Trespassing: When Does It Become Illegal?

Trespassing is a crime that can result in serious consequences, including jail time and fines. It is defined as entering or remaining on someone else's property without permission or a right to do so. This can include private property, public property, or private property that is open to the public. Trespassing is typically classified as a misdemeanour, but it can be upgraded to a felony in certain circumstances, such as if there is a risk of harm to others. In addition to criminal charges, trespassers can also face civil liability, as trespassing is a violation of someone's property rights.

Trespassing on public property

Trespassing is a criminal offence. It involves intentionally entering or remaining on someone else's property without authorisation. While state laws define criminal trespassing differently, the typical elements of criminal trespassing are:

• Entering or remaining on property which you know you do not have the right to enter, or
• Remaining on property after learning you do not have the right to be there.

Both require some form of criminal intent. Trespassing can occur on both private and public property. The status of being public property does not give the public the authority to access the property however they want. For instance, the public doesn't have a right to enter all areas of a government building. Like private buildings, certain areas—like employee break rooms or offices—can be restricted. Other public properties may be entirely closed to the public, such as electric power transformers.

In the case of public property, the government has the power to issue No Trespass Orders (NTOs) to people who have misbehaved on said property. These orders tell people that if they return to the property in question, they may be arrested. However, members of the public have a right to enter government property that is generally open to the public, such as public parks or certain public areas of municipal buildings during business hours.

In the United States, the First Amendment grants citizens the right to record public officials in the performance of their duties. However, this right is not absolute, and can be restricted in certain places. For example, filming inside a police station lobby may be prohibited.

Trespassing on private property open to the public

Trespassing is a criminal offence that involves entering or remaining on someone else's property without their permission. Trespassing can occur on both public and private property. Even if you are allowed to enter a place that's open to the public, such as a store or park, you can still be convicted of criminal trespass if you stay after the space closes or fail to leave after being ordered to do so.

A person can also trespass on private property that is open to the public. For example, a customer who enters a store during business hours but refuses to leave at closing time is trespassing. Trespassing might also occur if you are lawfully in an area open to the public, such as a store showroom, but you decide to go into a room with signage indicating it's a private area, such as a storage room.

In most states, there must be an intent to commit a crime for it to be considered trespassing. The person trespassing must either go onto a property knowing that they don't have permission to be there or remain on the property after learning that they don't have the right to be there. Accidentally wandering onto someone's land while hiking, for example, typically isn't considered criminal trespass.

In many states, laws require that a warning or notice be posted or delivered before a person can be guilty of trespassing. A property owner can do this by directly telling a trespasser to leave the premises, or by putting up a sign saying "No Trespassing", a fence around the property, or a locked door to the property.

Criminal trespass vs. civil trespass

Trespassing is a legal term referring to various offenses against a person or property. It involves entering real property without the landowner's consent. Trespassing can be further categorized into criminal trespass and civil trespass. While both types of trespassing involve entering property without permission, there are important distinctions between criminal and civil trespass, including the enforcing authorities, the intent requirements, and the consequences.

Criminal Trespass

Criminal trespass laws are enforced by police, sheriffs, or park rangers. Criminal trespass occurs when a person "knowingly" enters or remains on real property (land, building, etc.) without permission or legal authorization. This can include entering private property, hopping a fence, entering a building, or remaining on the property after being asked to leave by the owner. Criminal trespass charges typically require a higher level of intent and knowledge, meaning the trespasser must be aware that they are entering or remaining on the property without authorization.

The severity of criminal trespass charges can vary depending on the jurisdiction and the specific circumstances of the offense. For example, in Arizona, there are three degrees of criminal trespassing, with varying penalties, including expensive fines and jail or prison sentences. First-degree criminal trespass is the most severe and typically involves residential properties or critical public service facilities. Second-degree criminal trespass usually involves non-residential properties or unfenced residential yards. Third-degree criminal trespass involves entering or remaining on property after being asked to leave by the owner or a lawful authority.

