Refugees And Lawbreaking: Examining The Reality

Refugees are people who have fled their country of origin due to a well-founded fear of persecution or serious human rights violations. While the exact number of refugees who break laws is unknown, it is important to note that refugees, like any other group of people, may engage in unlawful activities. This could include a range of offences, from minor infractions to more serious crimes. Factors such as the conditions they faced in their home countries, the challenges of resettlement, and the lack of opportunities or support in their new countries can contribute to law-breaking among refugees. Addressing these issues through comprehensive refugee policies and social support systems is crucial to promoting successful integration and reducing the likelihood of refugees turning to illegal activities.

Refugees and criminal histories

The United States has long been a leader in refugee resettlement, but the Trump administration drastically reduced the number of refugees allowed to enter the country. The US government has also imposed new security vetting procedures, which has left many refugees in dangerous situations for prolonged periods.

Under US law, a refugee is someone who is located outside of the US, is of special humanitarian concern to the US, and demonstrates that they were persecuted or fear persecution due to race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group. Refugees are also required to be admissible to the US and not firmly resettled in another country.

Applications for refugee resettlement can be denied for various reasons, including criminal histories, past immigration violations, alleged connections to terrorist groups, or communicable diseases. If denied, applicants cannot appeal the decision unless new or previously unavailable information arises.

Research suggests that the impact of refugees on crime in host countries could be significant. For example, the influx of Syrian refugees into Turkey led to an increase in the incidence of crime of between 2% and 4.75% per year, corresponding to about 75,000-150,000 additional crimes per year.

However, it is important to note that participation in criminal activity is determined by various factors, including expected returns from the labour market, expected returns to illegal activity, and deterrence variables such as the probability of apprehension and severity of punishment. The risk aversion and time discount of the decision-maker are also important considerations.

In the US, an analysis of the 10 cities most impacted by refugee resettlement between 2006 and 2015 revealed that nine out of 10 of these communities became considerably safer in terms of violent and property crime. This suggests that refugee resettlement does not necessarily lead to an increase in crime rates.

Overall, while criminal histories can be a factor in refugee applications, the impact of refugees on crime rates in host countries is complex and influenced by a range of socioeconomic factors.

Refugees and immigration violations

Refugees and asylum seekers are protected by international law, which guarantees their human rights, regardless of how and why they arrive in a country. However, immigration violations can occur when seeking refuge, and these violations can have serious consequences for the individuals involved.

One such violation is the lack of legal documentation, which can make it difficult for refugees to access essential services, find formal employment, and become vulnerable to insecurity and discrimination in their host country. This was the case for many Venezuelan refugees who sought to rebuild their lives in South American countries before risking dangerous crossings to reach the US. The lack of safe pathways pushes migrants and asylum seekers to cross through dangerous territories, such as the Darien Gap, where they are exposed to abuses by criminal groups and receive little protection from local authorities.

Another violation is past immigration violations, which can result in denied applications for refugee resettlement. This was one of the criteria listed by the US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) for denying applications, in addition to criminal histories, alleged connections to terrorist groups, and communicable diseases. Such violations can have severe consequences for refugees, potentially leaving them stranded in dangerous locations or difficult circumstances.

It is important to note that the term "immigration violations" can cover a broad range of actions, and the specific consequences can vary depending on the country and its laws. In general, however, immigration violations can create significant challenges for refugees, impacting their ability to find safety and rebuild their lives in a new country.

Refugees and connections to terrorist groups

The relationship between refugees and terrorist groups is a highly contested issue in political and public debate. While some politicians and commentators argue that refugees pose a security threat to their host countries, there is little empirical evidence to support this claim. In fact, the available data suggests that refugees are more likely to be victims of terrorism than perpetrators.

Refugees as Victims of Terrorism

A 2019 study by the libertarian-leaning Cato Institute found that of the 192 foreign-born terrorists who committed attacks in the United States between 1975 and 2017, only 25 were refugees. Furthermore, only three of these attacks resulted in fatalities, and all three took place before 1980, when the Refugee Act created the current refugee screening procedures.

A cross-national study by Graig R. Klein of Leiden University also found no evidence that refugees themselves commit acts of domestic terrorism. Instead, Klein argues that refugees can be a "combustible environment" for domestic terrorism when they enter countries with high levels of xenophobia and negative social perceptions of foreigners. In other words, it is the xenophobic or nativist environment that refugees enter that defines the "tinderbox of violence" refugee flows can ignite.

