Dankula's Legal Trouble: Free Speech Or Hate Crime?

In 2016, Mark Meechan, better known as Count Dankula, posted a video online of his girlfriend's pug giving a Nazi salute. In the video, the dog raises its paw in response to the command Sieg Heil and gas the Jews. Meechan was subsequently charged and convicted under the Communications Act of 2003 for posting a grossly offensive video.

Meechan defended his actions as a joke intended to annoy his girlfriend. However, the court rejected this claim, stating that the video was viewed as grossly offensive within Jewish communities in Scotland and that it tended to normalize anti-Semitic attitudes.

The conviction sparked a debate about free speech, with some comedians, including Ricky Gervais and David Baddiel, defending Meechan's right to make jokes. Others, such as Father Ted writer Graham Linehan, disagreed, arguing that Meechan's use of the phrase gas the Jews was hate speech.

Count Dankula was convicted under the Communications Act for being grossly offensive

Count Dankula, whose real name is Mark Meechan, was convicted under the Communications Act for being grossly offensive. The Communications Act of 2003 states that:

> A person is guilty of an offence if he—sends by means of a public electronic communications network a message or other matter that is grossly offensive or of an indecent, obscene or menacing character.

Count Dankula was found guilty of this offence when he posted a video of his girlfriend's pug giving a Nazi salute in response to him saying things like "Sieg Heil!" and "Gas the Jews!". The video was viewed as grossly offensive within Jewish communities in Scotland and was considered to normalize anti-Semitic attitudes and provoke further unpleasant anti-Semitic messages.

Count Dankula denied that he was anti-Semitic and claimed that the video was a joke to annoy his girlfriend and should not be considered a hate crime. However, the court rejected his claim and found that he was aware that the video would cause offence.

The conviction of Count Dankula sparked a debate about free speech, with some arguing that the law was a restriction on freedom of expression. Others, however, supported the conviction, stating that the video was offensive and promoted hate speech. The Scottish Council of Jewish Communities welcomed the conviction, stating that the video was not a joke but rather an intentional attempt to cause offence.

Count Dankula was fined £800

Count Dankula, whose real name is Mark Meechan, was fined £800 for being found guilty of violating the Communications Act for being "grossly offensive". The specific charge was for sending a "grossly offensive message by a public telecommunications network". The charge was brought under Section 127 of the Communications Act 2003, which states that:

> A person is guilty of an offence if he—

> (a) sends by means of a public electronic communications network a message or other matter that is grossly offensive or of an indecent, obscene or menacing character;

The video in question, which was posted to YouTube, showed Meechan's girlfriend's pug giving a Nazi salute and reacting excitedly when Meechan asked "do you want to gas the Jews?" and raising its paw when he called "Sieg Heil". The video also included Meechan playing speeches by Adolf Hitler to the dog.

Meechan claimed that the video was intended as a joke to annoy his girlfriend and that it should not be considered a hate crime. However, the court rejected this defence, pointing out that Meechan's girlfriend wasn't even a subscriber to his YouTube channel. The court also found that the video was viewed as grossly offensive within Jewish communities in Scotland and that it tended to normalize anti-Semitic attitudes and provoke further unpleasant anti-Semitic messages.

The fine of £800 was not paid by Meechan, who instead donated the equivalent sum to charity.

Count Dankula's video was viewed as grossly offensive within Jewish communities in Scotland

Count Dankula, or Markus Meechan, was convicted of a hate crime after uploading a video of him teaching his girlfriend's dog to give a Nazi salute. The video was viewed as grossly offensive within Jewish communities in Scotland.

In the video, the dog reacts excitedly whenever Meechan asks "do you want to gas the Jews?" and raises its paw when he says "Sieg Heil". The video also includes Meechan playing speeches by Adolf Hitler to the dog.

The video was viewed as grossly offensive within Jewish communities in Scotland. The Scottish Council of Jewish Communities (SCJC) stated that the video tended to normalize anti-Semitic attitudes and provoke further unpleasant anti-Semitic messages. The SCJC welcomed Meechan's conviction, claiming that the video was not a joke but intended to give offense.

Meechan denied that he was anti-Semitic and stated that the video was meant as a joke to annoy his girlfriend and should not be considered a hate crime. He argued that context and intent were disregarded during his trial, and that his conviction raises serious questions about freedom of speech.

The video sparked a national debate about free speech, with comedians such as Ricky Gervais, Stephen Fry, and Jonathan Pie weighing in. Meechan's conviction was also supported by British far-right figureheads, including Tommy Robinson.

Count Dankula's video was found to normalise anti-Semitic attitudes

Count Dankula, whose real name is Markus Meechan, was convicted under the Communications Act for being "grossly offensive". The specific section of the Communications Act 2003 under which he was charged reads:

> A person is guilty of an offence if he—

> (a) sends by means of a public electronic communications network a message or other matter that is grossly offensive or of an indecent, obscene or menacing character;

Count Dankula's video was found to be "grossly offensive" by the Airdrie Sheriff Court. In his sentencing remarks, Sheriff Derek O'Carroll said:

> The evidence before this court was that the video was viewed as grossly offensive within Jewish communities in Scotland and that such material tended to normalize anti-Semitic attitudes and provoke further unpleasant anti-Semitic messages and as such, this video using menacing language, led to great concern.

The video was also found to contain anti-Semitic and racist material, as it:

> explicitly and exclusively referred to Jews, the Holocaust and the role of the Nazis in the death of six million Jews in a grossly offensive manner.

Count Dankula knew, or ought to have known, that the video would be found grossly offensive by many Jewish people.

Count Dankula's video was found to provoke further unpleasant anti-Semitic messages

Count Dankula, whose real name is Mark Meechan, was convicted of a hate crime after uploading a video of him teaching his girlfriend's dog to give a Nazi salute. In the video, the dog reacts excitedly whenever Meechan asks "Do you want to gas the Jews?" and raises its paw when he calls "Sieg Heil". The video also shows Meechan playing speeches by Adolf Hitler to the dog.

The video was found to be "grossly offensive" and was deemed to have "normalise[d] anti-Semitic attitudes and provoke[d] further unpleasant anti-Semitic messages". The Sheriff, Derek O'Carroll, stated that the video "contained anti-Semitic, and racist material, in that it explicitly and exclusively referred to Jews, the Holocaust and the role of the Nazis in the death of six million Jews in a grossly offensive manner".

Meechan denied that he was anti-Semitic and claimed that the video was nothing more than a joke to annoy his girlfriend. He argued that the case raised serious questions of freedom of speech, stating that "context and intent" were disregarded.

The conviction was welcomed by the Scottish Council of Jewish Communities, who claimed to have received hundreds of anti-Semitic messages online after their director, Ephraim Borowski, was called to give evidence at the trial. They said that the case was "not about whether the video was a 'joke' but about whether it was intended to give offense".

Frequently asked questions