Royal Assent: The Law-Making Process Simplified

Royal Assent is the final step in the legislative process for a bill to become law. Once a bill has completed all the parliamentary stages in both Houses, it is ready to receive Royal Assent. This is when the monarch formally agrees to make the bill into an Act of Parliament. The legislation within the bill may come into effect immediately after Royal Assent, or after a set period, or only after a commencement order by a government minister. While there is no set time period between the conclusion of the consideration of amendments and Royal Assent, the bill officially becomes law once it receives Royal Assent.

Royal Assent is the final step for a bill to become a law

In the United Kingdom, a bill is presented for Royal Assent after it has passed all the required stages in both the House of Commons and the House of Lords. The bill is then presented to the Sovereign, who has the following options: grant Royal Assent, delay the bill's assent, or refuse Royal Assent. The Royal Assent ceremony in Canada is based on British tradition.

In some jurisdictions, Royal Assent is equivalent to promulgation, while in others, it is a separate step. In modern constitutional monarchies, Royal Assent is considered a formality. Even in nations that theoretically permit their monarchs to withhold assent, such as the United Kingdom, Norway, the Netherlands, Liechtenstein, and Monaco, the monarch rarely does so except in dire political emergencies or on the advice of the government.

The process of granting Royal Assent is often associated with an elaborate ceremony. In the United Kingdom, the Sovereign may appear personally in the House of Lords or appoint Lords Commissioners to announce that Royal Assent has been granted. However, Royal Assent is usually granted in a less ceremonial manner through letters patent.

In Canada, the Governor General may grant Royal Assent in person during a ceremony in the Senate or by a written declaration notifying Parliament of their agreement with the bill. The Royal Assent ceremony takes place in the Senate, as the Sovereign is traditionally barred from the House of Commons. The ceremony involves various rituals, such as the Speaker moving to sit beside the throne, the entrance of the Governor General, and the summoning of members of Parliament.

Royal Assent is granted by a monarch or their representative

Royal Assent is the final step in the legislative process, where a monarch or their representative formally approves a bill. This approval transforms the bill into an Act of Parliament, or law. In the United Kingdom, this role is performed by the Queen, while in Canada, it is the Governor General or one of their deputies who carries out this task.

The Royal Assent ceremony in Canada is based on British tradition, but it has evolved over time. Until 2002, Royal Assent in Canada could only be granted during a traditional ceremony in the Senate Chamber. However, since June of that year, bills can also be granted Royal Assent by written declaration, as outlined in the Royal Assent Act. Despite this change, a traditional ceremony must still be held at least twice each year and for the first appropriation bill of each session of Parliament.

The process of granting Royal Assent involves elaborate rituals. In the United Kingdom, the Sovereign may appear in person in the House of Lords or appoint Lords Commissioners to announce that Royal Assent has been granted during a ceremony at the Palace of Westminster. Alternatively, Royal Assent is often granted in a less ceremonial manner through letters patent.

In Canada, the Governor General may grant Royal Assent either in person during a ceremony in the Senate or by a written declaration notifying Parliament of their agreement with the bill. The Royal Assent ceremony takes place in the Senate, as the Sovereign is traditionally barred from the House of Commons. On the day of the event, the Speaker of the Senate reads a notice indicating when the Governor General or their deputy will arrive, and the Senate cannot adjourn until after the ceremony. The Speaker moves to sit beside the throne, and the Governor General enters and takes the Speaker's chair. The Usher of the Black Rod then summons the members of Parliament, who follow back to the Senate, led by the Sergeant-at-Arms carrying the mace of the House of Commons.

During the ceremony, the Governor General signifies their assent by a nod of the head, and this assent is announced by the Clerk of the Parliaments. If there are supply bills to receive assent, the Speaker of the House of Commons reads their titles, and the Governor General once again nods to signify assent. Once all bills have been assented to, the Clerk of the Senate recites a formal statement, and the Governor General departs.

Royal Assent is a formality in modern constitutional monarchies

In modern constitutional monarchies, Royal Assent is considered a formality. Although the monarch has the right to refuse Royal Assent, in practice, this is very rare. The last time a monarch withheld Royal Assent was in 1708, during the reign of Queen Anne, when she vetoed the Scottish Militia Bill on the advice of her ministers.

