Morality Vs. Health: When Does Breaking The Law Heal?

Breaking the law can have serious repercussions, including unlimited fines and prison sentences. However, there are times when people feel they have no choice but to break the law for the sake of their health or the health of their loved ones. For example, in the UK, some parents are turning to the illegal market to obtain medicinal cannabis to treat their children's severe epilepsy, as they cannot afford or access it legally. This raises ethical questions about whether it is ever justifiable to break the law, even if it is for a noble cause.

Breaking the law to access life-saving treatments

In some cases, individuals may choose to break the law to obtain treatment that has been denied by their health insurance company. For example, insurance companies may put their profits before people's lives and deny coverage for life-saving treatments due to cost concerns or by claiming lack of medical necessity. This can result in patients being forced to accept less effective alternative treatments or, sadly, losing their lives because they cannot access the treatments they need. In such cases, breaking the law to access life-saving treatments may be a matter of survival.

Financial barriers can also drive individuals to break the law to access life-saving treatments. Medical treatments can be expensive, and not everyone can afford the costs associated with necessary medical care. As a result, some people may resort to illegal means to obtain treatment, such as purchasing medications or treatments on the black market or travelling to countries with more accessible healthcare systems.

Additionally, there are instances where individuals may break the law to access treatments that are not approved or available in their country of residence. For example, a person may seek out an experimental treatment for a rare disease that is not yet approved by the relevant health authorities. In their desperation to find a cure, they may turn to illegal or unregulated sources for treatment.

However, it is important to consider the potential risks and consequences of breaking the law to access life-saving treatments. Depending on the specific circumstances and jurisdiction, individuals may face legal repercussions such as fines, imprisonment, or both. The magnitude of these penalties can vary depending on the nature and seriousness of the offence, as well as whether anyone was harmed as a result. Furthermore, there may be unknown risks associated with obtaining treatments through illegal or unregulated means, including the potential for unsafe or ineffective treatments.

In conclusion, while breaking the law to access life-saving treatments may be a last resort for some individuals, it is a complex ethical issue that requires careful consideration. It highlights the importance of ensuring that everyone has equal access to necessary and affordable medical care, as well as the need for robust regulatory systems that prioritize public health and patient well-being.

The ethics of breaking the law

Breaking the law can have serious consequences, including financial penalties, imprisonment, and damage to one's reputation. However, there are times when breaking the law may be ethically justifiable.

Laws are not always a reflection of ethical principles, and what is considered ethical may fall outside the boundaries of the law. For instance, in the 1940s, people who hid Jews to protect them from Nazi officers were breaking the law, but their actions were ethically justifiable as they were saving lives. Similarly, in 1962, Helmut Schmidt, the Interior Senator of Hamburg, called on the Bundeswehr—the only organization with large helicopters—to rescue people during a severe storm, despite it being forbidden to use the Bundeswehr inside the country. Schmidt's actions broke the law but were ethical as they saved lives.

In the context of health, breaking the law can have life-saving implications. For example, in the UK, medicinal cannabis was legalized in 2018, but full-spectrum medicines containing the psychoactive ingredient THC have not been officially licensed. As a result, some parents of children with severe, treatment-resistant epilepsy have resorted to obtaining these medicines illegally, either by buying them online or smuggling them from the Netherlands. While these actions are illegal, they are ethically justifiable as they are improving the quality of life for these children and reducing the frequency and severity of their seizures.

However, breaking the law, even for ethical reasons, does not absolve one of the potential legal consequences. In the case of health and safety law breaches in the UK, individuals may face unlimited fines or imprisonment, depending on the seriousness of the offence and whether harm was caused.

Health and safety laws in the workplace

In the United States, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) was established in 1970 to set and enforce protective workplace safety and health standards. The agency's mission is to ensure safe and healthy working conditions for workers by setting standards, providing training, and offering compliance assistance. OSHA covers employers and their employees in the US, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, and other US territories.

