Who Voted On Abortion Law And What Was The Turnout?

The issue of abortion laws has been a topic for statewide ballot measures across the US since the 1970s. In 2024, 10 states will have abortion measures on their ballot, seeking to either affirm that the state constitution protects the right to abortion or that nothing in the constitution confers such a right. These states are Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Maryland, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, New York, Nevada, and South Dakota. The issue of abortion is expected to have a significant impact on voter turnout and could prove influential in tight races for the House of Representatives and the Senate, as well as the presidential election.

Voter turnout

In 2022, record-high support for abortion rights, spurred by the fall of Roe v. Wade, helped Democrats hold off an expected "red wave" and flip key legislative and judicial seats. This trend is expected to continue in 2024, with abortion on the ballot in several swing states, including Arizona, Nevada, and Montana.

In Arizona, for example, Democrats hope that the abortion-rights ballot measure will give them the boost they need to win the state. However, some are concerned that the measure may not be enough to sway voters away from Republican candidates, especially in a state with a history of opposing abortion rights. Similar concerns have been raised in Nebraska, where competing ballot initiatives could boost turnout but are unlikely to change the outcome of other races.

On the other hand, Republicans are also hoping to benefit from the inclusion of abortion on the ballot. In Arizona, some conservatives are pleased that voters have the option of protecting abortion rights while still supporting Republican candidates. They believe that voters will prioritize other issues, such as high grocery prices and border control, over abortion.

Overall, the impact of abortion on voter turnout in the 2024 election remains to be seen. While it may bring more voters to the polls, particularly women and those who support abortion rights, it is unclear whether this will translate into votes for Democratic or Republican candidates.

The impact on House of Representative seats

The impact of abortion laws on House of Representative seats is complex and multifaceted. Abortion has been a highly divisive issue in the United States, with strong opinions on both sides of the debate. As such, it has the potential to significantly influence election outcomes and shape the composition of the House of Representatives.

In the 2024 elections, abortion is expected to be a key issue for voters in several states, including Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Montana, Nevada, New York, and South Dakota. The impact of abortion laws on House seats in these states may vary, but we can identify some potential effects.

In Arizona, the abortion-rights ballot measure could have a "scrambling" effect on the election. While the measure is likely to pass overwhelmingly, polls show that the presidential race is much closer. Some voters have indicated they plan to vote to protect abortion rights while also supporting Republican candidates such as former President Donald Trump and Senate candidate Kari Lake, which could result in a split ticket. This dynamic may make it challenging for Democratic candidates to capitalize on the abortion issue and translate it into House seats.

In Florida, the impact of abortion on House races is expected to be minimal. However, the issue has drawn attention to Donald Trump's stance on abortion, with the former president initially stating he would vote in favour of the abortion rights initiative but later reversing his position due to pushback from within his party.

In New York, the abortion initiative takes a different form, aiming to amend the state's equal rights amendment to include protections against discrimination due to pregnancy, pregnancy outcomes, and reproductive healthcare. While the word "abortion" is not explicitly mentioned, there are a handful of tight House races in the state where high voter turnout among Democrats could be influenced by this ballot question. As a result, the control of the House of Representatives could be influenced by a small number of seats.

In states like Missouri, which consistently votes Republican, the impact of the abortion ballot question is unlikely to change the outcome of other races. However, Mallory Schwarz, executive director of Abortion Action Missouri, highlights that reversing the abortion ban could make the state a destination for women in nearby states with more restrictive abortion laws, potentially impacting future elections.

In conclusion, the impact of abortion laws on House of Representative seats varies across states. While abortion may be a motivating issue for voters, it does not always translate into support for a particular party. The complexity of voter priorities and the ability to compartmentalize issues can lead to unexpected outcomes. The effects of abortion laws on House seats may also extend beyond a single election, as changes to state constitutions and legislative majorities could have long-lasting repercussions.

The impact on Senate seats

The impact of abortion laws on Senate seats is complex and multifaceted. Here are some key points to consider:

