Shelly Luther: Breaking The Law During A Pandemic

Shelley Luther, owner of the Salon À la Mode hair salon in Dallas, gained national attention in 2020 when she defied COVID-19 restrictions and was subsequently jailed for breaking the law. On April 24, 2020, Luther reopened her salon in violation of Texas stay-at-home orders, as well as a cease-and-desist letter from County Judge Clay Jenkins. Luther's actions resulted in a seven-day jail sentence and a $7,000 fine imposed by Judge Eric Moye. The sentence was widely criticised, and Luther became a symbol of resistance to COVID-19 restrictions.

Shelley Luther defied a court order to close her salon

Shelley Luther, owner of the Salon À la Mode hair salon in Dallas, gained national attention when she defied COVID-19 restrictions and a court order by keeping her salon open. On April 24, 2020, Luther reopened her salon despite a cease-and-desist letter from County Judge Clay Jenkins. She also tore up a citation from the Dallas Police, and refused to apologise for her actions.

As a result, Judge Eric Moye sentenced Luther to seven days in prison and a $7000 fine for civil and criminal contempt of court. However, she was released after serving two days. Luther's sentence was criticised by some as excessive, while others argued that she should have been punished for breaking the law and endangering the health of others.

The case of Shelley Luther highlights the ongoing debate surrounding government powers and individual freedoms during the COVID-19 pandemic. Luther's actions and subsequent punishment brought attention to the economic impact of lockdown measures and the role of government in enforcing public health measures.

Luther's defiance of COVID-19 restrictions and a court order resulted in her gaining national attention and becoming a symbol of resistance to government mandates. Her case also sparked discussions about the appropriate response to individuals who defy public health orders, with some arguing that jail time was unnecessary and that alternative solutions, such as changing the locks on her business, could have been explored.

Ultimately, the Texas Supreme Court granted temporary relief and released Luther while considering a petition filed by her lawyer. The court's final decision will determine whether the emergency rules implemented during the pandemic are considered laws and whether Luther's actions constituted contempt of court.

She was fined $1000 per day

Shelley Luther, owner of the Salon À la Mode hair salon in Dallas, was fined $1000 per day for violating Texas stay-at-home orders. On April 24, 2020, Luther reopened her salon in defiance of local restrictions and a court order. As a result, she was found in contempt of court and sentenced to seven days in jail and fined $7000 by Judge Eric Moye.

Luther's actions attracted widespread attention and sparked intense debate. Some argued that she should have been punished for breaking the law and setting a dangerous precedent during a public health crisis. Others criticised her sentence as excessive, particularly given that she could have avoided jail time by apologising and agreeing to close her salon. The situation was further complicated by the involvement of prominent political figures and the creation of a GoFundMe campaign that raised over $500,000 for her cause.

The legal battle surrounding Luther's case continued after her release from jail. She filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus with the Texas Supreme Court, challenging the validity of the emergency rules as laws and the authority of the Dallas court to issue a temporary restraining order without requiring a bond. The Texas Supreme Court granted temporary relief and released Luther while considering the petition. The court's final decision is still pending, with several possible outcomes on the table.

Luther's stance resonated with a significant portion of the Texas population, and she leveraged this support to pursue a career in politics. In 2024, she won the Texas state house election, securing over 75% of the votes. Her campaign emphasised her unwavering commitment to her beliefs, a quality that clearly resonated with voters. Luther's political ambitions had been building for some time, with previous attempts to run for office in 2020 and 2022.

She was jailed for seven days

Shelley Luther, owner of the Salon À la Mode hair salon in Dallas, was sentenced to seven days in jail and a $7,000 fine for violating Texas's stay-at-home orders. On April 24, 2020, Luther reopened her salon in defiance of the state's COVID-19 restrictions. She also ripped up a citation she had received from the Dallas Police for opening her salon the day before.

