Canon Law Violation: Understanding The Consequences And Ramifications

Canon law is the legal system that governs the Catholic Church. Canon law contains some direct expressions of doctrine on matters of faith and morals, and the rest of it can be changed, dispensed, and even be broken by the faithful without sin or fault. Canon law is a heavily book-based legal system and relatively little of it is available online. Canon lawyers do not advertise or maintain conspicuous offices. Canon law has elements of both Divine Law and Human Law. Divine Law is received from God through Divine Revelation, and Human Law is made by the Church to give order and structure to the Church and how it functions.

Ignorance of canon law is not a permissible legal defence

Canon law is a type of ecclesiastical law that governs the Catholic Church and its members. It contains elements of both divine law, which is received from God through divine revelation, and human law, which is made by the Church to give order and structure to its functioning. While canon law is subject to change and can be dispensed, ignorance of canon law is not a permissible legal defence if it is broken.

The legal principle of "ignorantia juris non excusat" or "ignorance of the law is no excuse" holds that individuals cannot escape liability for violating a law simply because they were unaware of its content. This principle is based on the assumption that laws are publicly known and accessible, and it is necessary to ensure the legal system remains fair and functional. If ignorance were an acceptable defence, it could create chaos and undermine the system's stability and predictability.

However, there may be certain exceptions where ignorance of the law can be considered a valid defence. For example, in the case of newly enacted laws, individuals may not be immediately aware of their existence, and ignorance of the law can be a defence if there was no reasonable way for the accused to have known about the law. Additionally, in some jurisdictions, ignorance of specific local laws that differ from state or national laws, such as unique regional traffic ordinances, may also be considered a valid defence.

Furthermore, a distinction can be made between ignorance of the law and a bona fide belief arising from ignorance of the law. While mere ignorance of the law is not a valid defence, ignorance that leads to a bona fide belief in the existence of a right or claim may potentially be a valid defence in certain cases. This defence is based on the doctrine of equity and depends on the specific facts and circumstances of each case.

In summary, while ignorance of canon law is generally not a permissible legal defence, there may be limited exceptions depending on the nature and context of the offence, the geographic applicability of the law, and whether it gives rise to a bona fide belief in a right or claim.

Canon law is a mix of administrative and judicial processes

Canon law is a set of ordinances and regulations made by ecclesiastical authorities for the governance of a Christian organisation or church and its members. Canon law includes the internal ecclesiastical law, or operational policy, governing the Catholic Church, the Eastern Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox churches, and the individual national churches within the Anglican Communion. Canon law is a mix of administrative and judicial processes.

The Catholic Church has the oldest continuously functioning internal legal system in Western Europe. The canon law of the Catholic Church is a fully developed legal system, with all the necessary elements: courts, lawyers, judges, a fully articulated legal code, principles of legal interpretation, and coercive penalties. Canon law operates as a heavily book-based legal system, and relatively little of it is available online.

The Apostolic Signatura, located in the Vatican City State, is the Church's highest administrative court. Administrative law is generally more influential in ecclesiastical matters than judicial law, so the Signatura is effectively the Catholic Church's supreme court, albeit under the Roman Pontiff.

Canon law tribunals exist to adjudicate canonical issues. Every diocese and archdiocese is meant to have a tribunal authorised to adjudicate canonical issues, and most disputed cases heard in tribunals deal with marriage and divorce. Generally, tribunal proceedings are not open to the public due to the personal nature of the matters being discussed.

The common law system is 'adversarial-based', whereas canon law is 'inquiry-based'. The common law system believes that arguments between opposing, openly biased sides is the best way to find the truth of a matter. In contrast, canon law thinks that inquiry by qualified, dispassionate experts into a matter is the best way to find the truth.

Canon law contains some direct expressions of doctrine on matters of faith and morals. If those particular canons did not exist, the doctrines would still be in force, and there is no dispensation from such a canon. However, the rest of canon law can be changed, dispensed, and even be broken by the faithful without sin or fault.

Canon law is an 'inquiry-based' system, unlike common law, which is 'adversarial-based'

Canon law is a set of ordinances and regulations made by ecclesiastical authorities (church leadership) to govern a Christian organization or church and its members. Canon law is an inquiry-based system, unlike common law, which is adversarial-based. The adversarial system assumes that the best way to get to the truth of a matter is through a competitive process to determine the facts and application of the law accurately. The adversarial system is used in common law countries, such as England and the U.S., and features juries and single judges.

