Pope Francis' Abortion Law Stance: A Complex Perspective

Pope Francis has been very clear about his stance on abortion law. He has described abortion as murder, homicide, and like hiring a hitman. He has also said that abortion is a crime and absolutely evil. Pope Francis has urged Catholic bishops to deal with the problem in a pastoral way rather than a political way. He has also criticised countries and international institutions that promote abortion as an essential service in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Pope Francis has called abortion murder and homicide

Pope Francis has been unambiguously clear about his stance on abortion, stating that "abortion is murder". He has described the procedure as homicide, comparing it to Nazi eugenics and "hiring a hitman".

The Pope's statements on abortion have been more graphic and striking than even those of his predecessors. He has emphasised that the humanity of an unborn child must always be protected, and that abortion is a human problem, not a theological one.

In his comments, Pope Francis has drawn on embryology textbooks, stating that "at the third week after conception, all the organs are already there, even the DNA... it is a human life, this human life must be respected". He has also said that abortion is against the Hippocratic Oath, and that it is a "crime" and an "absolute evil".

Pope Francis has criticised the idea that abortion is a "woman's right to choose", stating that "abortion is more than an issue. Abortion is murder". He has also criticised the notion that abortion is a "benefit" to women, calling it "false compassion". Instead, he has argued that abortion "compounds the grief of many women who now carry with them deep physical and spiritual wounds".

The Pope has further stated that abortion is incompatible with the protection of nature and the environment, and that it is a form of throwaway culture, where human life is disposable. He has urged those who defend abortion to consider whether it is right to take out a human life to solve a problem or to hire a hitman to kill a human life.

He has compared abortion to hiring a hitman

Pope Francis has been vocal about his stance on abortion, and his statements on the issue have been more graphic and striking than those of his predecessors. On 10 October 2018, he compared abortion to "hiring a hitman" during his weekly catechesis. He asked:

> How can an action that ends an innocent and defenseless life in its blossoming stage be therapeutic, civilized or simply human? I ask you: Is it right to 'do away with' a human life in order to solve a problem? Is it right to hire a hitman in order to solve a problem? One cannot. It is not right to 'do away with' a human being, however small, in order to solve a problem. It is like hiring a hitman.

The Pope has repeated this analogy many times since, including when he was asked about the permissibility of abortion in the case of a woman who has been trafficked and becomes pregnant by rape.

In his statements, Pope Francis has emphasised the humanity of the unborn child and the need to protect innocent life. He has also criticised the idea that abortion is a "woman's right to choose", referring to it instead as "murder" and "homicide". He has instructed bishops to deal with the issue in a pastoral rather than a political way, encouraging them to act with closeness, compassion and tenderness.

Pope Francis has criticised the throwaway culture of abortion

Pope Francis has been vocal about his stance on abortion, making it clear that the procedure is "homicide" and "murder". He has criticised the "throwaway culture" of abortion, comparing it to hiring a hitman and Nazi eugenics. The Pope has emphasised that abortion is a human issue, not a religious one, and that it is a crime and absolutely evil.

In his statements, Pope Francis has expressed concern about the normalisation of abortion and the denial of the existence of a human life. He has also prayed at cemeteries for aborted babies and encouraged compassion for women who have had abortions, acknowledging the deep physical and spiritual wounds they may carry.

While maintaining the Catholic Church's position on abortion as a grave evil, Pope Francis has urged bishops to approach the issue pastorally rather than politically. He has emphasised that communion is not a prize for the perfect but a gift, even for those who do not align with Church teachings.

Pope Francis has been unambiguous in his opposition to abortion, stating that it is the deliberate destruction of a human life and must be addressed as such. He has consistently preached this message throughout his papacy, providing strong statements that build upon the Catholic Church's clear pronouncements against abortion.

He has also called abortion a tragedy and a plague

Pope Francis has been unambiguously clear that the humanity of an unborn child must always be protected. He has called abortion a "grave evil" and a grave sin, comparing it to murder, homicide, and hiring a hitman. He has also called abortion a tragedy and a plague, saying:

> The tragedy of abortion is experienced by some with a superficial awareness, as if not realizing the extreme harm that such an act entails...The plague of abortion is an attack on life.

In 2016, Pope Francis said:

> Abortion is not a “lesser evil”. It is a crime. It is wiping out one to save another. That is what the mafia does. It is a crime, it is absolutely evil.

He has also said that abortion is not a religious issue, but a human one, and that it must be addressed as such. He has criticised the idea that abortion is a benefit to women or a form of 'false compassion':

> The predominant school of thought sometimes leads to ‘false compassion‘ which holds that it is a benefit to women to promote abortion...Abortion compounds the grief of many women who now carry with them deep physical and spiritual wounds after succumbing to the pressures of a secular culture which devalues God’s gift of sexuality and the right to life of the unborn.

Pope Francis has also criticised the idea of abortion as an essential service in humanitarian responses to crises such as the COVID-19 pandemic.

Pope Francis has said that abortion is not a religious issue

Pope Francis has been very vocal about his stance on abortion, calling it "murder" and comparing it to "homicide". However, he has also stated that abortion is not a religious issue, but a human one. In 2018, he said:

> "The issue of abortion is not a religious issue: we are not opposed to abortion for religious reasons. No. It is a human issue and has to be addressed as such. The abortion question has to be studied from an anthropological standpoint."

Pope Francis has emphasised that the Church's opposition to abortion is based on the belief that it is the deliberate destruction of a human life, and not solely on religious doctrine. He has also criticised the idea that abortion can be promoted as a "benefit" or "compassionate" solution for women, arguing that it instead causes deep physical and spiritual wounds.

The Pope has consistently spoken out against abortion, calling it a grave sin and a tragedy. He has also prayed at cemeteries for aborted babies and encouraged organisations that help prevent abortion. However, he has also offered forgiveness and mercy for those who have had abortions, stating that there is no sin that God's mercy cannot reach.

While Pope Francis has been clear about his opposition to abortion, he has also urged Catholic bishops to approach the issue from a pastoral rather than a political standpoint. He has criticised bishops for dealing with abortion in a political manner and has emphasised the need for compassion and tenderness in addressing the issue.

Frequently asked questions