Very Few Private Member's Bills Become Law

Private Members' Bills (PMBs) are pieces of legislation introduced by MPs or members of the House of Lords who are not government ministers. While they can technically be passed and become law, this rarely happens. Instead, they are often used to draw attention to a certain issue, gather support from other members of the house, and influence government legislation. There are three ways to introduce a Private Member's Bill: the Ballot, Ten-Minute Rule, and Presentation. Ballot Bills have the highest chance of becoming law as they are prioritised during debates. However, due to limited parliamentary time allocated to PMBs, only a minority become law.

Private Members' Bills (PMBs) are introduced by MPs and peers who are not government ministers

Private Members' Bills (PMBs) are public bills introduced by MPs and Lords who are not government ministers. They are designed to change the law as it applies to the general population and can be introduced in either the House of Commons or the House of Lords. While only a minority of PMBs become law, they can create publicity around an issue and affect legislation indirectly.

There are three ways to introduce a PMB: the Ballot, the Ten-Minute Rule, and Presentation. Ballot bills have the highest chance of becoming law, as they are prioritised during the limited time allocated for debating. During the ballot, members wishing to propose a bill put their names into a ballot box, and those selected can then give a first reading of their bill.

Ten-Minute Rule bills allow MPs to make a ten-minute speech on a piece of legislation they want to pass. Following this, another MP can make an opposing speech, after which the House decides whether to introduce the bill. While these bills rarely become law, they are an opportunity for members to voice their opinions and raise the profile of an issue.

Presentation bills involve a member introducing the title of a bill, but no debate is allowed. For example, "A Bill to require the Leader of the House of Commons to move a Motion prohibiting Members of Parliament from having paid second jobs; and for connected purposes."

Thirteen Fridays per parliamentary session are dedicated to debating PMBs, and on these days, they take priority over government business. However, due to the large number of bills, there is often not enough time for individual bills to go through all the required stages to become law.

PMBs rarely become law but can be used to draw attention to an issue

Private Members' Bills (PMBs) are pieces of legislation introduced by MPs or members of the House of Lords who are not government ministers. While PMBs can technically be passed and become law, this rarely happens due to the limited parliamentary time allocated to them. Instead, they are often used to draw attention to a certain issue, gather support from other members of the house, and influence government legislation indirectly.

There are three ways to introduce a PMB: the Ballot, the Ten Minute Rule, and Presentation. Ballot bills have the highest chance of becoming law as they are prioritised for the limited amount of debating time available. During a Ten Minute Rule bill, MPs are given a 10-minute slot to speak on a piece of legislation they wish to pass. This method is often used to voice an opinion or criticise existing legislation rather than seriously attempt to pass a bill. Presentation bills are formally introduced during a Friday sitting but are not allowed to be debated.

In the UK Parliament, PMBs are debated on 13 Fridays per parliamentary session, and on these days, they take priority over government bills. However, with many bills competing for limited time, most individual PMBs do not proceed through all the required stages to become law. Similar challenges are faced in the House of Lords, where PMBs are considered on sitting Fridays but often lack dedicated time, reducing their chances of progressing.

Despite the challenges, some PMBs have successfully become law. Examples include the Animals (Penalty Notices) Act 2022, the British Sign Language Act 2022, and the Homelessness Reduction Act 2017.

There are three ways to introduce a PMB: the Ballot, Ten Minute Rule and Presentation

Private Members' Bills (PMBs) are public bills that can be introduced by MPs and Lords who are not government ministers. They are used to change the law as it applies to the general population. However, as less parliamentary time is allocated to these bills, only a minority of PMBs become law.

There are three ways to introduce a PMB in the House of Commons: the Ballot, the Ten Minute Rule, and Presentation.

Ballot

The Ballot method gives members who apply a chance to be drawn from a ballot and, if successful, are given parliamentary time for their bill. The ballot is usually held on the second sitting Thursday of a parliamentary session, and the first seven ballot bills typically get one day's debate each. Ballot bills have a higher chance of becoming law as they are prioritised for the limited debating time available.

Ten Minute Rule

The Ten Minute Rule method allows members to voice their opinions or criticise existing legislation rather than seriously attempting to pass a bill. Members speak for up to ten minutes, which can be opposed by another member for ten minutes. If the motion passes, the bill is introduced with a formal first reading but rarely progresses further due to a lack of priority on the parliamentary calendar.

Presentation

Any Member of Parliament may introduce a PMB by presentation if they have previously given notice of their intention to do so. Members formally introduce the title of the bill but do not speak in support of it, and it is rare for these bills to become law.

Ballot Bills have the best chance of becoming law as they get priority in debating time

Ballot Bills are a type of Private Members' Bill used in the UK House of Commons. At the start of each new parliamentary year, backbench MPs are invited to enter their names into a ballot, and those selected can introduce a bill of their choosing, known as a Ballot Bill.

Ballot Bills are prioritised over other Private Members' Bills when parliamentary time is allocated for debates. This means they have a better chance of becoming law. In the House of Commons, the first seven ballot bills will normally get a day's debate each, and in the House of Lords, a ballot is held to decide the order in which the first 25 Private Members' Bills will be introduced.

Private Members' Bills can be introduced in either House and must go through the same stages as other public bills. However, as less time is allocated to them, it is less likely that they will proceed through all the stages. Private Members' Bills can be used to create publicity around an issue and can affect legislation indirectly.

In the 2023-24 parliamentary session, 142 Private Members' Bills were introduced, with 20 of those being Ballot Bills.

PMBs are debated on 13 Fridays per parliamentary session

Private Members' Bills (PMBs) are debated on 13 Fridays per parliamentary session. This allocation of time signifies a commitment to providing freedom from the usual constraint that government business takes precedence. However, with so many bills, there is still not enough time for many individual bills to go through the required phases to become law.

The second reading is the most difficult hurdle for Commons Private Members' Bills to pass due to the lack of time for debate. PMBs are introduced by MPs and Lords who are not government ministers, and they can technically be passed and come into law. However, only a minority do so.

There are three ways to introduce a PMB: the Ballot, the Ten-Minute Rule, and Presentation. Ballot bills have the best chance of becoming law as they are prioritised for the limited amount of debating time available. It is normal for the first seven ballot bills to be allocated a day's debate each.

The Ten-Minute Rule is often an opportunity for members to voice an opinion or criticise legislation rather than a serious attempt to get a bill passed. Members make speeches of no more than ten minutes, followed by an opposing member's ten-minute speech. It is rare for a PMB to succeed via this method.

Presentation bills are formally presented on Fridays, but after all, the ballot bills on the Order Paper have been presented.

Frequently asked questions