Sec's Power Grab: Law Unto Itself?

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is an independent federal agency created in 1934 to regulate the U.S. securities markets and protect investors. In recent years, the SEC has faced criticism for its increasing use of in-house administrative proceedings to handle securities fraud cases, such as insider trading, rather than bringing these cases to court. This has led to concerns that the SEC is becoming a law unto itself and poses a danger to the impartial development of the law. The SEC's use of in-house courts has been specifically criticised by U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff, who has urged the agency to reconsider its approach. While the SEC has a mandate to protect investors and maintain fair, orderly, and efficient markets, there are questions about whether its increased use of administrative proceedings could hinder these goals.

The SEC's use of in-house courts

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is an independent federal agency that was created in 1934 in response to the 1929 stock market crash. The SEC is tasked with enforcing laws against market manipulation and maintaining fair, orderly, and efficient markets.

The SEC has the power to pursue enforcement cases in-house, with trials decided by staff SEC judges rather than juries. This has raised concerns among some, including U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff, who warned that the SEC's growing use of administrative proceedings to handle securities fraud cases poses "dangers" to the impartial development of the law.

In a 2014 speech, Rakoff urged the SEC to reconsider its use of in-house courts, stating:

> "I see no good reason to displace that constitutional alternative with administrative fiat... [Consider] that it is neither in its own long-term interest, nor in the interest of the securities markets, nor in the interest of the public as a whole, for the SEC to become, in effect, a law unto itself."

In recent years, the SEC has increased the number of administrative cases it brings, which has coincided with a series of well-publicized insider trading losses in court. For example, in the 2013 fiscal year, the SEC launched 235 administrative proceedings, up 10.3% from 2013. This increase in administrative cases may be due to the SEC's 100% win record in such cases, compared to a 61% success rate in federal court trials in the same period.

However, defenders of the SEC's use of in-house courts argue that it allows for more efficient and specialised handling of complex securities law cases. The SEC's administrative judges are experts in the field, and the in-house court system helps to reduce the burden on the federal court system.

The SEC's role in investor protection

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) was established in 1934, in the aftermath of the 1929 stock market crash and the subsequent Great Depression. The SEC's primary purpose is to enforce laws against market manipulation and protect investors.

The SEC requires public companies to disclose meaningful financial and other information to the public, creating a common pool of knowledge for all investors to judge if a company's securities are a good investment. The SEC also oversees other key participants in the securities world, including stock exchanges, broker-dealers, investment advisors, mutual funds, and public utility holding companies.

The SEC brings between 400-500 civil enforcement actions each year against individuals and companies that break securities laws. Typical infractions include insider trading, accounting fraud, and providing false or misleading information about securities and the companies that issue them.

The SEC has five commissioners, each appointed by the U.S. president, with one designated as chair. The SEC is headquartered in Washington, D.C., and has five divisions, 24-25 offices, and over 4,500 staff across the U.S.

Division of Corporation Finance

This division ensures investors are provided with material information about a company's financial condition and business operations to make informed investment decisions. The division's staff evaluates whether public companies have fulfilled their disclosure obligations and works to improve the quality of the disclosure.

Division of Economic and Risk Analysis

This division provides economic analysis, risk assessment, and data analytics expertise to support policy development, rulemaking, enforcement, and examinations.

Division of Enforcement

The Division of Enforcement investigates and prosecutes violations of federal securities laws and regulations. The SEC has the authority to bring civil charges in federal court or administrative proceedings. In addition, the division coordinates with criminal law enforcement agencies to develop and bring criminal cases when appropriate.

Division of Examinations

The Division of Examinations administers the SEC's nationwide examination and inspection program for self-regulatory organizations, broker-dealers, transfer agents, clearing agencies, investment companies, and investment advisors. The office conducts inspections to foster compliance with securities laws, detect violations, and keep the SEC informed of developments in the regulated community.

Division of Investment Management

The Division of Investment Management works to protect investors, promote informed investment decisions, and facilitate appropriate innovation in investment products and services through regulating the asset management industry. The division is responsible for the Commission's regulation of investment companies, variable insurance products, and federally registered investment advisors.

