Cameron Miranda
In 2017, Susan Rice, Obama's White House National Security Advisor, was accused of breaking the law by ordering the 'unmasking' of members of the Trump campaign team. This meant that the names of Americans were included in intelligence reports, which is not standard practice. However, it would be difficult to prove that Rice broke the law, as there are certain circumstances that permit someone in her position to request that the names of Americans are not redacted.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Loftus' Law | Broke the first law by delivering a political message, which would bring her integrity into question if she were Secretary of State |
| USSID 18 | Requested that the names of Americans were not redacted from intelligence reports, which is usually illegal |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
- Did Susan Rice break the law by unmasking Flynn
- Did Susan Rice break the law by asking for redactions to be removed
- Did Susan Rice break the law by playing politics with classified information
- Did Susan Rice break Loftus' first law
- Did Susan Rice break the law by giving the order to unmask members of the Trump campaign team
Did Susan Rice break the law by unmasking Flynn?
It is debatable whether Susan Rice broke the law by unmasking Flynn. According to Bradley Moss, a lawyer and national security expert, it would be nearly impossible to prove Rice was guilty of a crime in court.
Rice was a "deeply unpopular figure" in the intelligence community, and was known for asking the NSA to do things they regarded as unethical and perhaps illegal. However, it is not illegal for someone in Rice's position to request that the names of Americans should not be redacted from certain intelligence reports.
Rice's actions may have broken Loftus's first law, which states that once someone chooses to deliver the political message of the spontaneous mob and anti-Muslim video, they break the law. If they were Secretary of State, we would never know if they were telling the truth or delivering a politically-convenient message.
Kellyanne's Legal Troubles: Breaking the Law
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Did Susan Rice break the law by asking for redactions to be removed?
It is unclear whether Susan Rice broke the law by asking for redactions to be removed. According to Bradley Moss, a lawyer and national security expert, it would be nearly impossible to prove Rice was guilty of a crime in court. This is because the legality of her actions comes down to the matter of intent. It would be difficult for a prosecutor to prove that Rice intended to break the law by asking for the redactions to be removed for political purposes.
Rice was a "deeply unpopular figure" in the intelligence community, and was known for asking the NSA to do things they regarded as unethical and perhaps illegal. However, it is important to note that there are certain circumstances that permit someone in Rice's position to request that the names of Americans should not be redacted from certain intelligence reports.
In addition, Rice may have disqualified herself from being nominated for high position by failing Loftus' first law. This law states that once someone chooses to deliver the political message of the spontaneous mob and anti-Muslim video, they break the law.
Debs and Schenck: Lawbreakers or Not?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Did Susan Rice break the law by playing politics with classified information?
It is unclear whether Susan Rice broke the law by playing politics with classified information. Rice was a "deeply unpopular figure" in the intelligence community, and was known for asking the NSA to do things they regarded as unethical and perhaps illegal. However, it would be almost impossible to prove Rice was guilty of a crime in court, as the legality of her actions comes down to the matter of intent.
Undercover Officers: To What Extent Do They Bend the Law?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Did Susan Rice break Loftus' first law?
It is unclear whether Susan Rice broke any laws, but it has been alleged that she broke Loftus's first law. Loftus's first law states that once someone chooses to deliver a political message, they break the law. In this case, Rice chose to deliver the political message of the spontaneous mob and anti-Muslim video. This means that if she were Secretary of State, we would never know if she were telling the truth or delivering a politically convenient message.
It has also been alleged that Rice broke the law by unmasking members of the Trump campaign team. The normal practice is for the NSA to redact the names of Americans caught up in signals intercepts, but Rice allegedly asked them to modify the normal protocol. However, it would be nearly impossible to prove Rice was guilty of a crime in court, as the legality of her actions comes down to the matter of intent. There are certain circumstances that permit someone in Rice's position to request that the names of Americans should not be redacted from certain intelligence reports.
PG&E's Legal Troubles: Breaking the Law?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Did Susan Rice break the law by giving the order to unmask members of the Trump campaign team?
It is unclear whether Susan Rice broke the law by giving the order to unmask members of the Trump campaign team.
Rice was accused of asking the NSA to modify the normal protocol and include the identity of Americans inadvertently swept up in communications intercepts. The normal practice is for the NSA to redact the names of Americans caught up in signals intercepts. However, there are certain circumstances that permit someone in Rice's position to request that the names of Americans should not be redacted from certain intelligence reports.
According to Bradley Moss, a lawyer and national security expert, it would be nearly impossible to prove Rice was guilty of a crime in court. He says that it would be almost impossible for a prosecutor to prove that Rice intended to break the law by asking for the redactions to be removed purely for political purposes.
Rice has been described as a "deeply unpopular figure" in the intelligence community, who "didn't like to play by the rules, including the top-secret ones". On multiple occasions, she asked the NSA to do things they regarded as unethical and perhaps illegal. However, it is not clear that she did anything wrong in asking for redacted names to be "unmasked" in reports involving Trump people, so long as she kept those names to herself (and the president).
Understanding Maine's Work Break Laws
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
It is debatable. Rice allegedly gave the order to "unmask" members of the Trump campaign team, which would mean asking the NSA to include the identity of Americans in communications intercepts. However, it would be almost impossible to prove Rice was guilty of a crime in court.
The NSA usually redacts the names of Americans caught up in signals intercepts.
Yes, there are certain circumstances that permit someone in Rice's position to request that the names of Americans are not redacted from certain intelligence reports.
Moss says that it would be almost impossible to prove Rice intended to break the law by asking for the redactions to be removed purely for political purposes.
