Hoa Board Lawbreakers: What Are The Consequences?

Homeowners Associations (HOAs) in Florida are subject to specific state statutes that outline their governance, powers, and obligations. HOAs have a broad legal authority to create and enforce rules within their communities, and they can fine members for non-compliance. However, if an HOA board breaks the law, there are consequences. For example, after the leaders of an HOA in Miami were accused of theft and fraud, Florida lawmakers approved a Homeowners' Association Bill of Rights, which prevents HOAs from fining or suspending members without prior notice. This bill also requires greater transparency in HOA operations and meetings. If an HOA violates its members' rights or fails to follow its own rules, homeowners can take several steps, including raising concerns with the board, proposing amendments to bylaws, and, as a last resort, taking legal action.

HOA members can take legal action against the HOA board

Before taking legal action, HOA members should first raise their concerns with the HOA board, either by attending a board meeting, participating in an open forum, or reaching out through other communication channels. If this does not resolve the issue, members can propose an amendment to the bylaws or rules, or call for the removal of a board member through a vote.

If the dispute remains unresolved, HOA members can take legal action as a last resort. However, it is important to note that legal disputes with HOAs can be complex and time-consuming, and members should consider seeking legal advice from an experienced attorney specialising in HOA law.

HOA boards must follow the same due process as homeowners

HOA boards are responsible for making decisions and enforcing rules within their communities. While they have a certain level of authority, they are not exempt from the rules and regulations of the HOA. This means that HOA boards must follow the same due process as homeowners when it comes to violations and disciplinary actions.

In the state of Florida, HOA boards are subject to specific statutes that outline their governance, powers, and obligations. The Florida Homeowners' Association Act, found in Chapter 720 of the Florida Statutes, prescribes the way in which HOAs can operate, including the enforcement of rules and the handling of disputes.

If an HOA board member breaks the rules, they should face the same consequences as any other homeowner. This means following the established process for addressing violations, which typically starts with a violation notice or letter informing the offender of their infraction. The board member should then be given the opportunity to correct the violation within a reasonable amount of time, known as the "cure period." If the issue is not resolved, the matter may proceed to a disciplinary hearing, where the board member can present their side of the story and provide any relevant evidence.

It is important to note that HOA boards are expected to set a good example for their constituents. By following the same due process as homeowners, they maintain credibility and trust within the community. Failure to do so can lead to claims of selective enforcement and liability issues for the HOA board.

Homeowners who believe that an HOA board member has broken the rules can take several steps to address the issue. They can raise their concerns directly to the HOA board, propose amendments to outdated bylaws, or take legal action as a last resort. It is advisable for homeowners to work together and present a united front when dealing with an HOA board that is not following the established rules and regulations.

HOA boards can be removed for misconduct

• Take Away Their Official Duties: The HOA board can strip a board member of their officer role with a majority vote. This reduces their negative impact without removing them entirely.
• Request a Resignation: The board president or other members can meet with the problem board member, discuss the situation, and request a formal resignation. This approach is less aggressive and helps the member avoid embarrassment.
• Leave of Absence: If the board member is dealing with personal issues or health problems, the HOA can allow them to take a leave of absence. They remain on the board but are not expected to attend meetings.
• Term Limit Expiry: If the board member's behavior is not egregious and their term is almost up, the community may opt to wait for their term to expire.
• Impeachment: If all other methods fail, the HOA can impeach the board member. This is a last resort and typically involves a long process, including a community vote and an HOA meeting with a quorum.

It's important to note that the specific procedures and requirements for removing an HOA board member may vary depending on state laws and the association's governing documents. Homeowners should first try to address their concerns at board meetings and through various communication channels before resorting to removal.

HOA boards must operate within the bounds of Florida law

HOA boards in Florida are subject to specific state statutes that outline their governance, powers, and obligations. This means that they must operate within the bounds of Florida law. The Florida Homeowners' Association Act, found in Chapter 720 of the Florida Statutes, prescribes the way in which these associations can operate, from the collection of assessments to enforcing rules within the community.

The Florida HOA laws and regulations allow associations to pursue legal actions and enforcement measures that are critical in maintaining compliance and ensuring fiscal stability. For instance, associations have the authority to collect unpaid assessments through liens against the property. However, they must adhere to fair debt collection practices as outlined in the Florida Consumer Collection Practices Act.

In addition, HOA boards in Florida are required to comply with the Florida Not For Profit Corporation Act, which mandates transparent operation and management. This means that members must be duly informed of decisions affecting the association. HOA members in Florida have certain rights, including access to records, participation in meetings, and the ability to vote on important matters.

The HOA laws in Florida also place restrictions on HOA fines. For instance, the fine for a violation cannot exceed $100, and the total fine for continuing violations cannot exceed $1,000 unless the HOA's governing documents specifically allow for a higher amount.

Florida's new Homeowners Association laws also provide protections for HOA members. For example, under the "Homeowners' Association Bill of Rights," HOA members cannot be fined or suspended for violating the association's bylaws or rules unless a two-week notice is delivered to the member's email or mailing address in the HOA's official records.

It is important for HOA boards and members to be aware of their rights and obligations under Florida law. Failure to comply with the law can result in legal challenges and negative consequences for the association and its members.

HOA boards must adhere to federal non-discrimination laws

HOA boards in Florida have a responsibility to uphold federal non-discrimination laws. The Fair Housing Act (FHA) prohibits discrimination in housing and housing-related services based on race, colour, religion, sex, national origin, disability, and familial status. This applies to HOAs as they set terms and conditions for housing and provide services and facilities in connection with housing.

HOA board members must avoid making discriminatory decisions and ensure that community rules do not contain discriminatory terms. For example, an HOA rule that forbids homeowners from altering a home design with a front porch and steps could inadvertently prohibit the construction of a wheelchair ramp, violating the disability protections in the FHA. Similarly, rules prohibiting the rental or sale of a home to families with children would violate protections for families with children under the age of 18 and pregnant women.

HOA boards must also be careful not to discriminate based on race, colour, religion, sex, national origin, or disability when making housing decisions, such as whether to rent or sell a house. This includes subtle forms of discrimination, such as deciding that someone "just doesn't fit in."

To avoid disability claims, HOA boards should adopt a reasonable accommodation/modification policy and apply it consistently to all owners. A reasonable accommodation is a change in rules, policies, practices, or services that allows a disabled person equal opportunity to use and enjoy a house or common area. A reasonable modification is a structural change that allows a disabled person full enjoyment of a house or common facility, such as allowing the construction of a wheelchair ramp, even if it violates CC&R rules.

In addition to federal non-discrimination laws, HOA boards in Florida must also comply with state laws and their association's governing documents when making decisions and enforcing rules. Failure to adhere to these laws and guidelines can result in legal challenges and negative consequences for the HOA and the community it serves.

Frequently asked questions