Lie Detector Law: Breaking It Leads To Legal Consequences

Lie detector tests, also known as polygraph tests, are used to measure a person's physiological responses, such as blood pressure, perspiration, and heart rate, to determine if they are being truthful. While these tests are sometimes used in criminal investigations, they are not always admissible in court due to their questionable reliability. In the United States, less than half of the states allow polygraph test results to be used as evidence in criminal trials. Even in states where they are admissible, the defence can present evidence and testimony to question the test's reliability.

While the results of a lie detector test cannot be admitted in court, any statements made before or after the test may be used as evidence. Therefore, it is essential to consult a criminal defence attorney before agreeing to take a polygraph test. Additionally, it is important to note that refusing to take a lie detector test cannot be used against you in court.

In some cases, individuals may face penalties for lying to the police or providing false information. These penalties can include fines, jail time, or probation, and may increase for repeat offenders. Making a false report under oath can result in a charge of perjury, which can be a federal crime in extreme cases.

Lie detector results are inadmissible in court

Lie detector tests, or polygraph tests, are not admissible in court in most U.S. states. This is due to legitimate concerns about their unreliability and their subjective nature. The results of a lie detector test can vary depending on the person administering the test, the machine used, and the person taking the test. The nature or tone of the person giving the test can also significantly affect the results, as can the stress induced by the examination itself.

In the U.S., the admissibility of lie detector test results falls into two main categories. The first category consists of states that find the results of the test entirely inadmissible. The second category includes states that allow the admission of test results in court, but only if submitted with stipulations from both the defence and the prosecution.

Even in states that allow polygraph tests, the defence can use testimony and evidence to question the test's results. In addition, the test administrator must meet certain qualifications for the results to be admissible. They must hold a state license, have at least five years of experience, and demonstrate a clear understanding of the polygraph examination process.

While lie detector test results are generally not admissible in criminal cases, they can be used in some investigations and for decision-making in certain federal employment positions. They are also used in military hearings outside of court-martial hearings for non-serious offences.

It is important to note that while the results of a lie detector test may not be admissible in court, any statements made by the test subject before or after the examination are admissible and can be used to build a case. Therefore, it is crucial to consult a criminal defence attorney before agreeing to take a lie detector test.

Police cannot force you to take a lie detector test

If you are the subject of a criminal investigation, you may feel panicked and tempted to agree to a lie detector test, also known as a polygraph test, to prove your innocence. However, it is important to remember that the police cannot force you to take one, whether you are a suspect or have been arrested.

A polygraph test measures physiological responses such as blood pressure, perspiration, and heart rate while you are being asked a series of questions. The premise is that deceptive answers produce different physiological responses than truthful ones. However, the results of these tests are unreliable, and many innocent people have failed them. Even if you pass, it does not guarantee that you will not be charged with a crime.

In most states, including California and Virginia, the results of polygraph tests are not admissible in court due to their unreliability. This means that even if you fail the test, the results cannot be used as evidence against you in court to prove your guilt or innocence. Therefore, taking the test may not be in your best interest, as it may not significantly impact the outcome of your case.

Additionally, it is crucial to understand that the police request a polygraph test to gather evidence against you, not necessarily to get to the truth. The officers administering the test are trained to ask questions before and after the exam to elicit incriminating statements from you. These statements are admissible in court and can be used to build a case against you. Therefore, it is essential to carefully consider the potential implications of taking a polygraph test and consult with an experienced criminal defense attorney before making any decisions.

While you have the right to refuse a polygraph test without legal consequences, you may face penalties for lying to the police or providing false information. These penalties can include fines, jail time, or probation, depending on the circumstances and your previous record. However, remaining silent and explicitly invoking your Fifth Amendment right to remain silent cannot result in additional legal trouble and is often the best way to protect yourself during police interactions.

You can refuse to take a lie detector test

Lie detector tests, also known as polygraph tests, are used by criminal investigators and employers to gather evidence. They measure a person's physiological reactions, such as breathing rate, pulse, blood pressure, and perspiration, when asked a series of questions to determine if they are giving a deceptive or false response.

If you are an employee or job applicant, the Employee Polygraph Protection Act (EPPA) prohibits most private employers from using lie detector tests for pre-employment screening or during employment. Employers cannot require or request that you take a lie detector test and cannot take adverse action or discriminate against you for refusing.

It is crucial to understand the risks and consult with an experienced criminal defense attorney before deciding whether to take a lie detector test. The results of these tests are often inaccurate, and even if you pass, it does not guarantee that you will not be charged with a crime. Additionally, while the test results may not be admissible in court, any statements made before or after the test can be used as evidence.

Lie detector tests are not 100% reliable

Lie detector tests, also known as polygraph tests, are not 100% reliable. They are pseudoscientific procedures that measure and record physiological indicators such as blood pressure, pulse, respiration, and skin conductivity while a person is asked and answers a series of questions. The underlying principle is that deceptive answers will produce physiological responses that differ from those associated with non-deceptive answers. However, there are no specific physiological reactions linked to lying, making it challenging to differentiate between liars and truth-tellers.

The accuracy of polygraph tests is highly questionable, with scientific and government bodies suggesting they are highly inaccurate and easily defeated by countermeasures. The National Academy of Sciences, in a 2003 review, concluded that there was "little basis for the expectation that a polygraph test could have extremely high accuracy." This is supported by the American Psychological Association's statement that "most psychologists agree that there is little evidence that polygraph tests can accurately detect lies."

Polygraph tests can produce false positives, where innocent individuals exhibit stress or anxiety during the test and are marked as deceptive. Conversely, skilled liars or individuals with physiological control can pass the test, resulting in false negatives. Interpreting the results is more of an art than a science, and human emotions like anxiety can significantly impact the outcomes.

While polygraph tests are used in criminal investigations, pre-employment screening, and private matters, their results should be treated with caution. They are not foolproof and have limitations, so they should not be solely relied upon to determine truth or deception. In some countries, like India, polygraph results cannot be used as the sole evidence in court but can support other evidence. In other jurisdictions, such as Canada and certain US states, polygraph results are inadmissible in court.

You can do a private polygraph test to prove your innocence

If you've been accused of a crime and want to prove your innocence, you may be considering taking a polygraph test. While it may be tempting to agree to a police polygraph test, it's important to consult with an experienced criminal defense attorney first. Police polygraph tests are often used as an interrogation technique rather than a truthful examination, and innocent people regularly fail them.

• Seek legal advice: It's crucial to consult with an experienced criminal defense attorney before agreeing to any type of polygraph test. An attorney can advise you on the specific allegations against you, your rights, and whether taking a polygraph test is in your best interest.
• Understand the limitations: It's important to know that polygraph tests are not admissible in court in many states. While the results cannot be used against you, any statements you make before, during, or after the test can be used as evidence.
• Practice with a private test: Consider taking a private polygraph test before submitting to a police-organized examination. A private test can help you understand the process, see if you're likely to pass, and identify any issues that may affect your results. Private tests are easy to set up and inexpensive.
• Choose the right examiner: If you decide to take a private polygraph test, it's important to choose a credible and experienced examiner. The examiner should be recognized as an expert in the profession of polygraph testing to ensure the results are reliable and can be used to your advantage.
• Get a written agreement: If you decide to take a police polygraph test, make sure you have a written agreement with the prosecuting attorney's office stating that they will not issue charges if you pass. Without this agreement, there is no benefit to taking the test, as charges can still be filed even if you pass.

Remember, polygraph tests are not always accurate, and innocent people can fail them. Consult with an attorney to evaluate your specific situation and make an informed decision about whether to take a polygraph test.

Frequently asked questions