Luther's Legal Battle: What Law Was Broken?

Shelley Luther, owner of the Salon À la Mode hair salon in Dallas, Texas, was sentenced to seven days in jail and fined $7,000 for violating Texas stay-at-home orders during the COVID-19 pandemic. Luther gained national attention when she defied a state order to close her salon, resulting in her arrest and fines. On April 24, 2020, Luther reopened her salon in violation of local restrictions and a court order. She was found in contempt of court and jailed for two weeks, though she was released after serving only two days. This incident sparked a debate about the role of government power and individual freedom during a public health crisis.

Shelley Luther defied Texas stay-at-home orders

Shelley Luther, owner of the Salon À la Mode hair salon in Dallas, gained national attention when she defied Texas stay-at-home orders during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. On April 24, 2020, Luther reopened her salon in violation of local restrictions and a court order.

Dallas County was under a "Safer at Home Order" issued by County Judge Clay Jenkins, which was enforced by the city's manager, T.C. Broadnax, through a series of amended emergency regulations. Additionally, Texas Governor Greg Abbott had issued an executive order that allowed some businesses to open but advised people to avoid cosmetology salons.

Despite these directives, Luther chose to reopen her salon, citing the financial hardship caused by the closure. She received a notice of violation from a Dallas Code Inspector and a cease-and-desist letter from Judge Jenkins. On April 27, she received another notice of violation through her counsel.

Luther's actions resulted in legal repercussions. On April 28, Dallas filed a case against her for violating the emergency regulations, and the court granted a temporary restraining order requiring her to shut down the salon. However, Luther refused to comply and kept her salon open. As a result, she was found in contempt of court and sentenced to seven days in jail and a fine of $7,000 by Judge Eric Moye.

Luther's case sparked widespread debate and attracted significant media attention. Some criticised her actions as irresponsible and a threat to public health, while others sympathised with her struggle to keep her business afloat during the pandemic. Her sentence was criticised by prominent figures, including Texas Prosecutor General Ken Paxton and Governor Abbott, who called for her immediate release.

Ultimately, Luther served only two days in jail before being released by the Texas Supreme Court, which granted temporary relief while reviewing her petition for a writ of habeas corpus. The court later set a schedule of briefings to consider the case further.

She was fined and sentenced to jail for seven days

Shelley Luther, owner of Salon À la Mode in Dallas, was sentenced to seven days in jail and fined $7,000 for violating Texas's stay-at-home orders. On April 24, 2020, Luther reopened her salon in defiance of the state's COVID-19 restrictions. She also ripped up a citation from the Dallas Police and a cease-and-desist letter from County Judge Clay Jenkins.

On May 5, 2020, Judge Eric Moye sentenced Luther to seven days in prison and a $7,000 fine for civil and criminal contempt of court. The judge offered Luther the chance to avoid jail time if she apologised for her actions, which she refused. As a result, she was imprisoned.

Luther's sentence was widely criticised, and she was released after two days. The Supreme Court of Texas ordered her release, but she still had to pay the fine. Luther gained national attention for her defiance of COVID-19 restrictions and her case became a symbol for those opposed to such measures.

Luther's actions and the subsequent legal consequences occurred against a backdrop of broader political and social tensions surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic. Many people suffered financial hardship due to the restrictions, and there were debates about individual freedoms, the role of government, and the rule of law. Luther's case highlighted these divisions and sparked discussions about the appropriate response to those who defied public health measures.

She refused to apologise for her actions

Shelley Luther, owner of Salon À la Mode in Dallas, gained national attention in 2020 when she defied COVID-19 restrictions and a court order, keeping her salon open despite local mandates. On April 24, 2020, Luther reopened her salon, violating the City's Fourth Emergency Regulations. She was issued a notice of violation and a cease-and-desist letter, which she openly defied, tearing it up on stage during a rally.

On May 5, 2020, Judge Eric Moye sentenced Luther to seven days in prison and a $7,000 fine for civil and criminal contempt of court. Notably, Judge Moye stated that Luther could avoid jail time if she apologised for her actions, which placed the community at risk of COVID-19 transmission. However, she refused to apologise and was subsequently imprisoned.

Luther's sentence sparked widespread criticism, including from Texas Prosecutor General Ken Paxton and Governor Greg Abbott, who called for her immediate release. Abbott even reversed his statewide orders shortly after. Luther's refusal to apologise and her subsequent imprisonment became a highly politicised issue, with some criticising the judge's decision and others defending it as necessary to enforce compliance with public health measures.

