Texas Abortion Law: What's Next?

Texas's abortion law is one of the most restrictive in the country. The law prohibits abortions once a foetal heartbeat is detected, which is usually around six weeks into a pregnancy, and before many women know they are pregnant. The law does not make exceptions for rape or incest. In May 2021, Texas lawmakers passed the Texas Heartbeat Act, banning abortions as soon as foetal cardiac activity can be detected. The law provides that any person may sue anyone who performs or induces an abortion in violation of the statute, as well as anyone who aids or abets an unlawful abortion. The law was written this way to prevent abortion providers from challenging its constitutionality before it took effect. The Texas Supreme Court has upheld the state's abortion law, ruling that it does not violate the state constitution. However, the law continues to be challenged in court, with critics arguing that it does not adequately protect the lives of pregnant mothers.

The impact of the abortion ban on maternal mortality rates

Texas' abortion ban, which came into effect in September 2021, has had a significant impact on maternal mortality rates. From 2019 to 2022, the rate of maternal mortality cases in Texas rose by 56%, compared to just an 11% increase nationwide. This increase far outpaces the slower rise in maternal mortality across the nation.

The ban prohibits abortions once a fetal heartbeat is detected, which usually occurs around five to six weeks into a pregnancy. This timeframe is significant because many women do not know they are pregnant at this early stage. As a result, women in Texas are being forced to continue with unwanted pregnancies or seek alternative, often unsafe, means of terminating their pregnancies.

The ban has also had indirect effects on maternal health. Women in states with strict abortion laws, such as Texas, are more likely to forego prenatal care and face challenges in accessing OB-GYN services due to fear and uncertainty. This trend was confirmed by Dr. Leah Tatum, an OB-GYN in Austin, Texas, who reported a doubling of requests for sterilization procedures from her patients after the abortion ban.

The increase in maternal mortality rates in Texas is a direct consequence of restricted access to safe and legal abortions. This trend is expected to continue and even worsen as other states follow Texas' lead in enacting stringent abortion bans, putting more women at risk.

The role of the Supreme Court in upholding the abortion law

The Supreme Court's role in upholding the abortion law in Texas has been a complex and evolving one, with various rulings and interpretations at play. Here is an overview of the role the Supreme Court has played in upholding the abortion law in Texas:

• The Texas Heartbeat Bill: The Texas abortion law, also known as the Texas Heartbeat Bill, prohibits physicians from performing abortions once a fetal heartbeat is detected, which is usually around six weeks into a pregnancy. This law took effect on September 1, 2021, and sparked widespread debate and legal challenges. The law includes both civil and criminal penalties for those who perform or aid in abortions.
• Supreme Court Rulings: The Supreme Court has issued several rulings related to the Texas abortion law:

• Zurawski v. State (May 31, 2024): The Texas Supreme Court ruled against an injunction on the abortion law, stating that the law permits physicians to address life-threatening conditions for pregnant women.
• In re State of Texas (December 11, 2023): The Texas Supreme Court recognized that only a doctor can determine whether a pregnant woman's life is at risk, and a court cannot authorize an abortion pre-emptively.
• August 4, 2023 Ruling: A Texas judge granted a temporary injunction, allowing abortions in cases of medical emergencies, including pregnancies unsafe for the mother.
• Dobbs v. Jackson: The U.S. Supreme Court ruling in this case triggered the Texas abortion law by overturning Roe v. Wade, allowing states to set their own abortion laws.

• Enforcement Mechanisms: A unique aspect of the Texas abortion law is its enforcement mechanism. Unlike other states that rely on government action and criminal charges, Texas leaves enforcement up to private citizens through civil lawsuits. Any private citizen can sue abortion providers who violate the law and anyone who "aids or abets" a woman in getting an abortion.
• Federal Law and EMTALA: The Biden administration has argued that the federal Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA) requires emergency rooms to provide abortions if a pregnant patient's health or life is at serious risk, even in states with strict abortion bans. However, Texas and other states have successfully challenged this interpretation, arguing that EMTALA does not mandate abortion care and does not conflict with state abortion laws.
• Vague Language and Medical Exceptions: Critics of the Texas abortion law argue that its language is vague, leaving doctors unsure of when they can legally perform abortions. The medical exceptions included in the law are unclear, and doctors risk facing severe penalties if they misinterpret the law.
• Impact on Women's Health: The abortion law in Texas has had significant implications for women's health. There have been reports of pregnant women in medical distress being turned away from emergency rooms, and some women have suffered serious health consequences, including the loss of reproductive organs.