On the other hand, the inquiry-based or inquisitorial system is associated with civil law legal systems and has existed for many centuries. It is characterized by extensive pre-trial investigation and interrogations with the objective to avoid bringing an innocent person to trial. The inquisitorial process grants more power to the judge who oversees the process and is used in Roman ecclesiastical courts, which tend to follow the Roman Law style of continental Europe with some variation. The process involves collegiate panels of judges and an investigative form of proceeding, derived from the Latin "inquirere", meaning "to enquire".

Canon law contains elements of both Divine Law and Human Law. Divine Law refers to laws received from God through Divine Revelation, which cannot be broken. Human Law, on the other hand, refers to laws made by the Church to give order and structure to its functioning. While the Pope cannot break Divine Law, he has the power to dispense himself from Human Law, which is made by the Church and can be changed or dispensed.

The distinction between eternal moral law and the law of discipline is also important in understanding when it is moral to break Canon Law. The eternal moral law is unchanging and based on the Justice inherent in the Nature of God. Any violation of this law is considered a sin. However, the law of discipline, which includes rules, liturgical norms, and the rules established by a diocese or parish, is changeable, dispensable, and allows for exceptions based on intentions and circumstances.

In conclusion, Canon law is an inquiry-based system that differs from the adversarial-based common law in its approach to truth-seeking and judicial processes. It contains a mix of Divine and Human Law, with the Pope having the power to dispense himself from Human Law in certain circumstances. Additionally, the distinction between eternal moral law and the law of discipline further complicates the understanding of when breaking Canon Law is considered moral or immoral.

Canon law is largely a hard-copy legal discipline

Canon law is the legal system of the Catholic Church, governing the behaviour of its members and the church's external organisation. It is a fully developed legal system, with courts, lawyers, judges, a legal code, principles of legal interpretation, and coercive penalties. However, it lacks civilly-binding force in most secular jurisdictions.

Canon law is the oldest continuously functioning legal system in the West. The Catholic Church has the oldest continuously functioning internal legal system in Western Europe. The history of Latin canon law can be divided into four periods: jus antiquum, jus novum, jus novissimum, and the Code of Canon Law. The canon law of the Eastern Catholic Churches underwent a separate process of codification, resulting in the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, which was promulgated in 1990 by Pope John Paul II.

Canon law includes the internal ecclesiastical law, or operational policy, governing the Catholic Church (both the Latin Church and the Eastern Catholic Churches), the Eastern Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox churches, and the individual national churches within the Anglican Communion. The way that such church law is legislated, interpreted, and at times adjudicated varies widely among these four bodies of churches.

Canon law has influenced the development of modern civil law and common law. For example, in the English legal system, criminals could historically apply for the benefit of clergy, allowing them to be tried by more lenient ecclesiastical courts instead of secular courts. This practice was steadily reduced by Henry VII, Henry VIII, and Elizabeth I, and was systematically removed from English legal systems over the next 200 years.

Canon law is the legal system of the Catholic Church

Canon law contains elements of both Divine Law (received from God through Divine Revelation) and Human Law (made by the Church to give order and structure to its organisation and functions). Canon law is therefore not immutable, and can be changed, dispensed, or even broken without sin in certain circumstances. For example, the Pope is able to break some aspects of canon law, but not others. He could not, for instance, ordain a woman to the priesthood, as this is a precept of Divine Law. However, he could choose to ignore the requirement for a parish to have a finance council, as this is a human precept.

The distinction between Divine and Human Law is important when considering the consequences of breaking canon law. While the eternal moral law is unchanging, the law of discipline (rules, rulings, liturgical norms, etc.) is more flexible. In some cases, it is acceptable to break canon law without dispensation, as shown by the example of David and his soldiers in the Bible, who ate the bread of the Presence reserved for priests.

In general, ignorance of the law is not considered a valid excuse for breaking it, and individuals can be charged and tried if the relevant authorities decide to pursue charges. However, this is at the discretion of the court and officers, who may use their judgement in individual cases.

Frequently asked questions