Breaking Laws In China: What Are The Consequences?

If you break the law in China, you will be subject to the country's judicial system. The Chinese legal system is very different from that of other countries, and it is important to be aware of these differences. After an official arrest, there is a period of up to 13.5 months before formal charges are laid and the case is transferred to the court. During this time, detainees can only meet with their lawyers and consular officials and are usually unable to contact family or friends. It is also important to note that China does not recognize dual citizenship, and local authorities may refuse to grant access to consular services if they consider you a Chinese citizen. If found guilty, you may be sentenced to a jail term, fined, or both, and for serious crimes, you could face life imprisonment or even the death penalty.

Detention and imprisonment

If you are detained in China, you will usually be taken to a detention facility and your passport will be confiscated by the police. You will not be able to make phone calls or meet with family members until the final judgment is made. Under Chinese law, a suspect has the right to hire a practising lawyer from the date they are first interrogated by the investigating authority or are subject to compulsory measures. However, in certain cases, permission must be granted by the investigating authority, and access to a lawyer may be denied. It is important to note that Chinese law does not allow for "the right to remain silent".

The police can detain suspects for up to 37 days before the prosecutor approves the arrest. After an official arrest, there is a period of up to 13.5 months for investigation and prosecution review before formal charges are laid and the case is transferred to the court. During this time, detainees can only meet with their lawyers and, in the case of foreign nationals, consular officials. They are typically not allowed to speak to family members or friends.

If you are a foreign national, you should communicate your request to Chinese authorities if you wish to have your consular officials notified. Under Article 36 of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations (VCCR), Chinese authorities have an obligation to advise you of your right of access to a consular representative. While they are not obliged to inform the consular post of your detention or arrest unless you ask them to, they must send any communication you address to the consular post. For example, if you write a letter to the embassy of your country in China, that letter must be delivered.

After a victim reports a criminal case to the Public Security Bureau (PSB), it usually takes no more than three days for the initial investigation before filing the case. This period can be extended up to seven days for evidence verification and up to 30 days for significant and complicated cases. If the PSB decides not to file a case, they will issue a notification and deliver it to the victim within three days. The victim then has the right to report the case to the prosecutor, and if the prosecutor agrees with the PSB, the victim may apply for reconsideration. In certain criminal cases, the victim has the right to directly bring a lawsuit to a court.

All detainees, including foreign nationals, may apply for release on bail with the assistance of a lawyer. Bail may be granted under certain circumstances, such as serious illness, pregnancy, or if the detainee is not considered a threat to society. During the bail period, individuals must comply with restrictions, including appearing before the court when summoned, not leaving the city or county, and reporting any changes in address or contact details to the police within 24 hours. Failure to comply with these restrictions may result in forfeiting cash deposits or other punishments.

China's legal system allows individuals to request a lawyer to fight their case. If found guilty, individuals may be sentenced to a jail term, fined, or both. For serious crimes, life imprisonment or even the death penalty may be imposed. Each province has its own penalties, but China's punishments are typically on the less severe side. Minor offenses, such as breaking a traffic law or jaywalking, may result in offenders being set free.

Criminal charges and fines

If you break the law in China, you will be subject to the country's judicial system. Chinese criminal law applies to both citizens and foreigners who commit crimes within the country. The police can detain suspects for up to 37 days before the prosecutor approves the arrest. After an official arrest, there is a period of up to 13.5 months before formal charges are laid and the case is transferred to the court. During this time, detainees can only meet with their lawyers and, in the case of foreign nationals, consular officials. They are typically unable to contact family members or friends.

If you are detained, you will usually be taken to a detention facility and your passport will be confiscated. You will not be able to make phone calls or meet with family until the final judgment is made. Under Chinese law, suspects have the right to hire a practising lawyer from the date of their first interrogation or when subjected to compulsory measures. However, there are exceptions where permission must be granted by the investigating authority, and access to a lawyer may be denied.

China's legal system allows individuals to request a lawyer to fight their case. If found guilty, individuals can be sentenced to a jail term, fined, or both. The severity of the punishment depends on the seriousness of the offence, and each province has its own penalties. For minor offences, some offenders may be set free. However, for serious crimes, individuals can face life imprisonment or even the death penalty.

It is important to note that China's laws vary across different locations, regions, and enterprises. Therefore, it is crucial to understand the specific laws and cultural norms of the area you are visiting or residing in to avoid any legal troubles.

