Federal Law Violations: Understanding The Grave Repercussions

Breaking the law can result in various consequences, depending on the crime committed and the jurisdiction in which it was committed. In the United States, individuals who break federal laws may face community service, fines, or imprisonment. The specific punishment depends on the severity of the crime, with minor misdemeanours often resulting in community service or fines, while more serious offences, such as burglary, assault, and drug-related crimes, can lead to incarceration. Additionally, the legal system and consequences differ for minors, who are usually tried in juvenile court and may face probation, placement in foster care, or, in serious cases, time in a juvenile institution. While federal laws apply across the country, it is important to note that state laws and procedures can vary, resulting in different consequences for similar crimes in different states.

Minors (under 18s) usually appear in juvenile court

In the United States, minors (people under the age of 18) who break the law will usually appear in juvenile court. Here, a judge hears the evidence and decides whether there is sufficient evidence to prove that the minor has broken the law. Minors rarely have a jury trial.

In most cases, the minor admits to the crime, and the judge may decide to put the child on probation, place them in a foster home, or, in more serious cases, send them to a juvenile institution. If the minor denies the crime, an adjudicatory hearing (similar to a criminal trial) is held, where the minor is represented by a lawyer. If the judge decides there is enough evidence, a second hearing is arranged to decide on a sentence.

The age of majority (and therefore the age of a minor) varies depending on the jurisdiction and the context. While it is commonly 18, the age of majority in the United States is set by individual states, and a "minor" can refer to someone under 21 in the context of alcohol, gambling, and handgun laws. In some states, minors aged 16 or 17 who are charged with extremely heinous crimes may be treated as adults.

Adults may be indicted or face an arraignment

When an adult is arrested for committing a serious crime, they may be indicted or face an arraignment. An indictment is a formal charging document for federal crimes. A grand jury will review the evidence gathered against the accused and decide if there is enough information for charges to be filed. The grand jury does not decide guilt or innocence but rather whether there is enough evidence to move forward with criminal charges and bring a case to trial.

If a grand jury determines there is probable cause, it issues a True Bill of Indictment. This establishes that there is sufficient evidence to proceed with criminal prosecution. However, it does not mean that the accused is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. The accused is entitled to a separate jury trial where they can confront and cross-examine witnesses against them.

After an indictment, the accused will be arrested and will appear in court for a bail hearing. The indictment or information will be read to the defendant, and they will have the option to enter a plea of guilty or not guilty. This is known as an arraignment. The defendant has the right to be present at the arraignment, but they may waive this right in certain circumstances. Video teleconferencing may also be used to arraign a defendant if they consent.

During the arraignment, the defendant will be informed of the charges brought against them and will have the opportunity to enter a plea. If the defendant pleads not guilty, the case will proceed to trial. It is important to note that an indictment is a serious matter, and the accused may face severe consequences if convicted, including the possibility of prison, fines, or other penalties.

Adults can be incarcerated, fined, or put on probation

Breaking the law has serious consequences, and these differ depending on the severity of the crime committed. When an adult breaks the law, they may be arrested by the police, and this can lead to a trial. The consequences of breaking the law can include incarceration, fines, or probation. These punishments are decided by a judge or jury during a trial, and they are based on the severity of the crime and whether the defendant has any prior convictions.

Incarceration, or imprisonment, is a common consequence of breaking the law. The duration of incarceration varies depending on the crime committed and the jurisdiction. For example, first-time non-violent offenders may only serve a few years in jail, while repeat and violent offenders may face life sentences or even the death penalty in some US states.

Fines are also a common punishment for breaking the law. The amount of the fine will depend on the severity of the crime and the jurisdiction. Minor misdemeanour offences, for instance, often result in a specified fine.

Probation is another possible consequence of breaking the law. Probation is a period of supervision imposed by a court instead of incarceration. It may include requirements such as regular check-ins with a probation officer, drug testing, community service, or participation in rehabilitation programs. Probation provides an opportunity for offenders to avoid jail time and work towards rehabilitation while being monitored by the criminal justice system.

It is important to note that the majority of crimes committed are state crimes, and criminal laws and procedures vary from state to state. Federal laws typically address crimes that occur across state lines or involve violations of the US Constitution. As a result, the consequences of breaking federal law can be more severe than those of breaking state law.

Police brutality often goes unpunished

Police brutality is the excessive and unwarranted use of force by law enforcement against civilians, causing physical or psychological harm. It includes beatings, intimidation, racist abuse, torture, and even killings. Despite efforts to combat police brutality, it often goes unpunished due to various factors, and this has severe consequences.

Firstly, police brutality erodes trust in law enforcement and the criminal justice system. When police officers are not held accountable for their actions, it sends a message that such behaviour is tolerated, perpetuating a cycle of abuse and impunity. This can lead to a breakdown in relations between law enforcement and the communities they serve, particularly among marginalised groups who already view the police with suspicion.

Secondly, police brutality undermines the rule of law and denies victims their constitutional rights. The legal doctrine of qualified immunity has been criticised as a tool that allows police brutality to go unpunished. This immunity protects officers from being sued for their use of violence if their actions can be justified under the law, creating a sense of impunity.

Thirdly, police brutality can lead to a culture of corruption and cover-ups within police departments. The "blue wall of silence" is an unofficial code where officers do not report misconduct by their colleagues, further enabling brutality to go unpunished. This code of silence is underpinned by fear of exile and a sense of "brotherhood" among officers, creating an insular culture that resists external scrutiny and reform.

Finally, police brutality has severe and lasting impacts on victims and their communities. It inflicts physical and emotional trauma, violates civil rights, and can even result in death. The psychological effects can be long-lasting, affecting the mental health and well-being of survivors and their families.

To address these consequences, various solutions have been proposed, including increased oversight through body-worn cameras, independent civilian review boards, improved training, demilitarisation of police forces, and legislative reforms such as the Justice in Policing Act of 2020. While these measures aim to increase accountability and reduce brutality, their effectiveness depends on proper implementation and a commitment to systemic change.

Community service is a common punishment for misdemeanors

The consequences of breaking federal law vary depending on the crime committed and the jurisdiction in which it was committed. In general, when an adult commits a serious crime and is arrested, there will be a trial. In some cases, plea bargaining occurs, where the defendant pleads guilty to a lesser offense or the prosecutor drops some charges in exchange for a guilty plea. If the defendant is found guilty, they will be convicted and sentenced. The sentence may include a fine, incarceration, probation, or, in some states, the death penalty.

The types of community service that may be ordered include cleaning and maintenance tasks, such as picking up litter or maintaining public parks; charitable work, such as helping at food banks or homeless shelters; education and mentoring, such as tutoring or mentoring young people; environmental conservation work; and public health initiatives. The average length of community service for misdemeanor cases is around 34 hours, but this can vary depending on the specific circumstances.

It is important to note that community service is a serious matter and failure to complete the required hours can result in serious consequences, including an arrest warrant for contempt of court or reinstatement of the original charges or sentence. Community service provides benefits to society by offering manpower for charitable organizations and public services, and it can also help relieve the financial burden on the prison system.

Frequently asked questions