On April 27, Luther received another notice of violation through her counsel. The following day, Dallas filed a case against Luther for violating the Fourth Emergency Regulations under Section 54.016 of the Texas Local Government Code. The court granted a temporary restraining order requiring Luther to shut down her salon as it was deemed that her actions endangered the health of others. Luther refused to comply and was found in contempt of court.

On May 5, Judge Eric Moye sentenced Luther to seven days in prison and a $7,000 fine for civil and criminal contempt of court. The judge stated that Luther could avoid jail time if she apologised for her actions, which she refused to do. Her sentence was criticised by many, including Texas Prosecutor General Ken Paxton and Governor Greg Abbott, who asked for her immediate release.

Luther was released after serving two days in jail. Her case was taken up by the Texas Supreme Court, which granted her temporary relief while it considered her petition. The court set a schedule of briefings, which were completed on May 22, with a decision pending. Luther's imprisonment sparked a debate about the role of judges in enforcing COVID-19 restrictions and the balance between public health and individual liberties.

She refused to apologise to avoid jail time

Shelley Luther, owner of the Salon À la Mode hair salon in Dallas, was sentenced to seven days in jail and a $7,000 fine for violating Texas stay-at-home orders by Judge Eric Moye. Luther had reopened her salon in defiance of Judge Eric Moye's cease-and-desist order, which was issued after she initially opened her salon in violation of the "Safer at Home Order" issued by Dallas County Judge Clay Jenkins.

On May 5, 2020, Judge Moye sentenced Luther to seven days in prison and a $7,000 fine for her disobedience of the order. The judge informed Luther that she could avoid jail time if she apologised for her actions, which had placed the community at risk of transmitting coronavirus. However, Luther refused to apologise and was subsequently imprisoned.

Luther's sentence sparked widespread criticism, including from Texas Prosecutor General Ken Paxton and Governor Greg Abbott, who called for her immediate release. Abbott also reversed his statewide orders shortly after Luther's sentencing. Luther's case gained national attention and brought the issue of COVID-19 restrictions on businesses into the spotlight.

Luther's refusal to apologise and her subsequent imprisonment highlight the tension between public health concerns and individual liberties during the pandemic. While some criticised Luther's actions as irresponsible and a threat to public health, others applauded her stance as a defence of personal freedom and a challenge to what they saw as government overreach.

Ultimately, Luther's decision to refuse the apology offer and serve the jail sentence was a reflection of her unwavering commitment to her beliefs, which later helped propel her to political victory in the 2024 Texas state house election.

She was released after two days

Shelley Luther, owner of the Salon À la Mode hair salon in Dallas, gained national attention in 2020 when she defied COVID-19 restrictions and a court order by keeping her business open. On April 24, 2020, Luther reopened her salon in violation of Texas stay-at-home orders and was issued a notice of violation by a Dallas Code Inspector. Despite receiving a cease-and-desist letter from County Judge Clay Jenkins, Luther refused to close her salon.

On April 28, Dallas filed a case against Luther for violating the Fourth Emergency Regulations under Section 54.016 of the Texas Local Government Code. The court granted a temporary restraining order (TRO) requiring Luther to shut down her salon as its operation was deemed to endanger the health of others. Luther was given the opportunity to avoid jail time if she apologised for her actions and closed her salon, but she refused.

On May 5, Judge Eric Moye sentenced Luther to seven days in prison and a $7,000 fine for civil and criminal contempt of court. However, she was released after serving only two days of her sentence. The Supreme Court of Texas ordered her release, and she subsequently became known as a symbol of resistance to COVID-19 restrictions.

Luther's case sparked intense debate and garnered significant media attention. Some criticised her actions as irresponsible and a threat to public health, while others applauded her defiance of what they saw as government overreach. Luther's sentence was widely criticised by prominent figures, including Texas Prosecutor General Ken Paxton and Governor Greg Abbott, who called for her immediate release.

Following her release, Luther continued to voice her opposition to COVID-19 restrictions and gained political prominence. She ran for political office and won the Texas state house election in 2024, emphasising her unwavering stance on her beliefs.

Frequently asked questions