Collusion And Law: Understanding The Fine Line

Collusion is a non-competitive, secret, and sometimes illegal agreement between rivals that disrupts the market's equilibrium. While collusion itself is not a specific crime, it can involve criminal acts and colluding can be illegal. The term collusion means different things in different contexts, but it often refers to illegal or unethical acts committed by two or more individuals. In the context of criminal law, collusion can involve criminal intent and be characterised by acts such as lying, fraud, and obstruction of justice.

Collusion is illegal in the United States, Canada, Australia, and most of the EU due to antitrust laws. It involves companies or individuals working together to influence a market or pricing to gain an unfair advantage. This can include price-fixing, synchronized advertising, and sharing insider information.

Is collusion a crime?

The term "collusion" has no legal meaning in criminal law and is not a legal term. There is no criminal statute titled "collusion", and collusion itself is not always considered a crime. However, acts of collusion can be illegal and are considered crimes in certain contexts.

Collusion in Criminal Law

Collusion often refers to illegal or unethical acts committed by two or more individuals. Merriam-Webster's Dictionary defines collusion as "secret cooperation for an illegal or dishonest purpose". Black's Law Dictionary defines it as "a deceitful agreement or compact between two or more persons, for the one party to bring an action against the other for some evil purpose, as to defraud a third party of his right".

Collusion in Conspiracy

Collusion can be considered a crime in the context of conspiracy, which is a criminal charge. Conspiracy is defined as "an agreement between two or more people to commit an act prohibited by law or a lawful act by means prohibited by law". It is often a preparatory crime and a preliminary step in committing a target offence. Common crimes associated with conspiracy include murder, fraud, and drug offences.

Collusion in Competition Law

Under competition law, there is a distinction between direct and covert collusion. Direct collusion refers to companies communicating directly with each other to coordinate and monitor their actions, such as through pricing, market allocation, and sales quotas. On the other hand, tacit collusion, where companies coordinate and monitor their behaviour without direct communication, is generally not considered illegal.

Collusion in Antitrust Law

Collusion is illegal in the United States, Canada, Australia, and most of the EU due to antitrust laws. Antitrust laws are in place to prevent actions that would restrain trade and create an unfair advantage for businesses. Violations of these laws can occur when large companies merge or agree not to exceed a certain price point, known as price-fixing.

In summary, while collusion itself may not be a specific crime, it can involve illegal and unethical acts that are prosecutable by the state and punishable by law.

Conspiracy and collusion

Collusion and conspiracy are similar but distinct concepts. Collusion refers to a deceitful agreement or secret cooperation between two or more parties to limit open competition by deceiving, misleading, or defrauding others of their legal rights. On the other hand, conspiracy is a criminal charge that involves an agreement between individuals to commit an illegal act or to use illegal means to carry out a lawful act. While collusion itself is not a criminal charge, it can involve criminal offenses such as fraud or market manipulation.

Collusion often occurs in the context of antitrust law, where competitors in the same market collude to fix or control prices, limit supply, share insider information, or divide the market. This type of collusion, known as horizontal collusion, can lead to higher prices for consumers and harm competition. Direct collusion occurs when companies communicate directly with each other to coordinate their actions, while tacit collusion involves companies coordinating their behaviour without direct communication. Tacit collusion is generally not considered illegal, although it can have similar economic impacts as explicit collusion.

The distinction between direct and tacit collusion is important in competition law. Direct collusion, where companies explicitly communicate and coordinate their actions, is illegal in many countries due to antitrust laws. However, tacit collusion, where companies independently set prices and market share based on mutual understanding, is more difficult to regulate. This is because it relies on implicit signals and market behaviour rather than explicit agreements.

While collusion is not always illegal, it can be used to attain objectives that are forbidden by law. For example, collusion can be used to defraud, gain an unfair market advantage, or fix prices. In some cases, collusion can also involve unions, wage fixing, kickbacks, or misrepresenting the independence of the relationship between the colluding parties.

In summary, collusion refers to secret cooperation or deceitful agreements between parties, while conspiracy is a criminal charge for agreeing to commit illegal acts. Collusion can involve criminal offenses and is often associated with antitrust violations, but it is not itself a specific crime. The legality of collusion depends on the specific context and the intentions of the colluding parties.

Collusion in antitrust law

Collusion is a deceitful agreement or secret cooperation between two or more parties to limit open competition by deceiving, misleading or defrauding others of their legal right. It is not always considered illegal, but it can be used to attain objectives forbidden by law, such as defrauding or gaining an unfair market advantage.

Parallel pricing behaviour is suggestive of collusion when the parallel conduct is inconsistent with the defendant's individual self-interest and is not a rational response to market conditions. This means that if companies set prices that are not in their best interest when considered independently, it may suggest that they are colluding.

Tacit collusion, also known as oligopolistic price coordination or conscious parallelism, is when firms in a concentrated market set their prices at a profit-maximising, supra-competitive level after recognising their shared economic interests and interdependence with respect to price and output decisions. This process is not in itself unlawful, and tacit collusion does not violate antitrust laws unless there is additional evidence of an agreement between competitors.

Direct collusion, on the other hand, is when a group of companies communicate directly with each other to coordinate and monitor their actions, such as through pricing, market allocation, or sales quotas. This type of collusion is considered illegal and is a violation of antitrust law.

Whistleblower laws

Collusion is a non-competitive, secret, and sometimes illegal agreement between rivals that attempts to disrupt the market's equilibrium. While collusion itself is not a criminal charge, criminal offenses can be characterised by collusive acts.

In the US, the federal Whistleblower Protection Act shields all government employees. Whistleblowers may also be protected under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, the United States Federal Sentencing Guidelines for Organizations (FSGO), and the False Claims Act. Whistleblowers can receive a percentage of the money awarded if the government wins a lawsuit against the whistleblower's employer.

Whistleblowers often face retaliation, including termination of employment, increased workloads, reduction of hours, bullying, and damage to reputation. Whistleblowers may also experience stress, depression, and other negative impacts on their mental health.

Collusion and market manipulation

Collusion is a complex phenomenon where competitors secretly conspire to manipulate various aspects of the market. While collusion is not always illegal, it often entails clandestine agreements among competitors, aimed at disturbing the balance of a market. In economics and market competition, collusion occurs within an industry when rival companies cooperate for their mutual benefit, deceiving, misleading, or defrauding others of their legal rights.

Collusion in the context of market manipulation can take several forms. One of the most common ways is price-fixing, where companies with identical products form an agreement to set prices collectively. This can lead to artificially low prices to eliminate smaller competitors or inflated prices to maximize profits. Another form is advertising synchronization, where businesses coordinate their campaigns to restrict consumer awareness of a product or service, giving them a competitive edge. Sharing insider information is another form of collusion, particularly in the financial industry, where colluding parties can execute trades based on non-public information.

The primary goal of collusion is often to gain an unfair market advantage, which can result in reduced competition, higher barriers for new market entrants, and harm to consumers and smaller businesses. Colluding parties may also collectively influence the market supply of a good or agree on a specific pricing level to maximize their profits.

Antitrust laws are specifically designed to prevent collusion and other anticompetitive practices. These laws aim to promote fair competition and protect consumers. Violations can result in substantial fines and legal consequences for companies involved in collusion. Whistleblowers also play a critical role in exposing collusion, and they are protected and incentivized to come forward.

In recent years, there has been growing concern about the potential for AI-driven market manipulation in financial markets. While AI is believed to enhance efficiency in capital markets, research has shown the risk of unintended AI collusion through collusive trading, which can compromise market efficiency and harm financial stability.

Frequently asked questions