Texas Abortion Law: Civil, Criminal, Or Both?

is texas abortion law civil or criminal

The Texas abortion law, also known as the Texas Heartbeat Act, prohibits physicians from performing abortions once a fetal heartbeat is detected, which is usually around six weeks into a pregnancy. This law is unique in that it leaves enforcement up to private citizens through civil lawsuits instead of criminal prosecutors. While the woman who has the abortion cannot be prosecuted, anyone who provided or aided in her abortion is open to criminal prosecution. The law provides for enforcement through a private civil action or under the state's criminal statutes, punishable by up to life in prison. The constitutionality of the Texas Heartbeat Act is a matter of intense legal controversy, with several legal challenges pending in state and federal courts.

Characteristics Values
Nature of the law Civil and criminal
Enforcement Civil lawsuits and criminal prosecution
Who can be sued? Abortion providers, anyone who aids or abets an abortion
Who can be prosecuted? Anyone who performs or aids an abortion
Who is exempt from prosecution? The woman who had the abortion
Who can bring a civil suit? Any private citizen
Who can prosecute? Texas district attorneys
Penalties $10,000 civil penalty, $100,000 civil penalty, 5 to 99 years in prison

lawshun

Who can be prosecuted under the Texas abortion law?

The Texas abortion law does not allow for the prosecution of the woman who had the abortion or the mother/parent. However, anyone who provided or aided in the abortion can be prosecuted. This includes:

  • Medical personnel, including doctors and nurses
  • A family member or friend who helps pay for the procedure
  • A pharmacist who sells abortion medication
  • Anyone who hands a medication abortion pill to another person
  • Anyone who drives the patient to a clinic or the place of the abortion

The Texas abortion law also allows for civil lawsuits against the same party.

The Texas abortion law makes it a second-degree felony to "knowingly perform, induce, or attempt an abortion". The penalty is increased to a first-degree felony if the unborn child dies due to the offense. Performing or aiding an abortion resulting in the unborn child's death is a first-degree felony punishable by five to 99 years in prison.

In addition to criminal penalties, there are also civil penalties for violating the Texas abortion law. Texas Government Code Sec. 171.203, commonly known as the "heartbeat law", imposes a civil penalty of $10,000 for anyone performing an abortion after a fetal heartbeat is detected. The law also allows any private citizen to sue for this amount, plus court costs and attorney fees.

It is important to note that the Texas abortion law does not allow for the prosecution of the woman who had the abortion or the mother/parent. Texas law explicitly prohibits prosecuting a pregnant patient who undergoes an abortion.

lawshun

What are the penalties for performing an abortion in Texas?

Texas abortion laws are some of the most restrictive in the nation, providing for a near-total ban on abortion. The Texas abortion law makes it a second-degree felony for a person who knowingly performs, induces, or attempts an abortion. The penalty is increased to a first-degree felony if the unborn child dies due to the offence.

Under the law, administrative penalties include the mandatory revocation of a medical, nursing, or pharmacy license. The Texas Attorney General can also seek civil penalties of $100,000 per incident, plus attorney fees and court costs. If a pregnancy is terminated via abortion, the physician or other provider can face prison time of five to 99 years or life imprisonment, a $10,000 fine, or both. If a foetus survives an abortion, they can face two to 20 years in prison, a $10,000 fine, or both.

The Texas abortion law does not create a criminal cause of action against the mother or parent. It does create a criminal cause of action against doctors. The woman who had the abortion cannot be prosecuted, but anyone who provided or aided in her abortion is open to criminal prosecution.

The Texas Heartbeat Act prohibits all abortions after the detection of a foetal heartbeat at six weeks, despite the heart not being formed at that point and there being no sound medical evidence to support the claim. The term "fetal heartbeat" is subject to debate among medical experts as pulsing may be detected at six weeks into a pregnancy, but a formed heart doesn't appear until the 10th week.

The Texas abortion law creates a civil penalty of $10,000 for anyone performing an abortion after a foetal heartbeat is detected. There is no criminal penalty, but it allows any private citizen to sue for the $10,000, court costs, and attorney fees.

lawshun

What are the exceptions to the Texas abortion law?

The Texas abortion law prohibits physicians from performing abortions once a fetal heartbeat is detected. However, there are some exceptions to this law. Firstly, the law does not apply if the pregnant patient faces "a life-threatening physical condition aggravated by, caused by, or arising from a pregnancy". In such cases, a licensed physician is permitted to perform an abortion, but they must also attempt to save the life of the fetus unless doing so would increase the risk of the pregnant patient's death or impairment.

