Zoning Laws: How Cities Restrict Land Use

Zoning laws are a powerful tool that cities use to regulate the use of land and property within their boundaries. These laws are designed to structure cities and municipalities efficiently, and they can have a direct impact on the fabric of our daily lives. Cities can restrict a variety of factors through zoning laws, including the types of businesses that can exist in certain areas, residential areas, and building features. These laws help organise land use, enhance community welfare, and prevent potential land use conflicts.

Types of businesses

Zoning laws are a powerful tool for cities to regulate the types of businesses that can operate in specific areas. These laws are designed to maintain a balance between commercial, residential, and industrial activities, ensuring that they coexist harmoniously while considering the community's needs and values.

One key aspect of zoning laws is the ability to designate specific zones for different types of businesses. For example, a city may establish a retail zone, encouraging retail stores and shops while restricting manufacturing facilities to maintain a community-friendly environment. Similarly, in a commercial zone, restaurants, retail outlets, and offices may be welcomed, whereas residential buildings are prohibited. This segregation of land use helps prevent conflicts and ensures that certain areas remain dedicated to specific purposes.

Zoning laws can also restrict businesses based on their impact on the surrounding environment. For instance, a noisy factory or a large office building may not be permitted in a residential zone to preserve the peace and tranquility of the neighbourhood. Industrial zones, on the other hand, are often located away from residential areas and accommodate businesses with louder operations or those that generate significant traffic, such as warehouses, manufacturing plants, or airports.

Additionally, zoning laws can influence the mix of residential dwellings within a community. They may dictate whether an area is designated for single-family homes or multi-family buildings, including age-restricted communities. These regulations help create neighbourhoods that align with the demographics and preferences of the residents.

It is worth noting that zoning laws can vary across different jurisdictions, and it is essential to research the specific regulations applicable to a particular area. These laws are subject to change over time, and property owners may even request exceptions or apply for rezoning to accommodate their desired land use.

Building height

Zoning laws are a form of urban regulation that government authorities establish to limit the use of property in specific geographic areas of a city. They dictate how a property can or cannot be used within a certain area and are made by branches of the local government, municipal corporation, or a county.

One of the factors that zoning laws can restrict is the height of buildings. Height limits are a regulatory control on development found in the zoning codes of almost every city in the United States. These zoning codes regulate the height of new buildings based on geographic area, development types, and land use. The height limit is determined by measuring the vertical distance between the average ground level and the roof elevation of the proposed building.

Cities may set height limits for new buildings to preserve the prominence of older buildings or government landmarks. For example, in Saint Petersburg, Russia, the height of new buildings was restricted to be shorter than the Winter Palace for 200 years. Similarly, Los Angeles had a height restriction in place until the 1960s, with the exception of City Hall, which was completed in 1928.

Height restrictions can also be implemented due to the proximity of airports, as seen in Denver, Dallas, and Houston. Additionally, certain cities, like Austin, have rules regarding the view of significant landmarks, such as the Capitol View Corridor in Austin, which limits the sightlines of the State Capital dome.

Zoning laws that restrict building height can help ensure a coherent look in a neighborhood and protect the community's interests. They can also prevent the incompatibility of different land uses and enhance real estate value.

Land use

Zoning laws are a powerful tool that can be used to regulate land use and density, control urban growth and development, and ensure that land use is compatible and beneficial to the community. They are intended to keep incompatible land uses separate, such as industrial facilities next to residential areas, and to prevent issues like congestion and declining land values.

The regulation of land use is a common practice in most cities worldwide and is typically controlled by local governments, municipal corporations, or counties. These regulations can include urban growth boundary control, which separates urban development areas from urbanization-control areas, and floor area ratio regulation, which restricts building sizes. Zoning laws can also specify the type of structures that can be built within each zone, such as single-family homes or apartment buildings.

In addition to regulating the type of structures, zoning laws can also govern the frontage of lots, minimum lot size, front, rear, and side yards, off-street parking, the number of buildings on a lot, and the number of dwelling units in a certain area. They can also protect and enhance property values by preserving community character and ensuring new developments are in keeping with the area's architectural heritage.

