Dr Disrespect: Breaking Laws And Streaming Rules

Dr Disrespect, also known as Guy Beahm, broke the law when he filmed inside a men's public bathroom during a live stream at the E3 expo in Los Angeles. This incident, which exposed people who were inside the bathroom, resulted in a multi-week ban from the Twitch platform and his removal from the E3 event. Dr Disrespect later broke his silence on the incident, apologizing for his actions and acknowledging that he was unaware of the legal repercussions of his behaviour at the time. In addition to this, Dr Disrespect has also faced separate allegations of inappropriate conduct with a minor, which led to his permanent ban from Twitch and the termination of relationships with associated business partners.

Filming in a public bathroom

In 2019, Dr Disrespect, or Guy Beahm, broke the law by filming in a public bathroom at the E3 expo in Los Angeles. Beahm, who was streaming on Twitch, entered a men's public bathroom with his cameraman, who filmed the interior of the bathroom, inadvertently capturing several men in the background using the bathroom facilities and washing their hands.

Filming inside a public bathroom is against the law in California. Even if this were not the case, Twitch's Terms of Service prohibit streamers from violating the privacy of individuals. Beahm's actions constituted an infringement of Twitch's rules, as he showed live footage from inside a bathroom, regardless of whether he was the one filming or not.

Beahm later broke his silence on the incident, apologising for his actions and acknowledging that he and his cameraman were “unaware of the legalities" of filming in the bathroom. He stated that they had no malicious intentions and were simply "capturing an adventure" as part of the "Dr Disrespect" livestream experience.

While it is generally not illegal to film in an empty public restroom, it is important to be mindful of privacy laws and obtain permission if necessary. Legal issues can arise when filming people in the bathroom who have a reasonable expectation of privacy.

Inappropriate sexual conduct with a minor

In 2020, Dr Disrespect was banned from Twitch for sending inappropriate messages to an underage girl. Two former Twitch employees alleged that the streamer was banned for "sexting a minor". One of the former employees, Cody Conners, who worked on the company's strategic partnerships team, stated that Dr Disrespect was "trying to meet up with her at TwitchCon". Another anonymous former employee provided a similar account, confirming that Dr Disrespect had exchanged messages with a minor and planned to meet up with them at TwitchCon.

In response to these allegations, Dr Disrespect, whose real name is Herschel "Guy" Beahm, released a statement admitting to "having mutual conversations with a minor that sometimes leaned too much in the direction of being inappropriate". He claimed that "nothing illegal happened, no pictures were shared, no crimes were committed, [and that he] never even met the individual". He took responsibility, stating that he should not have entertained these conversations as an adult, a husband, and a father.

However, a former Twitch trust and safety employee who worked for the platform at the time of Beahm's ban disputed his claims, stating that Beahm continued to send sexually explicit messages even after learning that the recipient was underage. The employee recalled that during the conversation, the individual disclosed their underage status, to which Beahm indicated that it was "no problem" and proceeded to send more graphic messages.

As a result of the allegations, Midnight Society, the gaming studio co-founded by Beahm, terminated its relationship with him. YouTube and Facebook Gaming also did not offer him exclusive partnerships following his ban from Twitch.

Exposing people in the bathroom

In 2019, Dr Disrespect (real name Herschel "Guy" Beahm) was banned from the E3 gaming showcase and suspended from Twitch after filming himself inside a bathroom at the event. During an IRL stream, Dr Disrespect walked into a men's public bathroom and filmed its interior, exposing people who were inside. While Dr Disrespect's cameraman followed him inside, the streamer called for the camera to follow him to the front of a bathroom stall, livestreaming several men in the background from various angles.

Although Dr Disrespect did not hold the camera and his cameraman did not focus on anyone but him, filming inside a public bathroom is against California law. California Penal Code 647(j) PC states that it is illegal for a person to view the inside of a room or area in which a person has a "reasonable expectation of privacy". According to this law, a person has a reasonable expectation of privacy when using a toilet, sitting in a bedroom, or changing clothes in a fitting room, among other scenarios.

In his apology, Beahm wrote that he and his cameraman were so into the E3 IRL journey that they became blind to what was and was not okay. He also stated that they had no ill intentions and that they were focused on capturing an adventure. As a result of the incident, Dr Disrespect received a two-week ban from Twitch and was banned from the E3 event.

Breaking California law

In 2019, Guy "Dr DisRespect" Beahm was banned from Twitch for filming in a men's public bathroom at the E3 conference. While Dr DisRespect was in the bathroom, his cameraman followed him inside and filmed several men using the bathroom in the background, from washing their hands to using urinals.

Although Dr DisRespect was not holding the camera and his cameraman was only filming him, filming inside a public bathroom is against California law. Dr DisRespect admitted that he was unaware of the legalities of filming in a public bathroom at the time. He apologised for his actions, stating that he and his cameraman had no ill intentions and were simply "capturing the E3 event through the character".

In addition to breaking California law, Dr DisRespect's actions also infringed upon Twitch's Terms of Service, which forbid streamers from breaking any individual's privacy. As a result of the incident, Dr DisRespect was banned from Twitch and E3, and his director, Alex, was fired.

Infraction of Twitch's rules

Dr Disrespect, the popular streamer and internet personality, was banned from Twitch for filming in a public bathroom at the E3 expo in Los Angeles in 2019. While livestreaming, Dr Disrespect, whose real name is Guy Beahm, entered a men's public bathroom with his cameraman, who filmed several men using the bathroom facilities. This was a violation of California law, which forbids filming in public bathrooms.

Even if Dr Disrespect had not broken the law, his actions were still an infraction of Twitch's rules. Twitch's Terms of Service forbid streamers from invading the privacy of others. By filming inside a bathroom and showing live footage on his channel, Dr Disrespect broke Twitch's rules, regardless of whether he was holding the camera or not.

In the aftermath of the incident, Dr Disrespect issued an apology, stating that he and his cameraman were so into the E3 IRL journey that they became "blind" to what was and was not acceptable. He also claimed that they had no ill intentions and that their only goal was to capture an adventure.

Dr Disrespect's channel was banned from Twitch for an unspecified period of time, and he was also banned from the E3 event. The incident sparked debates within the Twitch community about the platform's role in moderating the behaviour of its creators and the appropriateness of the punishment meted out.

Frequently asked questions