In summary, the Supreme Court has played a pivotal role in upholding the abortion law in Texas by allowing the state to implement its own restrictions and leaving enforcement to private citizens. The court's rulings have shaped the interpretation and application of the law, impacting women's access to abortion services and their overall health and well-being.

The legal status of abortion in Texas post-Roe v. Wade

The legal status of abortion in Texas has changed significantly since the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Roe v. Wade (1973) was overturned in 2022. Roe v. Wade established a constitutional right to abortion in the U.S., but this was removed following the Supreme Court's ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization. This ruling allowed individual states to restrict or ban abortion access.

In Texas, abortion is now largely banned, with doctors facing criminal prosecution for performing abortions after a fetal heartbeat is detected—usually around six weeks into a pregnancy. The Texas Heartbeat Bill, which became state law on September 1, 2021, has sparked heated debates and legal challenges. While the law does not allow for the criminal prosecution of the woman or person who had the abortion, it does create a criminal cause of action against doctors and medical staff, who can face felony charges.

The Texas abortion law also allows any private citizen to sue abortion providers who violate the law, as well as anyone who "aids or abets" a woman in getting an abortion. The person bringing the lawsuit is entitled to at least $10,000 in damages if they prevail in court.

There are some exceptions to the Texas abortion ban. For instance, the law does not apply to someone who had an abortion out of state or in another country. Additionally, in March 2024, the Texas Medical Board proposed guidance for exceptions to the state's multiple abortion bans, aiming to clarify what qualifies as an exception in medical emergencies. However, critics argue that this guidance does not go far enough in protecting the lives of pregnant women.

The legal status of abortion in Texas remains contested, with abortion laws continuing to be challenged and subject to various court rulings.

The criminalisation of abortion providers and doctors

The Texas abortion law creates a criminal cause of action against doctors and medical staff who perform or aid in abortions. It is important to note that the law does not allow for the prosecution of the woman who had the abortion. However, anyone who provided assistance or aided the procedure is open to criminal prosecution. This includes medical personnel, family members or friends who help pay for the procedure, pharmacists, and those who drive the patient to the clinic.

The penalties for performing an abortion in Texas are severe. It is a second-degree felony for a person who knowingly performs, induces, or attempts an abortion. If the unborn child dies due to the abortion, the penalty is increased to a first-degree felony, punishable by five to 99 years in prison. The law also mandates the revocation of medical, nursing, or pharmacy licenses and allows the Texas Attorney General to seek civil penalties of at least $100,000, plus attorney's fees and costs.

The Texas abortion law has been challenged in courts, with some judges granting temporary injunctions and exceptions for medical emergencies. For example, the Texas Medical Board has proposed guidance for exceptions to the state's abortion bans in cases of medical emergencies. Additionally, House Bill 3058 provides legal protection for doctors who terminate a pregnancy to treat life-threatening complications such as ectopic pregnancies or pre-viable premature membrane rupture.

The implications of the abortion law for pregnant minors

• Parental Consent Requirement: Minors under 18 years of age must obtain parental consent for an abortion. This applies even if the minor already has children. The law requires a physician to notify the parent, guardian, or court-appointed managing conservator at least 48 hours in advance of the procedure.
• Judicial Bypass Option: A pregnant minor can file an application with the court to authorize an abortion without parental notification or consent. The court will appoint a guardian ad litem to represent the minor's best interests and an attorney to represent the minor. The court will determine if the minor is mature and well-informed enough to make the decision or if notification and consent are not in the minor's best interest.
• Medical Emergencies: In cases of medical emergencies, a physician may perform an abortion without parental consent if they conclude that the minor's life is at risk or they may suffer substantial physical impairment. The physician must provide notification within 24 hours after the procedure and document the specific medical emergency.
• Limited Access: Minors seeking abortions face limited access to clinics and providers due to the restrictive abortion laws in Texas. Many abortion clinics have stopped offering services due to fear of prosecution, creating challenges for minors trying to navigate an already complex process.
• Out-of-State Options: Organizations like Planned Parenthood offer connections to out-of-state abortion providers and resources for travel, meals, and childcare expenses. This can be a viable option for minors who are unable to obtain parental consent or navigate the judicial bypass process.
• No Criminal Prosecution for Minors: It is important to note that the Texas abortion law does not allow for the criminal prosecution of pregnant minors who undergo abortions. The law explicitly prohibits this, ensuring that minors are not legally penalized for their decisions.

Frequently asked questions