Christians' Ethical Dilemma: Report Criminals Or Not?

The Bible does not explicitly state whether Christians should report fellow believers for breaking secular laws. However, there are several passages that can guide Christians in this situation. For instance, Romans 13:1-6 states that the governing authorities are God's servants, agents of wrath to bring punishment on the wrongdoer. This suggests that Christians should submit to and cooperate with secular authorities in bringing criminals to justice. On the other hand, 1 Corinthians 6, where Paul prohibits civil litigation against fellow Christians, does not refer to criminal offences and should not be used to prevent Christians from reporting crimes or offering to be a witness. Ultimately, it is a matter of individual conscience for Christians to decide whether to report a fellow believer to secular authorities for breaking the law, taking into account the seriousness of the crime and the potential consequences for the victim and society.

Christians are obligated to report serious crimes

Additionally, Christians should seek justice and protect others in their community from harm. In cases of severe crimes, such as robbery, assault, rape, or murder, failing to report the crime and allowing the perpetrator to go unpunished could put others at risk.

It is important to note that Christians should also pray for and show love towards those who commit crimes, even as they report them to the authorities. This includes blessing those who curse them and praying for their persecutors, as Christ instructed.

When deciding whether to report a crime, Christians should use wisdom and discernment, considering all the facts and circumstances involved. Not every crime may need to be reported, and Christians should be slow to anger and quick to forgive when offences are minor. However, in cases of serious crimes, Christians have a responsibility to cooperate with the governing authorities to help maintain justice and protect the community.

Christians should not forgive serious crimes

Christians are encouraged to forgive others if they wish to be forgiven by God. However, this does not mean that they should not report serious crimes to the relevant authorities. In fact, reporting a crime and seeking justice can be seen as a way to protect others from harm and uphold God's objectives of maintaining order and punishing wrongdoing.

When it comes to serious crimes, Christians should not simply forgive and forget. While forgiveness is an important aspect of the Christian faith, it is not appropriate or safe to overlook severe offences. If a Christian is aware of a serious crime, they have a responsibility to address it through the proper channels. This may involve reporting the crime to the police, providing witness testimony, or seeking justice through the legal system. By doing so, they can help protect others from potential harm and ensure that the perpetrator is held accountable for their actions.

In the Bible, Jesus himself sought the hearts of human beings and accepted sinners who repented with tears. However, he also understood the importance of justice and recognised that those who do not come to understand their sins and repent will remain under God's curse. Therefore, Christians should strive to emulate Jesus' example by showing compassion and forgiveness while also upholding justice and protecting the vulnerable.

Additionally, it is important to recognise that forgiveness does not negate the need for consequences. Forgiving someone for a serious crime does not mean excusing their actions or releasing them from the legal repercussions. Instead, it can be seen as a way to free oneself from the burden of anger, bitterness, and the desire for revenge. It is about letting go of judgement and leaving the ultimate judgement to God, while still holding the perpetrator accountable in the earthly realm.

In conclusion, while Christians are called to forgive, this does not extend to condoning or ignoring serious crimes. Christians should report and address serious crimes through the appropriate channels, seeking justice and protection for all involved while also offering forgiveness and compassion where possible.

Christians should forgive minor offences

Christians are encouraged to forgive others, as Jesus forgave those who persecuted him. In the Lord's Prayer, Christians ask God to "forgive us our debts, as we also have forgiven our debtors" (Matthew 6:12). This suggests that forgiveness is reciprocal and that Christians should forgive others as they themselves are forgiven by God.

The Bible also states that "forgiveness is a choice". It is not easy to forgive, but it is a choice that Christians are called to make. Forgiveness benefits both the offended and the offender. It frees the offended, allowing them to love, trust, and live again.

There are two types of forgiveness: conditional and unconditional. Conditional forgiveness is granted when the offending party shows remorse, repents, and asks for forgiveness. Unconditional forgiveness is granted without the offender's repentance. While Christians are called to forgive unconditionally, this typically applies to minor offences. For more serious offences, Christians are encouraged to withhold forgiveness until the offender repents, as this can be an act of love, encouraging the offender to turn to God.

Christians are also called to cooperate with secular authorities, as they are ultimately appointed by God to maintain order and punish wrongdoing. However, this does not necessarily mean that Christians must report every minor offence committed by another believer. It is a matter of conscience and wisdom, based on the specific circumstances and facts of the case.

Therefore, while Christians are called to forgive minor offences, they should also use their discernment in deciding how to respond. In some cases, it may be appropriate to forgive and move on, while in other cases, it may be necessary to address the issue directly with the offender or seek guidance from church leaders or authorities.

Christians should report crimes to protect others

Christians are called to protect themselves and their loved ones from thugs and to acquire justice when a crime is committed. This is a matter of protecting oneself and others in the community from wicked thugs, as well as acquiring justice when a crime is committed.

Christians should not dismiss the offense or forgive the person's transgression when the offender is stubbornly unrepentant. Instead, they should report the crime to the governing authorities, who are established by God to punish criminals and hold the power to execute when appropriate. By reporting crimes, Christians are effectively helping God to pursue His objectives.

For example, if a Christian witnessed a fellow believer committing a serious crime such as rape, assault, robbery, or murder, they should not automatically forgive the offender. Instead, they should first contact the police and do everything in their power to apprehend justice.

In some jurisdictions, not reporting a crime and/or failing to render aid is a crime itself. Therefore, Christians have a civic duty to report crimes and provide evidence for the prosecution, regardless of whether the accused is a fellow believer or not.

However, it is important to note that reporting a crime is not always obligatory, and it should be a matter of conscience and wisdom, based on all the facts of the case and the circumstances involved.

Christians should report crimes to uphold justice

Christians are called to be peaceable and walk in patient peaceableness in trying circumstances. However, this does not mean that they should be submissive doormats to abuse and crime. The Bible teaches that Christians should be slow to anger and gracious, but it does not teach passive submission to wickedness.

In the book of Romans, Paul writes that the governing authorities are God's servants, agents of wrath to bring punishment on the wrongdoer. This means that Christians should submit to the governing authorities and report crimes, as this is a way of upholding justice and protecting the community from wickedness.

Additionally, in the book of Isaiah, it is written that the Lord loves justice and hates crime. Justice and righteousness are the very foundation of God's throne. Therefore, Christians should not be passive in the face of crime but should actively seek justice by reporting it to the proper authorities.

In conclusion, Christians should report crimes to uphold justice, protect the community, and honour God. By doing so, they are fulfilling their civic duty and helping to maintain peace and order in society.

Frequently asked questions