Petitions: The Power To Change Laws

A petition is a formal request made to a government agency or public official, often by a group of individuals. In the context of law, petitions are typically addressed to a court, requesting a court order or appealing a court's decision. The right to petition is protected by the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, recognising the importance of allowing individuals, including those not eligible to vote, to express their opinions and influence political decisions. This article will explore the legal requirements and processes involved in transforming a petition into law, including the necessary steps, signature requirements, and the role of legislative bodies in enacting policies based on petitions.

Petitioning in the US: a long tradition of asserting rights

Petitioning is a long-standing tradition in the US, with roots stretching back to the country's founding. The right to petition is enshrined in the First Amendment of the US Constitution, which prohibits Congress from abridging "the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances". This right has been expanded over time and is no longer confined to demands for "a redress of grievances", but also includes demands for the government to act in the interest and prosperity of the petitioners.

The practice of petitioning has a long history, dating back to ancient Egypt, where workers petitioned for improved working conditions. In the US, petitioning became a common practice in the 18th century, open to everyone, including those who could not vote. It became a crucial means for individuals and groups to express their opinions, influence legislators, and shape the political landscape of the fledgling nation. Scholars have found that petitioning led to more legislative action in early America than any other source.

The inclusion of the right to petition in the First Amendment highlights its importance in the eyes of the framers of the Constitution. The right to petition is a fundamental guarantee of civil liberties and is considered a basic practice of democracy. The act of adding one's name to an official appeal asserts not only identity but also rights. Historically, petitioning has been a way for disenfranchised groups, including women, African Americans, and Native Americans, to engage with elected officials and participate in politics.

The first significant exercise of the right to petition in the US was the submission of over a thousand petitions to Congress calling for an end to slavery, signed by approximately 130,000 citizens. This led to a series of gag rules being adopted by the House of Representatives, which automatically tabled all such petitions. These rules were eventually repealed in 1844 on the basis that they violated the Constitutional right to petition the government.

Today, petitioning remains an important tool for citizens to assert their rights and influence policy. With the advent of the internet, online petitions have become a common way to raise awareness and gather support for a cause. However, the goals remain the same: to assert strength in numbers and compel policymakers to listen and act.

Types of petitions: political, legal, public purpose, internet

Petitions are a way for individuals to express their opinions and assert their rights. They are a request to a government agency or public official, made on behalf of a group. The act of signing a petition is an assertion of identity and rights. In the 18th century, petitioning was open to everyone, including those who couldn't vote, and it became a way to influence the political landscape. The right to petition is protected by the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

There are four main types of petitions:

Political Petitions

These have a specific form and address a specific rule set by the state or federal government. Examples include nominating petitions filed by political candidates to get on a ballot, petitions to recall elected officials, and petitions for ballot initiatives. They are shared publicly to solicit signers, who must usually be U.S. citizens, registered voters, and residents of the relevant election district.

Legal Petitions

These are requests made to a court to issue a specific order in a pending case or lawsuit. They are typically filed by attorneys according to court rules and using specific forms. Legal petitions are not shared beyond the court and involved parties.

Public Purpose Petitions

These are requests made to officials, policymakers, government bodies, or administrative agencies, asking them to take or refrain from taking a specific action. They are shared publicly to acquire signers and typically have minimal or no requirements for participation.

Internet Petitions

These are conducted entirely online and are often effective at raising public awareness about an issue. They are not always specific about the actions to be taken and do not follow established civic or political processes. There are no legal requirements for internet petitions.

In addition to these four main types, there are also various other types of petitions that can be filed in court, such as those related to child custody, civil and misdemeanour cases, and bankruptcy.

Petitions vs. complaints: what's the difference?

Petitions and complaints are both legal documents that can be used to initiate a civil action or lawsuit. However, there are some key differences between the two.

A petition is a formal request made to a government agency, public official, or court, typically by an individual, group, or organisation. It usually seeks a court order and states the reasons why one is needed. In the context of a lawsuit, a petition is filed by a petitioner against a respondent. It asks the court to provide a court order, rather than seeking damages or compelling a defendant to start or stop an action.

