Punishments For Breaking Laws In The Middle East

Breaking the law in the Middle East can have a range of consequences, from fines to imprisonment, and even the death penalty. The legal system in the Middle East varies across countries and is largely based on religious laws, particularly Sharia law. In some countries, the legal system is based on a mix of religious and secular laws, while in others, religious laws take precedence.

The Middle East has a history of religious influence on its legal systems, dating back to the Ottoman Empire and the introduction of Sharia courts. Today, this influence continues to shape the region's legal landscape, often resulting in a dual legal system with both religious and secular courts.

The consequences for breaking the law can vary depending on the country and the nature of the offence. For example, in Saudi Arabia, freedom of religion is not recognised or protected by law, and apostasy is punishable by death. In contrast, other countries in the region may impose fines, imprisonment, or other penalties for similar offences.

International law also plays a role in the Middle East, with countries signing and ratifying treaties such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. However, the enforcement of these laws can be challenging due to the region's diverse legal systems and the resistance to change inherent in religion-based legal systems.

Breaking the law in the Middle East can result in the death penalty

Breaking the law in the Middle East can have severe consequences, including the death penalty. While capital punishment has been abolished in some countries, it remains legal in most Middle Eastern nations and is often motivated by religious beliefs.

In Saudi Arabia, for example, capital punishment is used for both lethal and non-lethal crimes, and even juvenile offenders are not exempt. Executions are usually carried out by beheading with a sword but may also be performed by shooting or firing squad. The kingdom has executed hundreds of people in recent years, and the number of executions continues to rise.

The death penalty in Saudi Arabia can be imposed for various crimes, including aggravated burglary, adultery, sorcery or witchcraft, and drug trafficking. In the case of murder, the family of the victim can choose between demanding the death penalty or granting clemency in return for "blood money."

Other countries in the Middle East that currently enforce the death penalty include the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, the Palestinian Authority, the United Arab Emirates, and Yemen. While Turkey had abolished capital punishment for all crimes by 2004, recent political developments have led to proposals to restore the death penalty for terrorism-related offenses.

The retention of the death penalty in the Middle East has sparked international criticism, particularly regarding the use of public executions and the imposition of the death sentence for non-lethal crimes or those arrested as minors. Human rights organizations have also raised concerns about the use of torture to obtain confessions and the lack of fair trial procedures in some cases.

In the Middle East, the legal system is largely based on Sharia law

Sharia law is derived from two main sources: the Quran, which is considered the direct word of God, and Hadith, which are the sayings and practices attributed to the Prophet Muhammad. Additionally, some Shiite Muslims include the words and deeds of the prophet's family in their interpretation of Sharia law. The process of interpreting Sharia law is known as fiqh and has been developed over centuries by Muslim scholars.

In the Middle East, countries such as Saudi Arabia, Iran, and some Gulf states follow a classical Sharia system, where Sharia law is formally equated with national law. In these countries, traditional religious scholars (ulama) play a decisive role in interpreting Sharia law, and it influences a wide range of legal and social matters. For example, in Saudi Arabia, Sharia law is the basis for legislation and is applied in criminal law, family law, and personal status law.

Other countries in the Middle East have a mixed legal system, where Sharia law influences certain areas of national law while codified laws based on European or Indian codes are also in place. For instance, Egypt's legal system references Sharia law as a source of legislation, but it also has a secular constitution that guarantees freedom of thought, conscience, and religious belief and practice. Similarly, countries like Malaysia and Nigeria have a dual legal system, where Muslims can choose to bring certain matters, such as marriage, divorce, and inheritance, to Islamic courts, while other cases are handled by the secular judicial system.

While Sharia law provides guidance on a range of spiritual and worldly matters, its interpretation and application have been a subject of intense debate. Critics argue that certain interpretations of Sharia law can lead to cruel criminal punishments and restrictions on the rights of women and minority groups. For example, some countries in the Middle East implement hudud punishments, such as stoning, lashing, and amputation, for crimes like theft, blasphemy, and adultery. Additionally, the treatment of LGBTQ+ individuals and religious minorities in some Middle Eastern countries has been a cause for concern, with discriminatory laws and practices in place.

