How Schoolhouse Rock Explains Lawmaking

I'm Just a Bill is a segment from the 1976 Schoolhouse Rock! series that explains the process of how a bill becomes a law in the United States. The segment, presented in the form of a song, follows the journey of a bill from its introduction in Congress to its potential enactment as a law. The song highlights the various stages a bill must go through, including committee discussions, votes in both houses of Congress, and the possibility of a presidential veto. While the Schoolhouse Rock! version provides a simplified linear path, the actual process of a bill becoming a law can be more complex and challenging, involving bicameral legislatures, committee investigations, and the need for advocacy to support or oppose legislation.

How a bill becomes a law

In the Schoolhouse Rock! segment "I'm Just a Bill", a young boy comes across a "sad little scrap of paper" on the steps of the Capitol Building in Washington. The paper tells the boy that it is a bill and that it hopes to become a law someday. The bill then explains the long process it must go through to become a law.

Firstly, the bill starts as an idea. In the case of "I'm Just a Bill", some folks back home decided they wanted a law passed, so they called their local congressman, who agreed and wrote the bill out before introducing it to Congress. Once a bill has been introduced to Congress, it is considered by a committee. If the committee approves the bill, it is then voted on by one body of Congress. If approved by that body, the process starts over in the other body.

If the bill passes the legislature, it is sent to the President. If the President signs it and doesn't veto it, the bill becomes a law. However, if the President vetoes the bill, it must go back to Congress and be voted on again. By that time, the bill is so old that it is very unlikely to become a law.

The process for how a bill becomes a law can be confusing, and it is important to understand the stages and hurdles a bill must overcome to be passed. Legislatures represent one of the three branches of government at the federal and state levels in the United States, and most legislatures in the US are bicameral, meaning they have two chambers that must pass legislation independently for it to become law.

The role of committees

The committee's work involves investigating, discussing, and evaluating the potential impact of the proposed legislation. They may hold hearings to gather input and expertise from various stakeholders, such as subject matter experts, advocates, and individuals who would be affected by the bill. This process helps to ensure that the legislation is thoroughly vetted and that all relevant considerations are taken into account.

In the United States, committees are typically partisan creations, meaning the party that holds the majority in the full chamber also holds the majority of seats on all committees. This can have implications for the fate of a bill, as the partisan divide may influence whether a bill passes out of committee and how it fares in the full chamber.

Once a bill passes out of committee, the chamber leadership will decide whether and when to schedule a debate and a vote on the bill for the full membership of the chamber. However, the passage of a bill out of committee does not guarantee its success in the chamber, as members can still vote according to their conscience or cross over to the other party's position.

In the context of "I'm Just a Bill" from Schoolhouse Rock!, the bill expresses its hope to survive the committee stage and receive a favourable report, recognising that many bills do not make it past this stage. The committee's decision can be a significant hurdle in the journey of a bill becoming a law.

The process of introducing legislation

In reality, the process of introducing legislation can begin with any legislator, on any topic they wish. Sometimes, lawmakers introduce legislation to demonstrate their commitment to a particular cause, or to make a statement about a political conversation they or their constituents think is important. Legislation can be introduced in either chamber of Congress at any time, and it is not uncommon for identical legislation to be introduced in both the House of Representatives and the Senate concurrently, to speed up the process. Bills are generally introduced by a single legislator but are co-sponsored by several others, to build support.

Once introduced, legislation is referred to a committee with jurisdiction over the topic in question. For example, in Congress, legislation related to higher education is generally referred to either the House Committee on Education and Labor or the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions. Committees do most of the investigative work to draft legislation, hold hearings, and make recommendations to the rest of their colleagues within the full chamber.

The journey to Capitol Hill

The bill has to climb many steps to reach the Capitol Building in Washington. It starts as a "sad little scrap of paper", sitting on Capitol Hill, with a long journey ahead to the capital city. It is a long wait for the bill, sitting in committee, but it knows it will become a law someday. The bill must remain patient and courageous as it navigates the legislative process.

The bill's introduction to Congress is a significant step. It is presented to Congress by a Legislator, who writes it out and ensures it is considered by a committee. If the committee approves, the bill moves forward in the legislative process.

The bill then goes through a rigorous process of discussion and debate among key Congress members. They decide whether to report favourably on the bill or let it die in committee. If the bill survives this stage, it moves on to the House of Representatives for a vote.

The bill's journey to Capitol Hill is not easy, and it must overcome many hurdles and challenges along the way. It requires patience and courage to navigate the complex legislative process and the many steps leading to the Capitol Building.

The President's veto

In the song, the Bill explains that even if a bill passes through Congress with enough support, the President still has the power to veto it. A veto means that the President chooses not to sign the bill, preventing it from becoming a law. This is a significant obstacle for any bill, and it is rare for a bill to survive after being vetoed. The last time this occurred was in 2008 when a Democratic Congress pushed a Medicare expansion past the Bush White House.

If the President vetoes a bill, it is not the end of the road. The bill can still become a law if Congress votes on it again and overrides the veto. However, by this point, it is unlikely that the bill will become a law, as it requires a significant amount of support to override a presidential veto.

While "I'm Just a Bill" provides a basic understanding of how a bill becomes a law, it is important to acknowledge that the legislative process can be more intricate and challenging. The President's veto power is just one example of the many steps and considerations involved in turning an idea into a law.

Frequently asked questions