Evolution's Challenge To Scientific Laws: Breaking Or Bending?

The theory of evolution is one of the most robust scientific theories, supported by evidence from genetics, paleontology, geology, and developmental biology. However, some critics argue that it breaks fundamental scientific laws and principles. For instance, the Law of Biogenesis, which states that life arises only from life, contradicts the idea of spontaneous generation, a key aspect of evolutionary theory. Additionally, the second law of thermodynamics, which states that all molecular arrangements tend towards increased disorganization over time, seems to contradict the concept of increasing complexity in evolution. Despite these apparent contradictions, evolution remains a widely accepted theory, and scientists continue to uncover new evidence supporting it.

Evolution and the Law of Biogenesis

The Law of Biogenesis, also known as Omne vivum ex ovo, is a fundamental scientific law that states that life arises only from pre-existing life and not from non-living matter. In other words, "life begets life". This law is closely intertwined with modern biology's Cell Theory, which posits that all living creatures are composed of cells, and that cells can only arise from pre-existing cells.

The Law of Biogenesis was formulated in the 17th century by Italian scientist Francesco Redi, who disproved the then-prevalent notion of spontaneous generation. Redi demonstrated that maggots came from the eggs of flies and not from rotting meat. In the 19th century, French scientist Louis Pasteur further solidified the law through his experiments, which showed that microorganisms did not spontaneously arise from non-living inorganic matter.

The Law of Biogenesis has significant implications for evolutionary theory. The theory of evolution posits that life arose from non-living matter, which is in direct contradiction to the Law of Biogenesis. This contradiction has led some to argue that the theory of evolution is fundamentally flawed and must be rejected.

However, it is important to note that the Law of Biogenesis does not explicitly address the question of the origin of life or how life began. Instead, it focuses on the continuation and propagation of life once it has emerged. While the law states that life can only come from pre-existing life, it does not provide insight into how the first life form came into existence.

The origin of life remains a subject of ongoing scientific inquiry, with various theories and hypotheses being proposed. Some scientists have suggested that life may have originated through a process known as abiogenesis, where complex organic molecules necessary for life arose from simpler inorganic molecules through chemical reactions. However, abiogenesis is not universally accepted and continues to be an area of active research and debate.

In conclusion, the Law of Biogenesis states that life arises from pre-existing life and not from non-living matter. This law has been supported by scientific experiments and observations. While it poses a challenge to evolutionary theory, it does not disprove evolution and leaves open the question of how the first life form emerged.

Evolution and the Laws of Thermodynamics

The second law of thermodynamics (the law of increase of entropy) is often used as an argument against evolution. The argument goes that evolution is a decrease of entropy, as it involves things getting more organised over time, while the second law of thermodynamics states that things get more disordered over time.

However, this argument is flawed. The Earth is not an isolated system – it receives energy from the sun and radiates energy back into space. The second law does not claim that the entropy of any part of a system increases. Instead, it says that the total entropy of the whole system must increase. Therefore, any decrease of entropy on Earth (for example, the formation of ice) must be compensated by an increase in entropy elsewhere (the heat released into the surrounding environment).

The anti-evolution argument also fails to take into account the change of entropy involved with both the absorption of energy from the sun and the radiation of energy into space. The sun acts as a heat reservoir that maintains a constant temperature of 6000 K, while the Earth radiates energy at a much lower temperature of 280 K. Since the sun's temperature is much higher than that of the Earth, the net entropy of the two reservoirs increases.

Evolutionary processes take place over millions of years and cannot cause a violation of the second law.

Moreover, living organisms are open systems that maintain greater order than their surroundings by importing free energy (nutrients) and exporting entropy (heat and waste). This is achieved through semi-permeable cell membranes, which separate external chaos from internal order and facilitate the exchange of specific nutrients and wastes.

The second law of thermodynamics is one of the most misunderstood aspects of physics. It is important to recognise that it only applies to thermally isolated systems, where energy is neither added nor removed. The Earth, however, is not a thermally isolated system due to the constant energy it receives from the sun.

In conclusion, evolution does not break the laws of thermodynamics.

Evolution and the Law of Conservation of Energy

The Law of Conservation of Energy states that energy can neither be created nor destroyed. Instead, it can be transformed from one form to another. For example, in a torch, the chemical energy of the batteries is converted into electrical energy, which is then converted into light and heat energy.

Energy is required for the evolution of life forms on Earth. It is defined in physics as the capacity to do work.