Luther's actions and her stance on her beliefs garnered both support and opposition. Her campaign website emphasised her unwavering commitment to her values, stating, "Shelley Luther isn't afraid to stand up for what she believes in and won't ever back down from a fight." This resoluteness resonated with many, as evidenced by her subsequent victory in the 2024 Texas state house election, where she secured over 75% of the votes.

In conclusion, Shelley Luther's refusal to apologise for breaking COVID-19 mandates and a court order resulted in her imprisonment and sparked a broader debate about individual rights, public health, and the role of government during a pandemic. Her actions and their aftermath highlighted the complexities and polarising nature of these issues, with strong opinions on both sides.

She was released after two days

Shelley Luther, an American salon owner and politician, was jailed for violating lockdown rules during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. She defied stay-at-home orders and kept her salon open, despite receiving a citation from the Dallas police and a cease-and-desist letter. She was sentenced to seven days in jail and fined $7,000 by District Judge Eric Moyé. However, she was released after just two days.

Luther's decision to keep her business open sparked national attention and controversy. On the one hand, she argued that she needed to keep her business open to support her family and pay rent. On the other hand, authorities maintained that she was violating public health orders aimed at curbing the spread of COVID-19. The case became highly politicized, with several Texas Republican Party politicians, including Governor Greg Abbott and Texas Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick, voicing their support for Luther and criticizing the judge's decision to incarcerate her.

The situation escalated when Judge Moyé gave Luther an opportunity to apologize and promise to close her salon until allowed to reopen. Luther refused, stating that "feeding my kids is not selfish." In response, Judge Moyé handed down the sentence, which included both jail time and a fine. Luther and her lawyers immediately appealed the decision, and the case eventually reached the Texas Supreme Court.

The intense public scrutiny and political pressure surrounding Luther's case prompted Governor Abbott to change his executive orders. He removed the possibility of imprisonment as a penalty for violating lockdown rules, which ultimately led to Luther's release from jail after two days. Her release was celebrated by supporters, including President Donald Trump, who commended her professionalism and dedication to providing for her children.

Following her release, Luther established a foundation called "Courage to Stand," aiming to support small businesses affected by government-mandated closures during the pandemic. She also entered politics, running for a seat in the Texas Senate and later for the Texas House of Representatives. While she faced initial setbacks, she successfully won the election for the Texas House of Representatives in 2024, defeating incumbent Reggie Smith in the primaries.

She later ran for State Senate

In 2020, Shelley Luther gained national attention for her decision to keep her salon business open during the COVID-19 pandemic. Despite initial compliance with stay-at-home orders, Luther reopened her salon in April, citing economic concerns as her reason. As a result, she received a citation from the Dallas police, followed by a cease-and-desist letter, which she defied by declaring her intention to remain open. This act of defiance led to a court case, in which Luther was sentenced to seven days in jail and a $7,000 fine. The case attracted widespread attention, with prominent Republican figures, including Texas Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick, voicing their support for Luther and criticising the judge's decision.

After her release, Luther established the "Courage to Stand" foundation, aiming to support small businesses impacted by government-mandated closures. She leveraged this newfound attention to launch a political career, announcing her campaign for a special election in the Texas Senate in August 2020. Luther's campaign focused on ending the "shutdown madness", positioning herself as a critic of Governor Greg Abbott's lockdown measures. She advocated for fully reopening nursing homes, bars, and restaurants, arguing that other states, like Florida, had already done so.

In the election, Luther faced off against five other candidates and emerged as the top vote-getter, securing 32.0% of the votes cast. However, since she did not receive more than 50% of the votes, a runoff election was triggered between her and Republican Drew Springer. Unfortunately for Luther, she was defeated in the runoff, garnering 43.5% of the votes compared to Springer's 56.5%.

Undeterred by this setback, Luther persisted in her political aspirations. In 2022, she challenged incumbent Reggie Smith in the primaries for the Texas House of Representatives' 62nd district but fell short, receiving only 41.3% of the votes. Demonstrating resilience, Luther mounted another campaign for the same seat in 2024, this time successfully defeating Smith in the primaries. She went on to face Democrat Tiffany Drake in the general election and emerged victorious with a substantial 77.7% of the votes.

Frequently asked questions