In summary, the SEC plays a crucial role in protecting investors and maintaining fair, orderly, and efficient markets. Through its regulatory, enforcement, and data analysis functions, the SEC ensures that investors have access to the information they need to make sound investment decisions and holds accountable those who engage in fraudulent or manipulative activities.

The SEC's enforcement powers

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is an independent federal agency that enforces securities laws and regulations. It was created in 1934 to restore investor confidence in the wake of the 1929 stock market crash. The SEC has five divisions and 23 offices, with goals to interpret and enforce securities laws, issue new rules, oversee securities institutions, and coordinate regulations among different parts of the government.

The Division of Corporate Finance ensures investors receive material information about a company's financial condition and business operations to make informed investment decisions.

The Division of Enforcement investigates and prosecutes violations of federal securities laws and regulations. It can bring civil charges in federal court or administrative proceedings before an administrative law judge. The division also works with law enforcement agencies and refers criminal cases to the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ).

The Division of Investment Management regulates investment companies, variable insurance products, and federally registered investment advisors.

The Division of Economic and Risk Analysis is the SEC's economics and data analytics unit.

The Division of Trading and Markets establishes and maintains standards for fair, orderly, and efficient markets. It oversees major securities market participants, including securities exchanges, securities firms, self-regulatory organizations, transfer agents, and securities information processors.

The SEC's authority to impose civil penalties through administrative proceedings was limited by a 2024 Supreme Court decision in SEC v. Jarkesy. The court ruled that this practice violated the Seventh Amendment right to a jury trial, requiring the SEC to pursue such penalties in federal court for securities fraud cases.

The SEC's independence

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is an independent federal government regulatory agency responsible for protecting investors and maintaining fair, efficient, and orderly securities markets. It was created in 1934 as the first federal regulator of the securities markets in the aftermath of the 1929 stock market crash.

The SEC is composed of five commissioners, appointed by the President of the United States, with staggered five-year terms. By law, no more than three of the commissioners may belong to the same political party, promoting nonpartisanship in the agency's decision-making. The President designates one of the commissioners as Chairman, who serves as the SEC's chief executive.

The SEC's divisions and offices work together to interpret and enforce securities laws, issue new rules, oversee securities institutions, and coordinate regulations among different parts of the government. The SEC brings civil actions against those who violate securities laws or regulations and refers criminal cases to the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ).

While the SEC has broad powers, its authority to impose civil penalties through administrative proceedings has been limited by a 2024 Supreme Court decision in SEC v. Jarkesy. The Court ruled that the SEC's practice of imposing civil penalties through in-house administrative proceedings violates the Seventh Amendment right to a jury trial. As a result, the SEC must now pursue such penalties in federal court for securities fraud cases.

The SEC's role in market integrity

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is an independent federal agency that was created in the aftermath of the 1929 Wall Street crash. Its role in market integrity is threefold: to protect investors, maintain fair, orderly, and efficient markets, and facilitate capital formation.

To achieve its mandate, the SEC enforces the Securities Act of 1933, the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, and other statutes. The SEC requires public companies and other regulated entities to submit quarterly and annual reports, as well as other periodic disclosures. These include annual financial reports and a "management discussion and analysis" (MD&A) that outlines the company's operations and performance in the previous year. The MD&A also usually addresses future goals and approaches to new projects.

The SEC maintains an online database called EDGAR (the Electronic Data Gathering, Analysis, and Retrieval system), which investors can use to access information filed with the agency, such as reports. EDGAR also accepts tips and complaints from investors to help the SEC track down violators of securities laws, as well as offering educational materials on investment-related topics.

The SEC has five divisions that interpret and enforce securities laws, issue new rules, oversee securities institutions, and coordinate regulations among different parts of the government. These divisions are:

• Division of Corporation Finance: Ensures investors are provided with relevant information as they make investment decisions.
• Division of Enforcement: In charge of enforcing SEC regulations by investigating cases and bringing civil suits in federal court or administrative proceedings.
• Division of Investment Management: Regulates investment companies, variable insurance products, and federally registered investment advisors.
• Division of Economic and Risk Analysis: The SEC's economics and data analytics unit.
• Division of Trading and Markets: Establishes and maintains standards for fair, orderly, and efficient markets.

In summary, the SEC plays a crucial role in maintaining market integrity by enforcing securities laws, promoting transparency, and protecting investors from fraudulent and manipulative practices.

Frequently asked questions