Royal Assent is the final step in the legislative process for a bill to become law. Once a bill has been passed by both houses of Parliament, it is presented to the monarch for approval. This is typically done during a ceremony known as a Commission, where diplomatic letters patent authorise Commissioners to declare Assent in the name of the Sovereign. There is also an older method of Royal Assent by notification, where the Sovereign informs the House of Lords that they have granted Assent, and the clerk reads out the titles of the acts that have received it.

The process of Royal Assent underscores the constitutional principle that the Sovereign 'reigns but does not rule', adhering to the democratic principle that elected representatives make and pass legislation. While the power to refuse technically remains within the Sovereign's remit, to exercise it would provoke a constitutional crisis. This is because the modern democratic structure of countries like the UK functions on the basis that the government has the mandate of the people.

Royal Assent is therefore a critical juncture in the legislative process, symbolising the final accord between democratic institutions of governance and the constitutional monarchy. It solidifies respect for democratic processes while maintaining a link to the traditional rites of the constitutional monarchy.

The legislation within a bill may come into effect immediately after Royal Assent

The process of a bill becoming a law varies across different nations and jurisdictions. In this response, I will focus on the UK, Canada, and Australia.

In the UK, the Queen formally agrees to make a bill an Act of Parliament (law) through Royal Assent. There is no set time period between the conclusion of the consideration of amendments and Royal Assent. The legislation within the bill may come into effect immediately after Royal Assent, after a set period, or only after a commencement order by a government minister. If there is no commencement order, the Act will come into force from midnight on the day of Royal Assent. The practical implementation of an Act is the responsibility of the government department, not Parliament.

In Canada, Royal Assent is given by the Governor General or one of their deputies, such as a Justice of the Supreme Court of Canada or a senior official. The legislative process requires the participation and approval of the three components of Parliament: the Sovereign, the Senate, and the House of Commons. While an Act may come into force on the day Royal Assent is given, some bills specify that the Act will come into force on a specific day or a day determined by a formal announcement (proclamation). The government, on the recommendation of the minister responsible for legislation, decides when the legislation will be enacted.

In Australia, Royal Assent is granted or withheld by the realm's sovereign or, more frequently, by their representative, the Governor-General. In the special case of a bill proposing to amend the constitution, the bill must receive majority support in a referendum before receiving Royal Assent. All other bills passed normally by Parliament become Acts of Parliament once they have received Royal Assent.

In summary, the legislation within a bill may come into effect immediately after Royal Assent, depending on the specific jurisdiction and the provisions of the bill. The timing of a bill becoming law can vary, and it is important to consider the unique processes in different nations and jurisdictions.

Royal Assent is accompanied by a traditional ceremony

In Canada, Royal Assent is accompanied by a traditional ceremony. This ceremony is steeped in history and tradition, with the country inheriting the practice from the United Kingdom. The ceremony brings together the three constituent elements of Parliament: the House of Commons, the Senate, and the Crown. It is a symbolic moment that represents the very essence of constitutional parliamentary democracy in Canada.

The traditional ceremony unfolds as follows: once a bill has been passed in identical form by both the Senate and the House of Commons, the Governor General, as the representative of the Crown, attends Parliament in the Senate Chamber. The Members from the House of Commons are summoned by the Usher of the Black Rod to join their Senate counterparts. With all parties present, the bills to receive Royal Assent are presented to the Governor General or a Justice of the Supreme Court of Canada, who may act as the Deputy of the Governor General. The formal request for Royal Assent is made, followed by the reading of the bill's title. The Governor General or their Deputy then signifies assent with a nod of the head.

The ceremony is not just a symbolic tradition but also a legal requirement. The Royal Assent Act mandates that the traditional ceremony be held at least twice each calendar year and for the first appropriation bill of each session of Parliament. This ensures that the important link to historical parliamentary practices is maintained, even as modern alternatives, such as written declarations, are introduced.

The Royal Assent ceremony is a solemn and intricate ritual that serves as a reminder of the collaborative nature of law-making in Canada. It brings together the different components of Parliament, showcasing their unity in the legislative process. The ceremony is a testament to the country's commitment to constitutional parliamentary democracy and the value placed on the sanctity of law.

Frequently asked questions