Antigone's Civil Disobedience: Justified Or Not?

Antigone, the main character in Sophocles' tragedy 'Antigone', justifies breaking the law by prioritising her family and her religious beliefs. Antigone's brother, Polyneices, is considered a traitor to his homeland and is denied a burial by Creon, the King of Thebes. Antigone, however, believes that her duty to her family and her religious beliefs are more important than the king's law, and so she performs funeral rites for her brother. She is aware of the consequences of her actions and accepts her punishment, valuing her family honour and religious customs above the law.

Antigone believed she was obeying a higher power than Creon's imperfect man-made legislation

Antigone's actions in the play are driven by her allegiance to her family, her moral conscience, and her religious beliefs. She believes that her duty as a sister outweighs any decree issued by Creon, the new king of Thebes. Antigone's brother, Polynices, was killed in battle while fighting against Thebes, leading Creon to label him a traitor and forbid anyone from burying his body as punishment. Antigone, however, is unwavering in her belief that her brother deserves a proper burial.

Antigone justifies her actions by appealing to a higher power and a set of laws that exist beyond those created by man. She argues that the laws of the gods are unwritten, ancient, and eternal, and therefore supersede any mortal laws created by Creon. Antigone believes that her actions are in accordance with divine law and that her duty as a sister is to honour her brother in death, regardless of his actions in life.

Antigone's strong conviction in her religious beliefs and natural law is evident in her confrontation with Creon. She boldly proclaims, "Nor did I think your edict had such force that you, a mere mortal, could override the gods, the great unwritten, unshakable traditions. They are alive, nor just today or yesterday: they live forever." Here, Antigone is challenging Creon's authority and questioning his ability to override the laws of the divine. She believes that Creon's laws are imperfect and inferior to the laws of the gods, which she holds sacred.

Antigone's unwavering devotion to her religious beliefs and natural law leads her to accept the consequences of her actions. She is aware that breaking Creon's law may result in her death, but she welcomes it, stating, "I say I'd gain something" and "to die for the act of bringing honour to my brother will bring me glory." Antigone's willingness to face death rather than obey Creon's law further highlights her belief that she is obeying a higher power and a more just law.

Antigone's actions and justifications in the play present a powerful challenge to Creon's authority and question the validity of his laws. By appealing to a higher power, Antigone justifies her disobedience and reinforces the idea that some laws are more fundamental and sacred than those created by man.

Antigone's actions were motivated by her allegiance to her family

Antigone's allegiance to her family is further demonstrated in her interactions with her sister, Ismene. Antigone demands that Ismene prove herself to be "a true sister or a traitor to your family" by helping her bury Polynices. Ismene is afraid of the consequences of breaking the law and refuses to help Antigone, showing that Antigone's loyalty to her family is stronger than her fear of punishment.

Antigone's actions also reflect her loyalty to her father, Oedipus, with whom she went into exile. When Oedipus went into exile, Antigone chose to accompany him, demonstrating her devotion to her family.

Additionally, Antigone was engaged to Creon's son, Haemon, who was also her cousin. This family connection may have further complicated Antigone's allegiance, as she was defying her uncle and future father-in-law by breaking the law.

Overall, Antigone's actions in the play are driven by her strong sense of loyalty to her family, even when it means breaking the law and risking her own life. She is willing to make sacrifices and take a stand against those in power to honour her family and do what she believes is right.

Antigone believed her brother deserved a proper burial

Antigone, the main character in Sophocles' tragedy "Antigone", chose to honour her family instead of obeying the laws of Creon, the king of Thebes. Antigone's brother, Polyneices, was considered a traitor to his homeland, and Creon decreed that he should not be buried. However, Antigone strongly disagreed and believed that her brother deserved a proper burial. She knew that a proper burial was the right thing to do and would please the gods.

Antigone's decision to break the law and bury her brother was driven by her loyalty to her family and her religious beliefs. She believed that basic rites should be entitled to everyone, regardless of their actions. In her view, her brother deserved to be honoured and mourned by his loved ones, as dictated by natural law and religious tradition. Antigone felt that Creon's law, which condemned her brother to rot and be eaten by animals, was inhumane and unjust.

Antigone's actions were also a form of civil disobedience against Creon's tyranny. She believed that Creon's laws were immoral and unjust, and she was willing to risk her life to challenge them. Antigone knew that the punishment for disobeying Creon's decree was death, but she was unwavering in her defiance. She even insulted Creon, calling him a fool and a tyrant. Antigone's bravery and determination to do what she believed was right, even in the face of severe consequences, is a testament to her character.

Furthermore, Antigone believed that she was following a higher power and the laws of the gods by burying her brother. She argued that the laws of the gods were more important than any man-made legislation. Antigone's religious perspective was a significant motivator for her actions, as she felt that she was obeying the gods' will by providing a proper burial for her brother.

Overall, Antigone's decision to break the law and bury her brother was justified in her eyes by her family ties, religious beliefs, and the belief that she was following a higher power. She was willing to face the consequences of her actions, even death, because she felt so strongly about doing what she believed was right.

Antigone believed she was following God's law

Antigone's decision to bury Polynices was influenced by her religious perspective and family ties. She believed that everyone, regardless of their actions, deserved basic funeral rites, as commanded by the gods. Antigone felt that leaving her brother unburied and allowing his corpse to be eaten by animals would be a disgrace, and she was willing to risk her life to ensure he received a proper burial.

Antigone's actions can be seen as an act of civil disobedience, where she prioritised her religious beliefs and moral conscience over the laws of the state. She knew that her actions were against the law, but she believed that following God's law was more important than obeying Creon's decree. Antigone's unwavering defiance, even in the face of death, highlights her strong conviction that she was doing what was right, despite the consequences.

Antigone's justification for breaking the law centres on her belief that she was following a higher power and a more just law than that of King Creon. She saw Creon's law as immoral and unjust, especially in the context of her religious and familial duties. By burying Polynices, Antigone was honouring her brother and ensuring his soul could rest in peace, which was more crucial to her than any mortal law.

Antigone believed family is more important than the law

Antigone, the main character of Sophocles' tragedy "Antigone", believed that family was more important than the law. This is demonstrated by her decision to bury her brother Polyneices, despite King Creon's decree that he should be left unburied as a traitor. Antigone's actions were motivated by her allegiance to her family and her religious beliefs. She believed that the laws of the gods were superior to the laws of man and that it was her duty as a sister to ensure Polyneices received a proper burial.

Antigone's strong sense of family loyalty is evident in her willingness to risk her life to honour her brother. She knew that breaking Creon's law carried a death sentence, yet she chose to defy the king and perform funeral rites for Polyneices. Antigone justifies her actions by arguing that Creon's law goes against the traditions and ordinances of the gods. She believes that the gods' laws are eternal and unchanging, while Creon's law is temporary and subject to the whims of a mortal man.

Antigone's devotion to her family is further highlighted in her interactions with her sister, Ismene. Antigone tries to enlist Ismene's help in burying Polyneices, but Ismene refuses, citing her respect for the law and her duty as a citizen. Antigone, however, is unwavering in her commitment to family, even when faced with the prospect of death. She tells Ismene, "I will raise a mound for him, for my dear brother" (Antigone 94-95). Antigone's determination to bury Polyneices, despite the potential consequences, demonstrates her unwavering belief that family comes before the law.

Additionally, Antigone's actions can be seen as a form of civil disobedience against Creon's unjust law. She believes that the law prohibiting Polyneices' burial is wrong and that it is her duty to challenge it. Antigone's decision to bury her brother is an act of defiance against Creon's authority and a statement that family loyalty supersedes legal obligations.

Antigone's strong sense of family loyalty, coupled with her religious beliefs, leads her to prioritise family over the law. She is willing to face the consequences of her actions, even death, to ensure that her brother receives the funeral rites she believes he deserves. Antigone's courage and conviction in standing up against Creon's decree showcase her unwavering belief that family is more important than any man-made law.

Frequently asked questions