Interstate Commerce Act: A Historical Law Overview

The Interstate Commerce Act became law on February 4, 1887, when it was signed by President Grover Cleveland. The Act was passed in response to public demand for the regulation of the railroad industry, which had become the first industry subject to federal regulation. The Act created the Interstate Commerce Commission, which was tasked with monitoring railroads to ensure compliance with the new regulations.

The Interstate Commerce Act was signed into law on February 4, 1887

The Act was passed in response to public outrage over the growing power and wealth of railroad corporations. Railroads were the principal form of transportation for people and goods, and they were often accused of forming monopolies, wielding corrupt political influence, stock manipulations, and rate discriminations. The Act created a federal regulatory agency, the Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC), to monitor railroads and ensure compliance with the new regulations.

The Interstate Commerce Act of 1887 was a landmark legislation that challenged the philosophy of laissez-faire economics and established Congress's right to regulate private corporations engaged in interstate commerce. It set guidelines for how railroads conducted business, including requiring reasonable and just rates, prohibiting rebates to high-volume users, and making it illegal to charge higher rates for shorter hauls.

The Act also established a five-member enforcement board, the ICC, which became the first independent regulatory agency of the US government. The ICC heard complaints against railroads, issued cease-and-desist orders, and investigated and prosecuted violations of the Act. While the Act had some successes, such as requiring railroads to submit annual reports, it was not very effective in practice due to contradictory provisions and the difficulty of determining which rates were discriminatory.

Over time, the Interstate Commerce Commission's authority was narrowed by the courts, and Congress passed additional legislation to further regulate the railroad industry and other modes of transportation. The ICC was eventually abolished in 1995, and its remaining functions were transferred to the Surface Transportation Board.

The Act created the Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC)

The Interstate Commerce Act, passed on February 4, 1887, created the Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC), a five-member board designed to oversee the conduct of the railroad industry. The ICC was the first federal independent regulatory commission in the US, and it served as a model for future regulatory agencies.

The Act's creation of the ICC was a direct response to public demand to constrain the railroads' conduct. In the years following the Civil War, railroads were privately owned and entirely unregulated, resulting in natural monopolies over the areas they serviced. This led to accusations of monopolistic practices, political corruption, stock manipulations, and rate discriminations.

The ICC was tasked with monitoring railroads to ensure compliance with the new regulations set out by the Act. These regulations included requiring railroads to publicize shipping rates, prohibiting short-haul or long-haul fare discrimination, and mandating that rate changes be "reasonable and just."

While the Act's terms often contradicted each other and its overall effectiveness was limited, it did successfully require railroads to submit annual reports to the ICC and banned special rates arranged among railroads.

Over time, the ICC's authority was narrowed by the courts, and in 1995, Congress abolished the commission, transferring its remaining functions to the Surface Transportation Board. Despite its shortcomings and eventual dissolution, the creation of the ICC through the Interstate Commerce Act marked a significant turning point in federal policy, demonstrating Congress's expanded power to address national issues involving commerce across state lines.

The ICC was the first independent regulatory agency of the US government

The Interstate Commerce Act, passed on February 4, 1887, created the Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC), the first independent regulatory agency of the US government. The ICC was established in response to mounting public anger against railroad malpractices and abuses. The agency's original purpose was to regulate railroads to ensure fair rates, eliminate rate discrimination, and regulate other aspects of common carriers, including interstate bus lines and telephone companies.

The ICC was the first regulatory commission in US history, and its establishment marked a significant turning point in federal policy. Before the Act, Congress had applied the Commerce Clause only on a limited basis, typically to remove barriers that states imposed on interstate trade. The Act demonstrated that Congress could apply the Commerce Clause more expansively to national issues involving commerce across state lines.

The ICC was tasked with overseeing the conduct of the railroad industry, which had become the first industry subject to federal regulation. The agency ensured that railroads complied with the new regulations, including requirements for reasonable and just rates and the prohibition of short-haul or long-haul fare discrimination. The ICC heard complaints against railroads and issued cease-and-desist orders to combat unfair practices.

Over time, the ICC's jurisdiction expanded beyond railroads to include all common carriers except airplanes by 1940. Its enforcement powers to set rates were also gradually extended through statute and Supreme Court interpretations of the Commerce Clause. In addition, the ICC was responsible for consolidating railroad systems, managing labor disputes in interstate transport, and enforcing Supreme Court rulings on the desegregation of passenger terminal facilities.

Despite its achievements, the ICC faced challenges and limitations. Courts narrowed the agency's authority, and its powers were curtailed by deregulation measures in the 1970s and 1980s. Ultimately, the ICC was abolished in 1995, and its remaining functions were transferred to the new National Surface Transportation Board.

The Act was a response to public demand to regulate the railroad industry

The Interstate Commerce Act of 1887 was a direct response to public demand to regulate the railroad industry. In the years following the Civil War, railroads were privately owned and entirely unregulated. The railroad companies held a natural monopoly in the areas they serviced, and they became even more competitive as they expanded into each other's markets.

The first attempt to regulate the railroad industry's practices came in 1871 at the state level. Illinois passed regulatory legislation first, and states across the South and Midwest quickly followed suit. However, the states were powerless to regulate interstate commerce, and the railroads were expanding their operations across more state borders all the time.

In the 1870s, various constituencies, notably the Grange movement representing farmers, lobbied Congress to regulate railroads. While the Senate investigated and reported its findings and recommendations in 1874, Congress initially declined to step in, mirroring the lack of consensus in approach.

Small businesses and farmers were protesting that the railroads charged them higher rates than larger corporations, and that the railroads were also setting higher rates for short hauls than for long-distance hauls. Although the railroads claimed economic justification for policies that favored big businesses, small shippers insisted that the railroads were gouging them.

In 1886, the Supreme Court ruled in Wabash, St. Louis & Pacific Railway Company v. Illinois that state laws regulating interstate railroads were unconstitutional because they violated the Commerce Clause of the Constitution, which gives Congress the exclusive power "to regulate Commerce with foreign nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes." This ruling, along with continued public anger over unfair railroad rates, prompted Illinois senator Shelby M. Cullom to hold the hearings that led to the enactment of the Interstate Commerce Act.

The Act was also a response to the Wabash v. Illinois Supreme Court ruling

The Interstate Commerce Act, passed on February 4, 1887, was a direct response to the Wabash v. Illinois Supreme Court ruling of 1886. The Wabash case saw the Supreme Court strike down an Illinois law outlawing long-and-short-haul discrimination. The court ruled that only the federal government could regulate interstate commerce.

The Interstate Commerce Act addressed the problem of railroad monopolies by setting guidelines for how the railroads could do business. The act became law with the support of both major political parties and pressure groups from all regions of the country. Applying only to railroads, the law required "just and reasonable" rate changes; prohibited special rates or rebates for individual shippers; prohibited "preference" in rates for any particular localities, shippers, or products; forbade long-haul/short-haul discrimination; prohibited pooling of traffic or markets; and established a five-member Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC).

The Wabash case was a significant moment in federal policy. Before 1887, Congress had applied the Commerce Clause only on a limited basis, usually to remove barriers that the states tried to impose on interstate trade. The Interstate Commerce Act showed that Congress could apply the Commerce Clause more expansively to national issues if they involved commerce across state lines. After 1887, the national economy grew much more integrated, making almost all commerce interstate and international.

The Wabash case also led to the creation of the first modern regulatory agency, the ICC, in 1887.

Frequently asked questions