The law of conservation of energy can be applied to evolution in the following ways:

• The evolution of life forms on Earth is dependent on energy.
• Energy is required for the evolution of life forms to occur, and this energy can be transformed from one form to another.
• The evolution of life forms can be seen as a transformation of energy from one form to another.
• The evolution of life forms is a consequence of the law of conservation of energy, which states that energy can be transformed but not created or destroyed.

The law of conservation of energy is a fundamental principle that governs the evolution of life forms on Earth. It states that energy can be transformed from one form to another but cannot be created or destroyed. This law applies to all forms of energy, including heat, electrical, chemical, and nuclear energy.

The total energy of an isolated system, such as the universe, remains constant over time. This means that if there is a loss of energy in one part of the universe, there must be a gain of an equal amount of energy in another part.

The law of conservation of energy can be expressed mathematically as:

> UT = Ui + W + Q

Where:

• UT is the total energy of a system
• Ui is the initial energy of a system
• Q is the heat added or removed from the system
• W is the work done by or on the system

The change in the internal energy of a system can be calculated using the equation:

> ΔU = W + Q

This law also applies to closed systems, which are isolated from their surroundings. In a closed system, the total energy of the system is conserved.

The law of conservation of energy has important implications for our understanding of evolution and the development of life forms on Earth. It highlights the role of energy in the evolution of life and the fact that energy cannot be created or destroyed, only transformed. This law provides a framework for understanding the complex processes involved in evolution and the transformation of energy that occurs during these processes.

Evolution and the Law of Universal Complexity

The theory of evolution, first sketched out by British naturalist Charles Darwin in his 1859 book "On the Origin of Species", provoked a revolution in scientific thought. It proposed that biological species change over time through the acquisition of traits that favour survival and reproduction. Now, almost two centuries later, scientists and philosophers have proposed a new law of nature that includes biological evolution as an example of a much broader phenomenon, one that appears at the level of atoms, minerals, planetary atmospheres, stars, and more. This new law of nature holds that complex natural systems evolve towards states of greater patterning, diversity, and complexity.

The Law of Universal Complexity

The law of universal complexity, or the "law of increasing functional information", holds that evolving systems, biological and non-biological, always form from numerous interacting building blocks like atoms or cells. Additionally, processes exist that generate many different configurations, such as cellular mutation. Evolution occurs when these various configurations are subject to selection for useful functions. This law aims to describe and explain why the universe keeps getting more diverse and complex at scales of atoms, molecules, minerals, and more.

The Three Universal Concepts of Selection

The authors of the law of universal complexity proposed three universal concepts of selection:

• The basic ability to endure, or static selection
• The enduring nature of active processes that may enable evolution, or dynamic selection
• The emergence of novel characteristics as an adaptation to an environment, or novelty generation

Biological Examples of Novelty Generation

Biological examples of novelty generation, or the third universal concept of selection, include organisms developing the ability to swim, walk, fly, and think. Our species, *Homo sapiens*, emerged after the human evolutionary lineage diverged from the chimpanzee lineage and acquired an array of traits, including upright walking and increased brain size.

The law of universal complexity provides a new perspective on why the diverse systems that make up the cosmos evolve in the way that they do. It may also allow for predictions about how unfamiliar systems, like the organic chemistry on Saturn's moon Titan, develop over time. By understanding and applying this law, scientists can gain insights into the evolution of complex systems, from the atom to the dynamics of ecosystems, and beyond.

Evolution and the Law of Natural Selection

The Theory of Evolution by natural selection was first formulated by Charles Darwin in his 1859 book, "On the Origin of Species". In it, Darwin describes how organisms evolve over generations through the inheritance of physical or behavioural traits.

Darwin's theory starts with the premise that within a population, there is variation in traits, such as beak shape in the Galapagos finches he studied. According to the theory, individuals with traits that enable them to adapt to their environments will survive and have more offspring, who will then inherit those traits. Over time, these traits will become more frequent in the population, and the population will change, or evolve. This process is known as "descent with modification".

Natural selection can alter a species in small ways, such as causing a population to change colour or size over the course of several generations. When this process happens over a relatively short period of time and in a small group of organisms, it is known as "microevolution". However, when given enough time and accumulated changes, natural selection can create entirely new species, a process known as "macroevolution".

Darwin also described a form of natural selection that depends on an organism's success at attracting a mate, known as sexual selection. The colourful plumage of peacocks and the antlers of male deer are both examples of traits that evolved under this type of selection.

While Darwin's theory is one of the most solid in science, he did not know the mechanism by which traits were passed on. Future research by geneticists provided the mechanism and additional evidence for evolution by natural selection.

Frequently asked questions