• Voter Turnout and Engagement: Abortion is a highly polarizing issue that can significantly influence voter turnout and engagement. The presence of abortion-related ballot measures can attract voters with strong opinions on the topic, leading to higher participation rates. This was evident in the 2022 elections, where record-high support for abortion rights contributed to Democratic victories in key states. The impact of abortion on voter turnout may favor one party over the other, depending on the political leanings of the state.
• Partisan Divide and Swing States: Abortion laws often fall along partisan lines, with Democrats generally supporting abortion rights and Republicans often opposing them. In swing states, such as Arizona, Nevada, and Montana, the abortion issue can become a pivotal factor in Senate races. The impact of abortion laws on Senate seats in these states can be significant, as small shifts in voter preferences can determine which party gains control of the Senate.
• Ballot Measure Wording and Complexity: The wording and complexity of abortion-related ballot measures can influence voter decisions. For example, in Nebraska, there are two competing ballot initiatives: one to enshrine abortion rights and another to enforce a 12-week abortion ban. The presence of multiple measures can confuse voters or lead to unexpected outcomes.
• Impact on Down-Ballot Races: While abortion may be a prominent issue at the federal level, its impact on down-ballot races, such as state legislative and judicial seats, cannot be overlooked. In some cases, abortion-related ballot measures may drive turnout and influence voters to support specific candidates or parties across the entire ticket. In other cases, voters may "split their tickets," supporting abortion rights while also backing Republican candidates who oppose those rights.
• Long-Term Impact on Abortion Access: The impact of abortion laws on Senate seats can have long-term consequences for abortion access. For example, if Republicans gain control of the Senate, they may pursue a national abortion ban or restrict abortion access through legislation and judicial appointments. On the other hand, if Democrats maintain or expand their Senate majority, they can work to protect and expand abortion rights at the federal level.
• Impact on State Politics: Abortion laws can also influence state-level politics and the composition of state legislatures. For example, in Arizona, the abortion-rights ballot measure may spur higher voter turnout, but it could also have "weird consequences" by allowing voters to support both abortion rights and Republican candidates who oppose those rights. This dynamic could impact the balance of power in state legislatures and shape state-level abortion policies.

In conclusion, the impact of abortion laws on Senate seats is multifaceted and varies across states. The interplay between abortion rights, voter preferences, and partisan politics will continue to shape the political landscape at both the federal and state levels. The outcome of the 2024 elections, with abortion measures on the ballot in several states, will provide further insights into the complex relationship between abortion laws and Senate seat dynamics.

The impact on the presidential election

The issue of abortion law is set to have a significant impact on the 2024 US presidential election. Ten states will have abortion questions on the ballot in November, including key battleground states such as Arizona, Nevada, and Florida. This comes after the Supreme Court's 2022 decision to overturn Roe v Wade, which led many states to enact abortion restrictions or bans.

The impact of abortion on the election is twofold. Firstly, it is expected to increase voter turnout, particularly among women. Democrats hope that more people who support abortion rights will show up on election day because the issue is on the ballot. This could benefit them in close races in swing states. However, it could also work in the Republicans' favour, as some voters may choose to support Republican candidates despite their anti-abortion stance.

Secondly, the abortion question is influencing how people vote. In states like Arizona, voters are indicating that they plan to vote to overturn the state's 15-week abortion ban but also support Republican candidates who have a history of opposing abortion rights, such as former President Donald Trump and Senate candidate Kari Lake. This suggests that, for some voters, abortion is just one of many factors when selecting a candidate.

The impact of abortion on the election outcome is difficult to predict, as it may depend on how people weigh this issue against others. While the ballot measure may increase Democratic turnout, it could also lead to "weird consequences" if people vote to protect abortion rights while simultaneously voting for Republican candidates.

Overall, the abortion question on the ballot in November is likely to be a significant factor in the 2024 US presidential election, influencing both voter turnout and voting behaviour. The ultimate impact on the election outcome remains to be seen and will depend on how voters in each state prioritize this issue.

The impact on state legislation

The impact of the Supreme Court's 2022 decision to overturn Roe v Wade has been profound on state legislation, with many states enacting abortion restrictions or bans. In response, pro-choice advocates have pushed to get abortion rights on state ballots, hoping to bypass the fluctuating state courts and enshrine abortion in state laws.

Since Roe v Wade was overturned, 14 states have banned abortion, with a further four states banning the procedure after six weeks. However, the impact of the Supreme Court's decision has been mixed, with 10 states voting to protect abortion rights in 2022 and 2023. In 2024, 11 states will have abortion-related measures on their ballots, the most on record for a single year.

The impact of these ballot measures has been felt in both red and purple states, with abortion-rights campaigns appealing to Republicans, independents, and Democrats with messaging focused on freedom from government interference in personal medical decisions. In 2022, for example, Arizona Democrats secured victories in razor-thin races, and in 2023, voters in Ohio approved a citizen-initiated constitutional amendment to protect reproductive rights.

However, the impact of these ballot measures on election outcomes is complex. While they may increase voter turnout, particularly among women, they do not always translate into support for Democratic candidates. Some voters express a willingness to "split their ticket" by supporting abortion rights while also voting for Republican candidates who have a history of opposing those rights. This dynamic has been observed in Arizona, where voters plan to overturn the state's 15-week abortion ban but also support former President Donald Trump and other Republicans.

The impact of abortion-related ballot measures on state legislation is, therefore, multifaceted. While they have successfully protected abortion rights in some states, they have also revealed a complex interplay between voter values, party politics, and the influence of independent and swing voters.

Frequently asked questions