Death penalty

China is the world leader in the number of legal executions. There are 46 crimes punishable by death in China, which are defined in the country's criminal law. The death penalty in China is usually administered to offenders of serious and violent crimes, particularly crimes that severely endanger national or public security, social order, or infringe on individuals' rights. This includes crimes such as aggravated murder, rape, kidnapping, human trafficking, drug smuggling or trafficking, and the production or sale of counterfeit medicine of an extremely serious nature.

China also retains certain capital offenses for non-violent crimes, such as drug smuggling or trafficking, and the production or sale of hazardous food products. Under Chinese law, the death penalty shall not apply to persons who were under 18 years old when they committed the crime, women who are pregnant during the trial, or (with exceptions) persons over 75 years old at the time of trial. The death penalty, as well as the death sentence with a two-year suspension, must be decided or approved by the Supreme People's Court.

The legal tradition on the death penalty in China has changed markedly since the establishment of the People's Republic of China, especially after the economic reforms of the 1980s. These changes were reflected in both substantive and procedural laws. The first Criminal Law since the establishment of the People's Republic of China was passed in 1979, which included 28 capital offenses. Among these capital offenses, 15 were counterrevolutionary offenses, such as overthrowing the government.

The actual application of the death penalty in China is reflective of the political and social climate of the time. Official reports of death penalty cases are also influenced by these factors. It is difficult to obtain valid and reliable data to conduct an accurate assessment of the practice of the death penalty in China. However, studies on the death penalty in China are relatively rare, and increasing attention has been given to this topic since the economic reforms and the "open door" policy instigated in the early 1980s.

Human rights violations

The Chinese government has been known to stifle criticism of its policies and actions through pervasive online censorship and the detention of government critics, human rights defenders, pro-democracy activists, and religious leaders. Ethnic minorities, such as Uyghurs, Tibetans, and Christians, face systematic repression, discrimination, and restrictions on their freedom of religion and movement. For example, the Uyghur population in Xinjiang is subject to strict controls on the practice of Islam, including restrictions on attending mosques, wearing religious attire, and using traditionally Islamic names.

The Chinese legal system also falls short of international standards for human rights. The judiciary is not independent of the ruling Chinese Communist Party (CCP), and judges face political pressure. The CCP's authority is enshrined in the constitution as superseding that of the law, creating a system often described as "rule by law" rather than the rule of law. This lack of independence and rule of law results in a lack of protection for civil rights and due process.

In addition, China has been criticized for its use of the death penalty, arbitrary detention, and torture. Amnesty International has expressed concern over prisoner abuse, particularly in detention centers administered by public security bureaus. The country has also been accused of using forced labor and committing genocide against Uyghur Muslims in Xinjiang, with around a million people reportedly detained in internment camps without trial or access to legal representation.

Furthermore, China has been known to restrict the freedom of assembly and association, with the All-China Federation of Trade Unions holding a monopoly on union activity. The CCP effectively monopolizes organized political activity, leaving no room for genuine electoral competition at any level of government.

Overall, the human rights situation in China remains poor, with the government regularly sanctioning or organizing abuses despite claims of improvement.

Lack of transparency

China's legal system is notoriously opaque, and the lack of transparency can make it difficult for foreigners to understand their rights and the consequences of breaking the law.

The Chinese Communist Party and the government have demonstrated a continued lack of transparency, which has been highlighted by the sudden disappearances and deaths of several high-ranking officials. This lack of transparency extends to the judicial system, where detainees are often denied access to legal counsel and family members. Foreign nationals may face additional challenges, as they are only allowed to meet with consular officials and their lawyers during detention.

The investigation and prosecution process can be lengthy, with a period of up to 13.5 months allowed for investigation and prosecution review before formal charges must be laid. During this time, detainees may be held without regular access to legal representation or family, which can make it difficult for them to understand their rights and mount a defence.

China's internet laws also contribute to the lack of transparency. Many websites are blocked in the country, and while foreign citizens have not been fined for using VPNs, there have been cases of Chinese citizens being fined for doing so. This makes it difficult for people to access information freely and securely, further contributing to the overall lack of transparency in the country.

The Chinese legal system is complex and can be challenging to navigate, especially for foreigners. It is important for anyone living in or visiting China to be aware of the laws and cultural norms to avoid accidentally breaking any rules. Understanding the legal system and one's rights is crucial to navigating the country's judicial process.

Frequently asked questions