendments that arise from the previous Committee Stage are discussed. Unlike the Committee Stage, members may speak only twice on each amendment, and their second contribution is limited to two minutes.

When all the amendments have been dealt with, the Bill is received for final consideration. The Fifth Stage may be scheduled for another day, but it is usually taken immediately after the Fourth Stage. If the Government wants to introduce new amendments at the Report Stage, it may do so by recommitting the Bill. This effectively returns the Bill to the Committee Stage in respect of an individual amendment.

The Report Stage is followed by the Fifth Stage, or the Final Stage, where the Bill is passed by the House. No amendments may be tabled, and there is generally no in-depth discussion of the Bill. Instead, members usually make short statements on whether the Bill would constitute good law. Then, the House agrees to pass the Bill, and a member may call a division by saying "Vótáil".

President signs Bill into law

Once a Bill has been passed by both the Dáil and the Seanad, it is presented to the President to be signed into law. The President must sign the Bill within five to seven days of receiving it, unless the Seanad requests an expedited process. If the President believes the Bill may conflict with the Constitution, they can refer it to the Supreme Court to seek a judgment on its constitutionality. If the Supreme Court finds that the Bill is unconstitutional, the President cannot sign it into law.

The Constitution does not allow the President much freedom in this process. The President cannot introduce their own proposals and get the Dáil or Seanad to vote on them – a Bill can only be initiated by the Dáil or Seanad (known as the 'Houses of the Oireachtas'). Additionally, Article 26 of the Constitution prohibits the use of this process for a 'Money Bill' – a Bill that deals solely with taxes and levies – or for any Bill that proposes to amend the Constitution.

Once the President has signed the Bill, it becomes an Act and is added to the Statute Book. A copy is bound and sent to the registrar of the Supreme Court, and a version is also placed on the Irish Statute Book. A notice that the Bill has been signed into law is published in the Iris Oifigiúil, and a list of laws signed by the President is placed on the President's website.

Frequently asked questions