On the other hand, a complaint is filed by a plaintiff against a defendant. It seeks damages or to force the defendant to start or stop doing something. Complaints are often used in litigation, although the term "filing suit" is also used. Complaints are typically associated with historical courts of law in the English common law system, and are used in cases seeking money damages, possession of real estate, or specific items of personal property.

The terms "petition" and "complaint" are sometimes used interchangeably, but they are not the same. The choice between the two depends on the type of case, the jurisdiction, and custom and history. For example, in some cases, a petition is used to initiate a probate case, a bankruptcy case, or a divorce case, while in other cases, a complaint might be used.

In addition to petitions and complaints, there are other terms used to initiate legal action, such as "motion", "application", "notice of civil claim", and "indictment".

Petitions in the appeals process

Petitions are a formal way to request action from a government agency or public official. In the appeals process, petitions are used to seek review of a lower court's decision or to request a rehearing. Here is an overview of how petitions function within the appeals process:

Initiating an Appeal

An appeal is typically initiated by filing a notice of appeal or a petition for review of a final decision made by a district court or agency. This marks the beginning of the appeals process. The petition is assigned a docket number, and the parties involved are required to complete the necessary forms for the appeal to proceed. The Clerk's Office will notify the parties of any potential issues, such as unpaid fees or jurisdictional concerns.

Briefing and Decision

Once all the necessary paperwork is in order, the Clerk will issue a briefing schedule. The brief is the primary focus of the appeal, where the appellant presents their legal arguments in writing. After all the briefs have been submitted, they are sent to a panel of judges for a decision. In most cases, the judges' decision is based solely on the briefs, without any new evidence or testimony presented. This decision is usually the final word in the case, unless specific exceptions apply.

Requests for Rehearing or Further Review

If a litigant is dissatisfied with the decision made by the Court of Appeals, they can file a petition for rehearing within the same court. Additionally, they have the option to petition the Supreme Court to review the case by filing a "writ of certiorari". The Supreme Court is not obligated to grant this request and typically only does so when the case involves significant legal principles or conflicting interpretations of a law by different appellate courts.

Understanding Different Types of Appeals

It is important to note that the appeals process can vary depending on the type of case. For example, appeals involving bankruptcy, social security benefits, or criminal cases may follow slightly different procedures and be directed to specific courts or panels of judges.

In summary, petitions play a crucial role in the appeals process by providing individuals or groups with a mechanism to seek review or reconsideration of a lower court's decision. The appeals process involves strict procedures and timelines that must be followed for a petition to be successful.

The freedom of petition: enshrined in the First Amendment

The right to petition is a cornerstone of democracy, and in the United States, it is enshrined in the First Amendment. The First Amendment protects the freedoms of religion, expression, and assembly, and crucially, it guarantees the right of citizens to petition their government. This right to petition is a powerful tool for individuals and groups to express their opinions and influence public policy.

The text of the First Amendment states that "Congress shall make no law [...] abridging [...] the right of the people [...] to petition the Government for a redress of grievances." This amendment ensures that citizens can address their grievances to the government without fear of legal repercussions. The inclusion of this right in the First Amendment underscores its fundamental importance in American democracy.

The history of petitioning in the US dates back to its early days as a nation. Even before the American Revolution, colonists exercised their freedom to petition King George III, then still seeing themselves as Englishmen, to address their concerns. When their petitions were ignored, the American Revolution began, ultimately leading to the independence of the United States and the adoption of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, which includes the First Amendment.

The right to petition has been used throughout US history to advocate for significant social and political changes. For example, abolitionists collected petitions to raise awareness and pressure Congress to end slavery. Women also played a significant role in using petitions to drive social change, with the first nationally organized petitioning drive in the US being led by women protesting the removal of Cherokee Indians from their native lands. Later, women's groups organized petitions to end slavery and fight for women's suffrage, with petitions playing a significant role in the eventual passage of the 19th Amendment.

The right to petition is not limited to the federal government but applies to local and state governments as well. This ensures that citizens can address issues at all levels of government. The format and requirements for petitions can vary depending on the type and level of government being petitioned, but they all serve the same purpose: to give citizens a voice and a means to influence the political landscape.

Frequently asked questions