Refugees as Perpetrators of Terrorism

While the available evidence suggests that refugees are rarely implicated in terrorist attacks, there have been some high-profile cases that have fuelled public fears and shaped political debates. For example, the 2015 Paris attacks, which were carried out by perpetrators with links to refugee flows from the Middle East, sparked intense scrutiny of refugee admissions in Europe and the United States. In the United States, the Obama administration initially proposed an increase in the annual refugee admissions ceiling to address the growing migration crisis caused by the war in Syria. However, this proposal was reversed by the Trump administration, which issued an executive order temporarily prohibiting the entry of nationals from seven Muslim-majority countries.

Despite the intense political and public debate surrounding this issue, the empirical evidence suggests that the connection between refugees and terrorist groups is complex and multifaceted. While there may be individual cases of refugees involved in terrorist activities, the overall risk of refugee-related terrorism is relatively low, especially in Western countries with robust refugee screening procedures.

Refugees and human trafficking

Refugees are among the most vulnerable members of society, and human traffickers prey on their insecurity. When people are forced to flee, they leave behind their homes, belongings, jobs, and support networks. They often end up in unfamiliar surroundings, socially and culturally isolated, and lacking access to basic resources and livelihood opportunities. This makes them easy targets for traffickers.

Many refugees resort to the services of smugglers to reach safety, placing themselves in situations where they are extremely vulnerable to human trafficking. In some cases, smugglers deceive refugees by promising them safe passage and then demanding more payment. If the refugees are unable to pay their "debts," they may be forced into physical and sexual abuse or prostitution. This was the case for some Ukrainian refugees who accepted rides from strangers, only to be told that they owed a debt that could only be paid by working for the driver.

The intersection between conflict-induced migration and human trafficking is undeniable. Human trafficking is a symptom of a refugee crisis, which creates the economic impoverishment and lack of options that traffickers exploit. For example, the mass exodus from Venezuela has led to the displacement of over 5 million people, with many Venezuelan women forced into sex trafficking rings in neighbouring countries. Similarly, many of the 5.6 million refugees who fled the war in Syria have become victims of labour and sex trafficking, facing long hours, low wages, and poor working conditions in the textile and agricultural industries of Jordan, Lebanon, Iraq, and Turkey.

The number of global refugees has reached an all-time high, with figures estimated at nearly 27 million in 2021. This number is expected to exceed 30 million in 2022 due to the ongoing crisis in Ukraine. According to the International Labour Organization, there are over 40.3 million victims of human trafficking globally, with migrants accounting for more than half of this number.

To address the issue of human trafficking among refugees, it is crucial to understand the vulnerabilities that put people at risk. Awareness-raising initiatives, such as the EU's "Telling the Real Story" campaign, aim to inform people on the move about the dangers of onward irregular movement and provide information about alternative options. Additionally, the development of standard operating procedures for the identification and protection of trafficking victims, such as the Joint Framework published by UNHCR and IOM in 2020, is an important step in combating human trafficking.

Refugees and human rights violations

Refugees are people who have fled their own country because they are at risk of serious human rights violations and persecution there. They are protected by international law, which states that everyone has the right to seek and enjoy asylum from persecution in other countries. However, the lack of human rights-based migration governance at the global and national levels is leading to the routine violation of migrants' rights in transit, at international borders, and in the countries to which they migrate.

Human rights violations against refugees can include a denial of civil and political rights, such as arbitrary detention, torture, or a lack of due process. They may also face economic, social, and cultural rights violations, such as the rights to health, housing, or education. These violations are often linked to discriminatory laws and deep-seated attitudes of prejudice or xenophobia. For example, refugees may face daily racism, xenophobia, and discrimination, as well as exploitation and marginalization.

The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) conducts an initial screening to determine if an individual seeking refugee status qualifies as a refugee under international law. They then identify an appropriate "durable solution" for that individual: voluntary repatriation, local integration, or resettlement. However, the resettlement process can be very time-consuming, leaving some refugees in dangerous situations for prolonged periods.

In conclusion, while refugees have a right to international protection, they often face human rights violations during their journey and in their host countries. These violations can take many forms, including civil, political, economic, social, and cultural rights abuses. It is important for the international community to work together to protect the rights of refugees and ensure that they have access to safe and regular migration pathways.

Frequently asked questions