Customs To Law: The Evolution Of Social Norms

Customs are the earliest sources of law and form the basis of the English Common Law system. Customs are cultural practices that have become definite and backed by obligation or sanction due to their widespread practice and continuous presence. Customs can be divided into two types: general customs, which have the force of law throughout the territory of a state, and local customs, which have the force of law in a particular locality. Customs without binding obligations are prevalent in society and have societal sanctions attached to them, while customs with binding obligations are viewed as specific obligations of individuals and have more stringent sanctions. Customs with widespread acceptance acquire legal character and become a source of law.

Customary law in international law

Customary international law is a crucial aspect of international law, involving the principle of custom. It refers to international obligations that arise from established or usual international practices, which are often unwritten and less formal than those arising from written conventions and treaties. Customary international law is derived from the consistent conduct of states, which act out of a belief that the law compels them to do so. This belief is known as opinio juris.

Customary international law is one of the oldest sources of international law, alongside the law codified in international conventions. The International Court of Justice (ICJ), the main judicial body of the United Nations, acknowledges the existence of customary international law in its statute. According to Article 38(1)(b) of the ICJ Statute, customary international law is defined as "a general practice accepted as law". This means that a large number of states must engage in the practice, and they do so out of a sense of legal obligation rather than custom or habit.

The two essential elements of customary international law are state practice and opinio juris. State practice refers to the widespread repetition by states of similar international acts over time. Opinio juris refers to the requirement that these acts must occur out of a sense of legal obligation. Additionally, the acts must be taken by a significant number of states and not be rejected by a significant number of states.

Customary international law is particularly important in the absence of a treaty or other controlling rule. It fills gaps left by treaty law and addresses situations not specifically provided for in treaty law. It is also crucial in the law of armed conflict and humanitarian action, as it codifies interactions and confrontations between states and non-state actors.

Customary international law can be established through various sources, including treaties, decisions of national and international courts, national legislation, diplomatic correspondence, opinions of national legal advisors, and the practice of international organizations. It is recognised by the International Court of Justice, jurists, the United Nations, and its member states as one of the primary sources of international law.

Customary law in civil law tradition

Customary law, also known as consuetudinary or unofficial law, is a set of customs, practices, and beliefs that are accepted as obligatory rules of conduct by a community. It is often unwritten and based on long-standing traditions, customs, and rules that a community accepts as binding. Customary law is applied in many countries, sometimes alongside civil law, common law, or religious legal systems. In civil law jurisdictions, customary law is recognised as a source of law, although its importance is said to be "slight and decreasing".

Customary law can be traced back to medieval times, with the development of custumals—collections of local customary law that were compiled and later written down by local jurists. Custumals became the undisputed rule by which certain rights, entitlements, and obligations were regulated between members of a community. Over time, these collections of local customary laws were consolidated and codified, with the most notable examples being France's Napoleonic Code and Germany's Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch.

Customary law is often administered at the local level through traditional, informal justice systems. However, in some countries, it is enforced within the modern court system. The recognition and enforcement of customary law vary by country and region and may evolve over time as local customs change. Customary law may be subordinate to statutes and regulations, and it is not always given the same weight as judicial precedent in civil law systems.

In jurisdictions where civil law and customary law coexist, the relationship between the two can be complex. Customary law may be considered subordinate to civil law or may influence the interpretation and application of civil law. The Scandinavian legal systems, for example, are characterised by a mix of civil law and Scandinavian customary law, while the laws of the Channel Islands blend Norman customary law and French civil law.

In conclusion, customary law in the civil law tradition is a recognised source of law, although its influence may vary across jurisdictions. It is shaped by local customs, traditions, and norms, and its enforcement can range from informal community-based systems to formal court proceedings. Customary law's role and significance within civil law systems are subject to ongoing scholarly debate and can be influenced by factors such as legal pluralism, codification, and the relative weight of judicial precedent.

Customary law in common law

Customary law is a set of laws based on the traditions, customs, or norms of a local community. It is applied in many countries around the world, often in conjunction with civil, common, and religious legal systems. The content and features of customary law vary by country or region and may evolve over time, in keeping with changes in local customs. In countries with weak formal justice systems, the use of customary law is more prevalent.

