Navigating Laws In International Waters

International waters, or the high seas, are areas of the ocean that do not fall under any nation's jurisdiction. They are beyond the reach of any single nation, meaning no one owns them. International waters usually begin where territorial waters end, which is typically 12 miles from the shoreline, although this can vary by country. Contrary to popular belief, international waters are not a lawless no man's land. International law dictates that all ships must be registered with a territory and come under the jurisdiction of that territory, as do their passengers. Certain crimes, such as slavery, piracy, and illegal broadcasting, fall under the category of universal jurisdiction, meaning any ship from any state can intervene.

International waters are not lawless

International waters, or the "high seas", are areas of the ocean that do not fall under any nation's jurisdiction and are beyond a nation's reach, meaning no one "owns" them. However, this does not mean that they are lawless. International waters are subject to international law and various treaties, such as the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). This convention establishes guidelines that give countries the authority to exercise jurisdiction over social, technical, and administrative matters concerning ships flying their flags.

According to UNCLOS, each state has the power to enforce its laws on vessels registered under its flag. This means that if a crime is committed on a ship, the laws of the country where the ship is registered would apply. For example, if a fugitive is on board a ship in international waters, they would be subject to the laws of the country the ship is registered to. Similarly, if you are sailing a British ship, you are subject to British law, regardless of your location.

International law also recognises universal crimes, such as piracy, where a country can assert its jurisdiction over international waters. In addition, all ships are required to be registered with a territory, and by default, come under the jurisdiction of that territory. This is known as the "flag of convenience", where ships are registered in countries with more relaxed laws to take advantage of the legal benefits. If a ship is not registered, it is subject to the laws of any state, as any ship can investigate and intervene in suspected illegal activities.

Furthermore, the "passive personality principle" states that a person committing a crime is subject to the jurisdiction of the state of the victim. For example, if a French citizen is murdered on a ship in international waters, the perpetrator can be prosecuted under French law. Overall, while international waters do not belong to any single nation, they are still governed by a complex interplay of international laws, treaties, and agreements between nations.

Jurisdiction is determined by ship registration

The country of registration determines a ship's flag state and nationality, as well as the laws that govern its operation and the behaviour of its crew. The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) affirms that "every state has the power and authority to exercise its jurisdiction over all social, technical, and administrative matters on watercraft with its flag". This means that if a crime is committed on a ship, the laws of the country where the ship is registered will apply. For example, if a ship is registered in the Netherlands and is cruising in the territorial waters of the US, playing poker in the onboard casino would be deemed illegal and the casino would have to remain closed until the vessel leaves US territorial waters.

The registration process varies depending on the registry, which can be a governmental or private agency. Some registries are traditional or national registers, only open to ships of their own nation, while others are open registries that accept foreign-owned ships. The requirements for registration also differ by jurisdiction, with some requiring vessels operating in territorial waters to register on their national register, and others forbidding foreign-flagged vessels from trading between domestic ports.

The choice of jurisdiction for ship registration can have significant implications for ship owners, including tax savings, regulatory stability, recognition of the flag, and flexibility in ownership arrangements. For example, the Cayman Islands is known for its high flag reputation, strong legal and privacy protections, and fast registration process, making it a desirable option for owners of luxury yachts and commercial ships.

In summary, jurisdiction over a ship is determined by its registration and flag state, with the country of registration setting the legal framework for the ship's operation and crew, and the flag state exercising regulatory control and ensuring compliance with safety and pollution standards.

Universal crimes like piracy are prosecutable

International waters, or the "high seas", are areas of the ocean that do not fall under any nation's jurisdiction. They are beyond the reach of any single nation, and so no one "owns" them. However, this does not mean that they are lawless. International law dictates that all ships must be registered with a territory and come under the jurisdiction of that territory, as well as flying that territory's flag. This means that passengers on these ships are subject to the laws of the country in which the ship is registered.

Universal crimes, such as piracy, are prosecutable by any country or international organisation under the concept of universal jurisdiction. This means that any party can claim authority over the matter, justify the right to thwart criminal activity, and bring charges against and try assailants in their own national or international courts.

For example, if a person from Country X commits a murder on a ship owned by Country Y in international waters, but the ship then enters the territorial waters of Country Z, the laws of Country Y would apply. However, because this is a universal crime, any country could prosecute.

If a ship is not registered or flying a flag, it is considered suspicious and can be inspected by any other ship. Any illegal activity found can be reported and punished by the laws of the country of the criminals, or, if this information is not provided, by the laws of the country of the inspecting ship.

The US can assert jurisdiction in some situations

International waters, or the "high seas", are areas of the ocean that do not fall under any nation's jurisdiction. They are beyond the reach of any single nation, meaning that no one "owns" them. However, this does not mean that they are lawless. International waters are governed by international law and agreements between nations.

The United States can and does assert jurisdiction in certain situations in international waters. The US Code grants the federal government the power to exercise "Special Maritime and Territorial Jurisdiction" in specific scenarios, as outlined below:

• Any island or rock with guano deposits, as per the President's discretion: In cases where islands or rocks in international waters are found to have guano deposits, the US government has the authority to claim jurisdiction over them. Guano, the excrement of seabirds or bats, was historically valuable as a source of nitrate for fertiliser and saltpetre for gunpowder.
• Crimes against US citizens outside of US territory: The US government has the jurisdiction to intervene in situations where a crime has been committed against a US citizen in international waters or in a foreign country. This extends their reach beyond their territorial boundaries to protect their citizens.
• Foreign watercraft involved in crimes against US citizens: Additionally, the US can assert jurisdiction over foreign watercraft that are scheduled to arrive in or depart from the US if a crime has been perpetrated against a US citizen on board. This provision ensures that the US can take action against criminal activities that directly impact its citizens, even on foreign vessels.

These provisions allow the US to extend its jurisdiction beyond its territorial waters, which typically extend 12 miles from the shoreline, and in the case of the US, up to 24 nautical miles. By asserting jurisdiction in these specific situations, the US can enforce its laws and protect its citizens even in international waters.

The UN Convention on the Law of the Sea

The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) was adopted in 1982 and lays down a comprehensive regime of law and order in the world's oceans and seas. It establishes rules governing all uses of the oceans and their resources, introducing new legal concepts and regimes and addressing new concerns.

UNCLOS embodies traditional rules for the uses of the oceans in a single instrument. It also provides the framework for further development of specific areas of the law of the sea. The convention comprises 320 articles and nine annexes, governing all aspects of ocean space, such as delimitation, environmental control, marine scientific research, economic and commercial activities, the transfer of technology, and the settlement of disputes relating to ocean matters.

Some of the key features of the convention include:

• Coastal states have sovereignty over their territorial sea, with the right to establish its breadth up to a limit not exceeding 12 nautical miles. Foreign vessels are allowed "innocent passage" through those waters.
• Ships and aircraft of all countries are permitted "transit passage" through straits used for international navigation. States bordering the straits can regulate navigational and other aspects of passage.
• Archipelagic states have sovereignty over a sea area enclosed by straight lines drawn between the outermost points of the islands. The waters between the islands are declared archipelagic waters, where states may establish sea lanes and air routes, with all other states enjoying the right of archipelagic passage through designated sea lanes.
• Coastal states have sovereign rights in a 200-nautical-mile exclusive economic zone (EEZ) regarding natural resources and certain economic activities. They also exercise jurisdiction over marine science research and environmental protection.
• All other states have freedom of navigation and overflight in the EEZ, as well as the freedom to lay submarine cables and pipelines.
• Land-locked and geographically disadvantaged states have the right to participate in the equitable exploitation of an appropriate part of the living resources of the EEZ's of coastal states in the same region or sub-region.
• Coastal states have sovereign rights over the continental shelf for exploration and exploitation. The shelf can extend at least 200 nautical miles from the shore and more under specified circumstances.

UNCLOS grants all states traditional freedoms of navigation, overflight, scientific research, and fishing on the high seas. They are obliged to adopt or cooperate with other states in adopting measures to manage and conserve living resources.

Frequently asked questions