Understanding Copyright Law: Breaking Rules, Facing Consequences

Copyright infringement can result in a range of penalties, depending on the jurisdiction and the severity of the offence. In the United States, copyright enforcement falls under federal courts, with copyright arising automatically once the creator commits the work to a fixed format. While infringement is typically a civil action, the US government can pursue criminal penalties for wilful infringement involving commercial profit. In the UK, the maximum term of incarceration for copyright infringement is 6 months and/or a fine of up to £50,000 in a magistrate's court. In more serious cases, the Crown Court can impose a maximum term of 10 years and/or an unlimited fine.

Fines and imprisonment

Copyright infringement can result in severe penalties, including fines and imprisonment. The penalties vary depending on the jurisdiction and the nature of the infringement.

In the United States, copyright infringement is ordinarily a civil action, with the copyright holder suing for damages. However, the US government can pursue criminal penalties if the infringement is deemed willful and involves commercial profit. If the infringer makes a retail profit of over $2,500 by selling 10 or more copies within a 180-day period, the infringement becomes a felony. This carries a maximum fine of $250,000 and up to five years in prison for a first offence, and 10 years for a second offence.

In the United Kingdom, the maximum fine for online copyright infringement is £50,000, and the maximum term of incarceration is 10 years. The UK's Intellectual Property Office (IPO) proposed increasing the maximum fine from £5,000 to £50,000 to align with the penalty for physical infringement and to act as a stronger deterrent. The IPO also suggested a maximum prison sentence of 10 years for the most serious cases of commercial gain from copyright infringement.

The UK's Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 outlines various offences and their respective penalties. For example, importing or making for sale or hire illicit recordings can result in a fine of up to £5,000 and/or six months' imprisonment, while distributing such recordings can carry an unlimited fine and/or 10 years' imprisonment. Possessing an unauthorised decoder can result in a £5,000 fine and/or six months' imprisonment, while distributing or advertising such decoders can lead to an unlimited fine and/or 10 years' imprisonment.

In addition to fines and imprisonment, other consequences of copyright infringement can include orders to pay damages, hand over profits and copies, and restraining orders to stop the infringing acts.

Injunction and confiscation

In the United States, the Copyright Law (Title 17) outlines the following with regard to injunctions and confiscation:

• Any court having jurisdiction of a civil action arising under this title may grant temporary and final injunctions to prevent or restrain infringement of a copyright.
• The court may order the impounding of all copies or phonorecords claimed to have been made or used in violation of the exclusive right of the copyright owner.
• As part of a final judgment or decree, the court may order the destruction or other reasonable disposition of all copies or phonorecords found to have been made or used in violation of the copyright owner's exclusive rights.

In addition to injunctions and confiscation, other penalties for breaking copyright laws include monetary fines, loss of property, loss of freedom, or loss of employment. The penalties can vary in magnitude depending on the scale of the violation and whether the violator received money for the materials.

Civil action and criminal penalties

If the infringement is deemed a felony, penalties can include a maximum $250,000 fine and five years in prison for a first offence, and 10 years in prison for a second offence. However, sentencing guidelines typically require commercial profits in the millions for maximum penalties to be imposed.

In the UK, the maximum term of incarceration for copyright infringement is six months and/or a fine of up to £5,000 upon conviction in a magistrates' court. If convicted in the Crown Court, the maximum term of incarceration increases to 10 years and/or an "unlimited" fine. The UK government has considered increasing the maximum fine for online copyright infringement for commercial purposes to £50,000, bringing it in line with the penalty for physical infringement.

Civil penalties for copyright infringement can include orders to pay damages, hand over profits and copies, and restrain copying, displaying, or broadcasting the work. In the US, statutory damages range from $750 to $30,000 for each infringed work, with additional damages of up to $150,000 for willful infringement. The court can also order the infringer to pay the copyright holder's attorney's fees and court costs.

Copyright infringement and plagiarism

Plagiarism and copyright infringement are distinct but related concepts. While both involve the misuse of someone else's work, copyright infringement is illegal, whereas plagiarism is an ethical violation. Plagiarism occurs when someone attempts to pass off someone else's work or ideas as their own without giving credit to the original source. It is considered unethical in academic and professional contexts and can lead to various consequences, such as receiving a failing grade, revocation of a degree, or termination of employment.

Copyright infringement, on the other hand, involves the unauthorized use, reproduction, distribution, display, performance, or adaptation of copyrighted material. It is a legal violation of the rights belonging to the creator or owner of a work. Copyright automatically applies to original works of authorship, such as songs, literary works, movies, or photographs, as soon as they are fixed in a tangible medium of expression. Infringement occurs when someone implicates one or more of these rights without authorization from the copyright owner or an applicable exception in copyright law, such as fair use.

Copyright infringement can lead to significant legal consequences, including injunctions, monetary damages, and criminal penalties in extreme cases. In the UK, for example, the maximum penalty for copyright infringement is a term of incarceration of up to 10 years and/or an unlimited fine. In less severe cases, penalties may include orders to pay damages, restraining copying or broadcasting of the work, handing over profits and copies, and, in serious cases, granting copyright owners private search warrants.

It is important to note that plagiarism can also occur without infringing on copyright, as in the case of copying a small portion of a work or using a work in an educational setting, which may fall under fair use. Additionally, copyright infringement can occur without plagiarism if the infringing party properly attributes the original source but does not have permission to use the copyrighted material.

Copyright law and trademark law

On the other hand, a trademark protects words, phrases, symbols, or designs that identify and distinguish the source of goods or services from those of others. Trademarks can be registered with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) and provide federal protection for a brand in connection with particular goods or services. While it is not mandatory to use trademark symbols, doing so can help to designate a work as trademarked and call attention to the intention to protect the asset. Trademarks are often considered more important for businesses as they act as unique identifiers or brands and may be the foundation on which a business is built.

The penalties for breaking copyright law can vary depending on the jurisdiction and the severity of the infringement. In the UK, for example, the maximum term of incarceration for copyright infringement is 6 months and/or a fine of up to £50,000 in a magistrate's court. Upon conviction in the Crown Court, the maximum term of incarceration increases to 10 years, and the fine can be unlimited. Severe infringement can also lead to criminal penalties, including imprisonment, fines, and confiscation of copyright material and the equipment used to produce it. These penalties are typically intended for cases of industrial-scale copyright infringement for commercial gain, particularly piracy or counterfeiting of videos and computer software.

Frequently asked questions