However, it is important to note that there is significant diversity in how Sharia law is interpreted and applied, and reforms have been made in some countries to modernize and adapt the legal system to reflect changing societal values. Additionally, the role of Sharia law in the legal systems of Muslim-minority countries, such as those in the West, is also a topic of ongoing debate.

The Middle East has a history of religious violence

The Middle East has a long history of religious violence, with the region continuing to have the highest levels of religious hostilities in the world. The conflicts in the region are usually multi-causal, but religion and religious hostilities are important factors. The violence is not limited to a single religion, with Christians, Jews, and Muslims all facing harassment in the region.

In 2014, six countries in the Middle East-North Africa region had "very high" levels of religious hostilities. These countries included Israel, Iraq, Syria, Yemen, Lebanon, and the Palestinian territories. The violence in these countries took the form of killings, kidnappings, harassment, intimidation, and displacement.

The Islamic State (IS or ISIS) has been a major contributor to the religious violence in the region. IS follows an extreme anti-Western interpretation of Islam and promotes religious violence. They regard those who do not agree with their interpretations as infidels or apostates. IS has been responsible for ethnic cleansing and the massacre of religious minorities.

The Middle East has also seen violence at holy sites, with Israeli security forces forcibly removing Palestinians from the Al-Aqsa Mosque. This has resulted in rocket attacks from militants in Gaza and Lebanon, causing damage to property and injuries.

The region has also witnessed a rise in terrorist activities, with Israel experiencing over 50 casualties in 2014. Additionally, there have been reports of settler-related violence, with Huwwara remaining a flashpoint.

Free speech is largely censored in the Middle East

The Middle East's censorship of the media is largely driven by the desire of governments to retain control over their people by preventing them from accessing information that could incite rebellion. The majority of nations in the Middle East censor the media, including Bahrain, Egypt, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Turkey, and the United Arab Emirates.

In the Middle East, censorship is often justified on religious grounds. In many countries, freedom of speech and the right to access information are governed by Islamic principles. Islamic principles have determined the trends present in social development. Censorship policies are often justified by citing a verse used by many Muslim jurists: "And do not argue with the people of the Scripture except in a way that is best (29:46)".

In some countries, censorship is also justified on the grounds of national security. In Syria, for example, the authorities censor information and correspondence with a free hand under the terms of emergency legislation promulgated more than forty years ago.

In some countries, censorship is also driven by a desire to maintain social norms and morals. In Egypt, for example, the government has worked with the first commercial ISPs to censor Internet pornography. Censorship during the Arab Spring also saw totalitarian regimes crack down on information flow.

In some countries, censorship is also driven by a desire to maintain the status quo and prevent criticism of the government. In Tunisia, for example, the government has imprisoned writers for their activities online.

Women in the Middle East face discrimination and a lack of gender equality

One of the most pressing issues is the low female participation rate in the workforce. According to the World Employment and Social Outlook: Trends 2024, the Arab States (non-Gulf Cooperation Council) has the lowest female participation rate in the world at 11.7%, compared to 66.2% for men. This gap is reflected in income as well, with Arab women earning just 12.5% of what Arab men earn, the lowest ratio globally. Women also face under-representation in leadership positions.

Girls and young women in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region face additional challenges due to restrictive gender norms that limit their physical mobility, access to education and employment, and decision-making power within the household and society. Adolescent girls are particularly vulnerable to malnutrition and gender-based violence, including sexual exploitation, female genital mutilation, child marriage, and gender-related killings.

Inequality is also prevalent in family laws, which often treat women as minors and restrict their rights in marriage, divorce, child custody, and inheritance. For example, in Algeria, polygamy is permitted, and a divorced mother can lose custody of her children if she remarries. In some countries, including Iraq, Kuwait, and Algeria, 'marry your rapist' laws remain in place, perpetuating a cycle of impunity for perpetrators of sexual violence.

While there have been victories for women's rights movements in the region, such as the repeal of 'marry your rapist' laws in Morocco, Jordan, Lebanon, and Palestine, significant challenges remain. Conflict, the resurgence of extremist religious groups, and political turmoil have reduced the space for civil society engagement with governments, hindering long-term legal reforms.

Frequently asked questions