Customary law systems are based on patterns of behaviour (or customs) that have come to be accepted as legal requirements or rules of conduct within a particular country. The laws of customary legal systems are usually unwritten and are often dispensed by elders, passed down through generations.

Customary law may be implemented by national judiciaries, but in many countries, it is applied through traditional, often informal, justice systems. These traditional systems, rooted in family and community structures, resolve disputes at the local or regional level. Some are government-sanctioned, while others are not officially recognised.

Customary law is often—but not always—unwritten. It is based on long-standing traditions, customs, and rules that a community accepts as binding. Customary law is often administered at the local level in accordance with tradition and dispute resolution mechanisms. However, in some countries, it is enforced within the modern court system.

Customary law is a recognised source of law within jurisdictions of the civil law tradition, where it may be subordinate to both statutes and regulations. It is also used in some developing countries, usually alongside common or civil law.

Customs are the earliest sources of law and form the basis of the English Common Law system as we see it today. They can be described as cultural practices that have become definite and backed by obligation or sanction by virtue of widespread practice and continued presence.

In the English common law, "long usage" must be established. It is a broad principle of property law that, if something has gone on for a long time without objection, the law will eventually recognise the fact and give the person doing it the legal right to continue. It is known in case law as "customary rights". Something that has been practised since time immemorial by reference to a particular locality may acquire the legal status of a custom, which is a form of local law.

Customary law in canon law

Canon law is a set of ordinances and regulations made by ecclesiastical authority (church leadership) for the government of a Christian organization or church and its members. It is the first modern Western legal system and is the oldest continuously functioning legal system in the West.

Customary law, on the other hand, is a set of customs, practices, and beliefs that are accepted as obligatory rules of conduct by a community. It is a recognized source of law within civil law jurisdictions and is also a source of law in the canon law of the Catholic Church.

In the context of canon law, custom refers to the established patterns of behavior and practices that are specific to a particular social or ecclesiastical setting, such as a locality or a church. Customary law in canon law exists when a certain legal practice is observed and recognized as binding by the relevant actors, including church authorities and members.

For a custom to become a source of law in canon law, it typically needs to meet certain criteria. These criteria may include longevity (practiced for a long time, often "time immemorial"), consistency (practiced continuously without interruption), reasonableness (not arbitrary, but based on principles of justice and public utility), peaceableness (non-violent), and conformity with public policy and the general principles of law.

In summary, customary law in canon law refers to the established patterns of behavior and practices that are specific to a particular church or ecclesiastical setting. It becomes a source of law when recognized by the relevant actors and can shape the regulations and practices within that context. Customary law in canon law reflects the unique traditions and beliefs of a church community and plays a role in governing their activities.

Customary law in developing countries

Customary law is a set of laws based on traditions, customs, or norms of a local community. It is often used in developing countries alongside common or civil law. For example, in Ethiopia, there are over 60 systems of customary law in force, despite the adoption of civil law in the 1950s. This is partly due to a lack of resources to enforce a centralised legal system across the country, but also due to a commitment to preserving these customary systems.

Customary law is often unwritten and based on long-standing traditions, customs, and rules that a community accepts as binding. It is usually administered at the local level, in accordance with tradition and dispute resolution mechanisms. However, in some countries, it is enforced within the modern court system.

Customary law is a recognised source of law within civil law jurisdictions, where it may be subordinate to statutes and regulations. It is also used in some religious legal systems, such as the canon law of the Catholic Church, which requires the consent of the legislator for a custom to obtain the force of law.

Customary law can be further divided into two types: general custom and local custom. General custom has the force of law throughout the territory of a state, such as the Common Law in England. Local custom, on the other hand, has the force of law in a particular locality and is considered to have higher authority than general custom.

Customary law is often associated with flexibility and a "repertoire of norms" from which litigants and adjudicators can choose when negotiating solutions. This flexibility can be advantageous for dispute settlement, allowing for the accommodation of conflicting norms and providing a "strategic resource" for disputants.

However, it is important to note that not all customs have the force of law, and the recognition of custom as law can vary across different legal systems. In some cases, customary law practices have been criticised for failing to comply with international human rights norms.

Frequently asked questions