Civil Trespass

Civil trespass, on the other hand, is a separate type of case brought against the trespasser by the property owner. In civil trespass, the property owner initiates a private enforcement action for trespass to land in court. The landowner can enforce their legal rights through tort law, which addresses wrongful civil acts. Civil trespass allows landowners to seek compensation for any damages caused by the trespasser, regardless of whether a crime has been committed.

While civil trespass may not result in criminal penalties such as jail time, it can still have significant financial consequences for the trespasser. Landowners can sue for damages and hold trespassers liable for any harm or loss caused to their property. Additionally, civil trespass may also be used to establish adverse possession or continuous trespasser's rights in some jurisdictions.

In summary, the key difference between criminal trespass and civil trespass lies in the enforcing authorities, the intent requirements, and the consequences. Criminal trespass is enforced by criminal justice authorities and focuses on the intentional and unauthorized entry or presence on private property. It carries criminal penalties, including fines and imprisonment. Civil trespass, on the other hand, is a civil matter where landowners seek compensation for damages caused by trespassers. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for property owners and individuals to protect their rights and ensure compliance with the law.

Trespassing resulting in harm or injury

Trespassing is a criminal offence, and in most cases, property owners will not be held liable for any harm or injury that befalls a trespasser. However, there are some exceptions to this rule.

Willful and Wanton Conduct

If a property owner engages in willful and wanton conduct, they may be found liable for a trespasser's injuries. This means that if a property owner acts with reckless disregard for the safety of others, they can be held responsible for any harm that comes to a trespasser. For example, if a property owner has a dog with known dangerous tendencies, and this dog injures a trespasser, the property owner may be found liable.

Attractive Nuisance

The doctrine of attractive nuisance means that a property owner may be liable for a trespasser's injuries, especially if the trespasser is a child. For example, if a property owner has a pool or a trampoline on their property that could attract children, they have a duty to secure it to ensure the safety of anyone who might access it, whether they are invited or not.

Discovered Trespassers

If a property owner is aware of the presence of a trespasser, they have a duty to warn them of any known hazards on the property that could result in injury. For example, if a homeowner sees a group of teenagers regularly cutting through their property and knows there is a dangerous hole in the yard, they must either tell the teenagers to leave the property or warn them about the hole. If a trespasser is injured and the property owner did nothing to prevent it, the owner could be considered responsible.

Duty of Care

Property owners have a duty of care to provide a reasonable level of safety by maintaining their property to a reasonable level. If a trespasser is injured by a hazard that could also impact a guest or visitor, then the property owner has failed in this duty, and their negligence would make them responsible for the trespasser's damages.

State-Specific Laws

It is important to note that trespassing laws can vary by state, and some states have specific laws regarding trespassing and the use of force. For example, in California, trespassing is a misdemeanour, while in Kentucky, a conviction for entering another person's home without permission can result in up to a year in jail and a fine.

In conclusion, while trespassing is a criminal offence, property owners may still be held liable for any harm or injury that comes to a trespasser in certain circumstances. These circumstances include willful and wanton conduct, attractive nuisances, discovered trespassers, failure to uphold a duty of care, and state-specific laws.

Trespassing and breaking and entering

Breaking and entering, on the other hand, involves the use of force, however slight, to gain entry into a building or residence. It generally requires the intent to commit another crime, such as robbery, theft, or arson. Breaking and entering is often considered a more severe type of criminal offence than trespassing and is often classified as a felony.

In most states, the specific intent to interfere with another person's property rights and the actual interference of those property rights are required for trespassing to be considered a crime. Additionally, in many states, a warning or notice must be posted or delivered before a person can be found guilty of trespassing. This can be done through verbal warnings, posted signs, fences, or locked doors.

The penalties for trespassing and breaking and entering vary from state to state. For example, in California, trespassing is typically a misdemeanour, while breaking and entering is often a felony. In Wisconsin, criminal trespass to dwellings is a misdemeanour and can result in up to 9 months in jail and a $10,000 fine.

Frequently asked questions