OSHA standards require employers to identify workplace hazards and take steps to mitigate them. This includes providing protective equipment, such as gloves, harnesses, and goggles, and ensuring that workers are protected from toxic chemicals and other known health risks. Employers are also required to keep records of work-related injuries and illnesses, and to provide training in a language that all employees understand.

The consequences of failing to comply with health and safety laws can be severe. In addition to facing criminal prosecution, businesses may be subject to unlimited fines, imprisonment, or both. The size of the fine and the severity of the punishment depend on the seriousness of the offence, whether it was deliberate, and if anyone was injured as a result.

For example, in 2022, B&M was fined £1 million after an electrician suffered severe burns during a warehouse explosion, and Carlsberg was fined £3 million after a contractor died due to an ammonia leak. In another case, two directors of a metal recycling company received 9-month jail sentences when a wall collapse killed five workers.

Therefore, it is crucial for businesses to prioritize health and safety in the workplace, not only to comply with the law but also to protect their employees, customers, and the public from harm.

The consequences of breaking health and safety laws

Health and safety laws are in place to protect employees, customers, and the general public from risks at work. These laws apply to all businesses, regardless of industry. Compliance with health and safety regulations is essential to keep people safe from harm, and neglecting these obligations can have serious consequences.

Financial Consequences

Breaking health and safety laws can result in unlimited fines. These fines are no longer capped and can exceed a company's annual profits. For example, in 2022, Northern Gas was fined £5 million plus £91,000 in costs after a lady died in a fire and gas explosion at a residential property.

Reputation Damage

Even if a company can afford to pay the fine, the damage to its reputation might be irreparable. Negative publicity and public shaming by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) can lead to a loss of trust and business.

Personal Consequences

The guilt of being responsible for someone's injury or death is a heavy burden to bear. The consequences of health and safety breaches can be life-changing or even fatal for those affected.

Legal Consequences

Health and safety breaches can result in criminal prosecution, with individuals or companies being found guilty of criminal offences. This can lead to imprisonment, with sentences ranging from a few months to several years, depending on the seriousness of the offence. In addition, those found guilty may face civil claims brought by injured parties or their dependents.

Other Penalties

Other consequences of breaking health and safety laws include:

• Improvement or prohibition notices, requiring the offender to rectify health and safety failings.
• Being ordered to pay costs and compensation if prosecuted.
• Company directors or self-employed individuals may be banned from running a company.
• Adverse PR and disclosure in tenders.

The legality of breaking the law for health reasons

Breaking the law can have serious consequences, and the decision to do so should not be taken lightly. However, there are times when people feel they have no choice but to break the law for health reasons. This can include situations where individuals are facing life-threatening illnesses or injuries and believe that breaking the law is their only option for accessing potentially life-saving treatments.

For example, in the UK, while medicinal cannabis was legalised in 2018, full-spectrum medicines containing the psychoactive ingredient THC have not been officially licensed. As a result, some parents of children with severe, treatment-resistant epilepsy have resorted to purchasing these medicines illegally, either online or by travelling to countries where they can be bought legally and smuggling them back into the UK. While these parents are risking prosecution and even imprisonment, they feel it is worth the risk to improve their children's quality of life and save them from potentially fatal seizures.

Another example might be individuals in countries with restrictive abortion laws who seek out illegal abortions to protect their health or even their lives. In countries where abortion is illegal or highly restricted, women are often forced to continue with unwanted pregnancies, which can have serious physical and mental health consequences.

In other cases, individuals may break the law to protect the health and safety of others. For instance, an employer might be found guilty of health and safety breaches if they fail to provide a safe working environment for their employees, potentially resulting in injuries or even deaths.

While breaking the law for health reasons may sometimes be justifiable from an ethical standpoint, it is important to remember that there can be legal repercussions, including fines, imprisonment, and damage to one's reputation.

Frequently asked questions