Additionally, in August 2023, Texas Governor Greg Abbott signed HB 3058 into law, which allows doctors to provide abortions in the case of an ectopic pregnancy or if a pregnant patient's water breaks too early, rendering the fetus unviable. It's important to note that the Texas abortion law does not make exceptions for pregnancies resulting from rape or incest.

lawshun

How does the Texas abortion law compare to those in other states?

The Texas abortion law prohibits physicians from performing abortions once a fetal heartbeat is detected, which is usually around six weeks into a pregnancy. This law took effect on September 1, 2021, and sparked heated debates and legal challenges across the nation. The law does not make exceptions for rape or incest, and it allows any private citizen to sue Texas abortion providers or anyone who "aids or abets" a woman in getting an abortion. The person bringing the lawsuit is entitled to at least $10,000 in damages if they prevail in court.

Texas is one of 14 states with laws either banning abortion entirely or prohibiting it after eight weeks or less of pregnancy. The other states with similar laws include Alabama, Arkansas, Georgia, Iowa, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, North Dakota, Ohio, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Utah. However, the courts have blocked the implementation of these laws in these states.

The key difference between the Texas law and those in other states is the enforcement mechanism. The Texas law relies on citizens suing abortion providers over alleged violations, while other states sought to enforce their statutes through government actions like criminal charges against physicians who provide abortions.

In addition, Texas has resurrected a 1925 law that opens abortion providers to lawsuits and civil penalties. This law creates a civil penalty of $10,000 for anyone performing an abortion after a fetal heartbeat is detected, and it allows any private citizen to sue for this amount, as well as court costs and attorney fees.

The Texas abortion law also stands out for its lack of clear exceptions for medical emergencies. While there are nominally exceptions to save the mother's life or prevent "substantial impairment of major bodily function", the law is written ambiguously, and attempts to clarify and codify these exceptions have been rejected by Republican lawmakers in Texas. This has prompted expecting mothers with health complications to leave the state or give birth while jeopardizing their health.

Overall, the Texas abortion law is one of the most restrictive in the country and has had a significant impact on abortion access and reproductive rights in the state.

lawshun

What is the history of abortion laws in Texas?

The history of abortion laws in Texas can be traced back to the 19th century when abortion was illegal in the state unless it was necessary to save the mother's life. In 1854, an Act was passed in Texas that made it a criminal offence to attempt to "procure the miscarriage of any woman being with child". This was followed by the formal codification of the Penal Code in 1856, which included provisions related to abortions. Over the years, the abortion statutes were renumbered and amended, but the substance remained largely the same.

In 1973, the landmark Supreme Court case Roe v. Wade struck down Texas's abortion law, finding that it violated the constitutional right to privacy. This ruling effectively legalised abortion across the United States. However, Texas and other states continued to impose restrictions on abortion access.

In 2003, Texas passed the "Woman's Right to Know Act", which mandated that doctors provide misleading information about abortion procedures and alternatives to termination. The law also required patients to wait 24 hours before the procedure and mandated that abortions after 16 weeks be performed in an ambulatory surgical centre.

In subsequent years, Texas enacted several additional restrictions on abortion, including bans on third-trimester abortions, parental consent requirements for minors, and mandatory sonogram laws. In 2013, Texas passed House Bill 2, which imposed several new restrictions, including a ban on abortions after 20 weeks, admitting privilege requirements for doctors, and mandatory state protocols for medication abortions.

In 2016, the Supreme Court struck down two key provisions of House Bill 2, finding that they placed an undue burden on women's access to abortion. Despite this, Texas continued to pass new abortion restrictions, including bans on certain abortion procedures, insurance coverage mandates, and restrictions on fetal tissue disposal.

In 2021, Texas passed Senate Bill 8, which banned abortion as early as six weeks into pregnancy and authorised private individuals to file civil lawsuits against anyone who performs or aids in an illegal abortion. This law effectively eliminated abortion access in the state.

In 2022, the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, holding that there was no longer a federal constitutional right to abortion. As a result, Texas's near-total ban on abortion went into effect.

Frequently asked questions

No, the statute explicitly prohibits prosecuting a pregnant patient who undergoes an abortion.

Anyone who performs or aids an abortion or intends to perform or aid an abortion could be criminally prosecuted under the Texas abortion law.

No, the perpetrator of rape, sexual assault, or incest can't sue the victim or anyone who provided or assisted the victim in receiving an abortion.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment