The Evolution Of An Idea Into Law

The process of an idea becoming a law is a complex and lengthy one, involving multiple stages and stakeholders. In the UK, an idea becomes a Bill after the government has consulted the public about its proposals. This essay will explore the journey of an idea through the legislative process, highlighting the key steps and stakeholders involved, from the initial proposal to its enactment as a law. The essay will also discuss the role of Parliament, the House of Commons, and the House of Lords in shaping and approving new laws, as well as the influence of public consultation and the potential impact of EU law.

The UK's constitution and parliamentary sovereignty

The UK's constitution is often described as 'partly written and wholly uncodified'. Unlike countries like the US and Germany, the UK's constitution is not contained in a single text. Instead, it is made up of laws passed in Parliament (statute law), rules established through practices over hundreds of years, and principles established in court decisions (common law).

The UK constitution is underpinned by the principle of parliamentary sovereignty, which makes Parliament the supreme legal authority in the UK. This means that Parliament can create or repeal any law, and no Parliament can pass laws that bind future Parliaments. The courts generally cannot overrule its legislation.

Parliament is made up of the House of Commons and the House of Lords. The House of Commons contains 650 Members of Parliament (MPs), who are directly elected every five years. The House of Lords, on the other hand, is unelected. Its members, known as peers, are appointed by the Queen on the recommendation of the Prime Minister.

The process of turning an idea into a law in the UK begins with a Green Paper, which invites interested parties to submit their views on a proposed law. After considering these views and making any necessary changes, the government produces a White Paper, detailing the final legislative proposals and the rationale behind the new law. This is followed by the introduction of a Bill, which must pass through several stages in both the House of Commons and the House of Lords before receiving Royal Assent and becoming an Act of Parliament.

While the UK's entry into the European Union in 1973 and the Human Rights Act 1998 have placed some limits on parliamentary sovereignty, these developments do not fundamentally undermine the principle. In theory, Parliament could repeal any of the laws implementing these changes, as it retains the ultimate legislative authority in the UK.

The role of the European Union in UK lawmaking

The United Kingdom's constitution is founded on the principle of parliamentary sovereignty. The will of Parliament, expressed through Acts of Parliament, is not constrained by any authority. However, the European Union's influence has altered this dynamic, with European laws taking precedence over Acts of Parliament. This has led to debates about whether the European Union is the new supreme institution, overriding national laws. Nonetheless, the European Union's law-making role in the UK is complex and evolving.

The European Union has its own legal order, separate from international law, and its laws have a direct or indirect effect on its member states, including the UK. The EU's legal system is based on the rule of law, with established legal remedies and procedures. The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) plays a pivotal role in reviewing the legality of the EU institutions' acts. The Treaties and general legal principles are at the apex of the EU's legal hierarchy, known as primary legislation. Secondary legislation, derived from the Treaties, and supplementary law also contribute to the EU's legal framework.

The EU's law-making process involves three main institutions: the European Parliament, representing EU citizens; the Council of the European Union, representing EU governments; and the European Commission, representing the EU's overall interests. This ordinary legislative procedure, formerly known as the co-decision procedure, involves these institutions working together to reach an agreement on legislation. The European Commission typically initiates the process by proposing new initiatives and assessing their potential impact through an 'impact assessment'. This assessment considers economic, social, and environmental factors and includes input from various stakeholders.

The European Parliament's role has evolved over time, gaining more influence in law-making. While initially only consulted, the Lisbon Treaty established the co-decision procedure, granting the Parliament joint decision-making powers. This procedure applies to a wide range of policy areas, including discrimination, free movement, workers' rights, asylum, and environmental protection. The Parliament's consent is also required for international agreements entered by the EU in areas under its legislative competence.

The UK's relationship with the European Union and the role of EU law in UK lawmaking have been dynamic and subject to change. The UK's withdrawal from the EU, often referred to as Brexit, further complicates the situation. The impact of EU law in the UK and the extent of the EU's influence on UK lawmaking are ongoing topics of discussion and negotiation between the two entities.

The process of turning an idea into a Bill

In the UK, the process of turning an idea into a Bill involves several stages, including public consultation, drafting of the Bill, and passage through the House of Commons and the House of Lords.

The first step is for the government to consult the public about its proposals. This is done through the production of a Green Paper, which invites interested parties to submit their views and suggestions. The government considers these submissions and may make changes to the original proposals. This is followed by the production of a White Paper, which details the final legislative proposals and explains the rationale behind the new law.

After the public consultation process, a Bill is produced and placed before Parliament. The first reading of the Bill is a formality, where the sponsoring MP briefly outlines it, and the Speaker of the House takes a vote on whether to consider it in more detail. If the Bill passes this stage, it moves on to the second reading, where MPs debate its principles, meaning, and overall worth. Once this debate concludes, the Speaker takes another vote on allowing the Bill to proceed to the committee stage.

During the committee stage, a small group of MPs, usually between 16 and 50, studies the Bill in detail. These MPs are selected based on their expertise in the relevant field. The committee may suggest amendments, which are then passed back to the House for further debate. At the report stage, the House debates any amendments proposed by the committee and can choose to accept or reject them. If the Bill passes this stage, it moves on to the third reading, which is another formality, where it receives a final "yes" or "no" vote.

Once a Bill has passed all the stages in the House of Commons, it is transferred to the House of Lords and goes through the same process. Ordinarily, a Bill must be passed by both houses before receiving Royal Assent to become an Act of Parliament. However, there are exceptions, such as the Parliament Acts of 1911 and 1949, which allow the House of Commons to pass an Act without the consent of the House of Lords.

The role of the House of Commons and House of Lords

The House of Commons and the House of Lords are the two chambers of the UK Parliament. The House of Commons is the lower house, while the House of Lords is the upper house. Here is an overview of their respective roles in the process of turning an idea into a law:

The House of Commons

The House of Commons is responsible for initiating and introducing bills that become laws. It is composed of elected representatives from different constituencies across the UK, who come together to debate issues and make decisions. The main role of the House of Commons is to introduce, debate, and pass bills. This process involves multiple stages, including readings, committee scrutiny, and voting. Members of Parliament (MPs) can express their opinions, raise concerns, propose amendments, and ultimately accept or reject a bill during this process. The House of Commons also plays a role in forming the government, deciding on budgets and taxes, and holding the government accountable.

The House of Lords

The House of Lords, on the other hand, is an unelected chamber. Its members, known as peers, are appointed for life by the Queen on the recommendation of the Prime Minister. The House of Lords has similar functions to the House of Commons but with some key differences. The House of Lords scrutinises bills, holds the government accountable, and considers and reports on public policy. While it cannot prevent bills from becoming laws, it can delay their enactment by up to one year. This ability to delay legislation allows the House of Lords to act as a "revising chamber," focusing on legislative detail and occasionally requesting the House of Commons to reconsider its plans. The House of Lords also has a role in holding the government accountable and introducing or amending legislation.

The Royal Assent and the enactment of laws

The Royal Assent is the final step in the legislative process for an Act of Parliament to become law. It is the method by which a monarch formally approves an Act of the legislature, either directly or through an official acting on their behalf. In the United Kingdom, the Sovereign may appear in person in the House of Lords or appoint Lords Commissioners to announce that Royal Assent has been granted. This typically takes place during a ceremony at the Palace of Westminster. However, Royal Assent is usually granted in a less ceremonial manner through letters patent.

Once a bill has passed all the required stages in both the House of Commons and the House of Lords, it is presented to the Sovereign for Royal Assent. The Sovereign has three formal options: they can grant Royal Assent, thereby making the bill an Act of Parliament; delay the bill's assent through the use of reserve powers, invoking a veto; or refuse Royal Assent on the advice of their ministers.

In modern times, the Royal Assent is considered a formality, and the monarch almost never withholds their approval. The last bill that was refused assent was the Scottish Militia Bill during Queen Anne's reign in 1708. While the monarch has the power to veto by withholding Royal Assent, this power is rarely exercised.

After Royal Assent is given, an announcement is made in both Houses – by the Lord Speaker in the Lords and the Speaker in the Commons. The legislation within the bill may come into effect immediately, after a set period, or only after a commencement order by a government minister. If there is no commencement order, the Act will come into force from midnight at the start of the day of Royal Assent.

Frequently asked questions