While zoning laws can have benefits, they have also been criticised for creating and widening disparities in the quality of life among socioeconomic groups. For example, zoning laws that restrict heavy industrial and commercial development to tracts of land adjacent to lower-income neighbourhoods can lead to more affluent parts of town avoiding associated noise and pollution. Additionally, zoning laws that prioritize single-family housing have been linked to higher housing prices, reduced construction activity, and decreased housing supply, contributing to homelessness and inequality.

In recent years, some jurisdictions have re-evaluated their zoning laws to address these concerns. For example, the state of Oregon eliminated single-family zoning in large cities, allowing for the development of duplexes, triplexes, and "cottage clusters" in areas previously reserved for single-family homes. Other changes, such as legalizing accessory dwelling units, eliminating parking requirements, and amending height restrictions, have also been effective in increasing the housing stock and creating more diverse and efficient land use.

Residential areas

Zoning laws are regulations that divide land into designated areas or "zones", with each zone corresponding to a geographic area on a zoning map. They are created by local governments, municipal corporations, or counties. These laws determine which types of properties can coexist in different areas of a city, and they can be used to restrict certain types of development or land use.

In residential areas, zoning laws can be used to maintain the character of a community and ensure that incompatible land uses do not exist side by side. For example, zoning laws might prevent industrial facilities from being located next to residential neighbourhoods, or restrict the height of buildings to protect access to natural light for residents.

In the United States, the first zoning regulations were adopted in 1916 by New York City, which established height restrictions for buildings and prevented factories and warehouses from encroaching on retail districts. Since then, zoning laws have often been used to restrict the types of homes that can exist within a residential zone, such as designating areas for single-family homes or apartment buildings.

In recent years, there has been a pushback against restrictive zoning practices, particularly those that contribute to socioeconomic divisions, housing affordability issues, and racial segregation. Critics argue that zoning laws that prioritize single-family housing constrain the supply of housing, inflate prices, and contribute to homelessness and inequality. In response, some cities have started to eliminate single-family zoning, allowing for the development of duplexes, triplexes, and other types of multi-family housing.

In addition to restricting the types of homes that can be built, zoning laws in residential areas can also regulate the number of structures allowed on a property, the number and kind of animals allowed, and other details of construction. These laws can also influence property values, with more restrictive zoning practices often leading to higher property prices.

Building features

Zoning laws can restrict the number of animals allowed on a property. They can also dictate the maximum height of buildings in a given area, regardless of the type of construction allowed. For example, Bassett's zoning map established height restrictions for New York City, limiting building height to no higher than the width of adjoining streets. In some cases, high-rise residences or offices could be banned in certain areas. Zoning laws can also specify the number of structures allowed on a property, such as the number of dwellings per lot. In Los Altos Hills, California, the zoning laws restrict the town to one primary dwelling per lot, with a minimum lot size of one acre.

Zoning laws can also regulate the types of structures that can be built within each zone. For example, a zone may be designated for single-family homes or multiple-family homes. In some cases, localities may prohibit duplexes, small homes, and multi-family buildings through zoning laws. These restrictions can contribute to socioeconomic divisions and racial segregation, as certain types of housing are more likely to be occupied by racial minorities, recent immigrants, and poor households.

In addition to height restrictions, zoning laws can also impose other building design requirements. For example, in France, the Code of Urbanism guides regional and local planning and includes procedures for obtaining building permits. Zoning districts are classified into twelve use zones, each with its own set of restrictions on the allowable floor area ratio and building height. These controls are intended to allow adequate light and ventilation between buildings and on roads.

Zoning laws can also require that certain proposed developments undergo additional reviews and approvals before construction can begin. This process, known as "conditional use" or "special use", can include public meetings where residents and advocates can voice their concerns about the project. The lengthy and uncertain outcome of this process can make development more expensive and risky, ultimately driving up rents and property prices.

Frequently asked questions