Family Law: Who Decides?

which law can family members make decisions for them

In the UK, the Mental Capacity Act 2005 provides information on how decisions are made on behalf of someone without mental capacity. If an adult lacks the mental capacity to make a particular decision, the law states that a decision must be made in the person's 'best interests'. Family members have a right to be consulted in such cases. In the case of divorced or separated parents, a parenting plan should allocate responsibility for decisions about their children, whether one parent receives all decision-making authority or the parents must cooperate to make the decision together. In Australia, family law encourages separated parents to consult each other when making decisions on major long-term issues for their child, and if they cannot agree, a judge in a family law court will make a decision based on the best interests of the child.

Characteristics Values
Applicable laws Mental Capacity Act 2005 (UK), Family Law Act (Australia)
Who can make decisions Family members, attorneys-in-fact, court-appointed deputies, parents
Decision-making criteria Best interests of the individual, individual's mental capacity, individual's wishes
Types of decisions Medical, financial, property, welfare, child-related
Overriding decisions Family members can petition the court to revoke power of attorney if they believe the attorney-in-fact is acting irresponsibly
Preventing conflicts Open communication, maintaining records, consulting family members

lawshun

Parental responsibility

In the context of the parent-child relationship, parental wrongdoing often means failure to supervise a child with known dangerous tendencies. For example, if a child has a history of texting while driving, and the parents are aware but still allow the child to drive unsupervised, they may be found negligent if the child causes an accident. Many states, including Florida, hold parents liable for personal injuries and property damages caused by their underage children. This is known as vicarious liability, where the parent is held legally responsible for the actions of their minor (under 18 years old) children.

In shared parenting arrangements, parents are typically required to discuss and reach a joint consensus on decisions regarding their child's education, religion, and medical care. These agreements should be included in a written parenting plan that outlines the decision-making authority of each parent. In rare cases, a court may grant sole decision-making responsibility to one parent if shared decision-making is deemed detrimental to the child, such as in cases of domestic violence or substance abuse.

Additionally, when a minor applies for a driver's license in Florida, a parent or guardian must sign the application, assuming responsibility for any injuries or damages caused by the child's driving. This includes financial responsibility for any damages caused by the child's willful misconduct or reckless disregard for consequences while behind the wheel.

It is important to note that parental responsibility laws vary by state and country, and the above examples primarily refer to laws in Florida, USA.

lawshun

Power of attorney

The principal grants the attorney-in-fact the power to make important decisions about their life or finances because they trust them. However, family members cannot override the decisions of their loved one's attorney-in-fact, no matter what their relation to the principal is. If the attorney-in-fact for an incapacitated principal is acting irresponsibly or causing harm to them, their family can try to override the agent's decisions by filing a petition with the court to try to have the power of attorney revoked.

Creating a power of attorney usually involves the following steps: choosing an agent (usually a family member or friend), drafting the POA based on the principal's needs, and signing and executing the document. Once the power of attorney is signed, it becomes legally binding, but the rules around signing vary from state to state. For example, some states require multiple witnesses and a notarised signature for the document to be considered valid.

A power of attorney can help provide clarity for families around who is responsible for making certain decisions. It can help create a communication structure among siblings and other family members as they work together to address their senior loved one’s needs. It is recommended that the principal discusses any decisions made by the attorney-in-fact with their family members, to keep them informed and prevent potential conflicts.

lawshun

Conservatorship

There are several types of conservatorships, including limited, short-term, and full or general conservatorships. Limited conservatorship usually applies to individuals with developmental or mental disabilities who are still capable of making some important decisions. In this case, the conservatee may retain the right to decide where they live, for example. Short-term conservatorship typically lasts no more than 90 days and addresses specific and immediate needs, such as unexpected incapacitation. General conservatorship, also known as probate conservatorship, does not usually have a temporary period unless there is an urgent emergency creating risk to the person or their estate.

In the state of California, there are two types of conservatorships: Lanterman-Petris-Short (LPS) and Probate conservatorships. LPS conservatorships begin with a temporary 30-day period, which can be renewed annually or terminated if no longer needed. Probate conservatorships, on the other hand, do not automatically expire and typically do not have a temporary period.

When determining whether to establish a conservatorship, the court may appoint an attorney to represent the proposed conservatee. If the conservatee is unable to have an attorney-client relationship due to impairment, a guardian ad litem may be appointed to act on their behalf and represent their best interests to the court. An outside party or agency, often a local county mental health representative with expertise in a relevant field, must review the facts of the case and submit a report to the court before a decision is made.

lawshun

Court of Protection

The Court of Protection is a specialist court that makes decisions or appoints deputies to make decisions on behalf of people who lack the capacity to do so themselves. The Court of Protection's powers are defined by the Mental Capacity Act 2005, which came into force on 1 October 2007. The Court of Protection was established under the terms of this Act, which also outlines how decisions are made on behalf of someone without mental capacity.

The Court of Protection has the power to decide if a person lacks the capacity to make decisions for themselves, and then to decide what actions to take in the person's best interests. This includes decisions about where protected persons live, who they see, and how they are cared for. The Court can also make declarations, decisions, or orders on financial or welfare matters affecting people who lack capacity to make these decisions. For example, in 2015, the Court of Protection ruled that a woman with six children and an IQ of 70 should be sterilised because another pregnancy would have been a "significantly life-threatening event" for her and the foetus.

The Court of Protection can also appoint deputies to make decisions on behalf of those deemed to lack capacity. Deputies are most commonly appointed to deal with matters of property and finances, although the Mental Capacity Act 2005 allows them to make decisions on health and welfare as well. The Court can also remove deputies or attorneys who fail to carry out their duties.

The Court of Protection is responsible for determining disputes regarding the registration of enduring powers of attorney and Lasting Powers of Attorney, appointing new trustees, authorising certain gifts, and making statutory wills. Cases are heard by Circuit, District, and High Court Judges at the central registry in Holborn and at courts throughout England and Wales.

lawshun

Mental Capacity Act 2005

The Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA) is a law in England and Wales that protects and empowers people who may lack the mental capacity to make decisions about their care and treatment. It applies to people aged 16 and over, and covers a range of decisions from day-to-day choices such as what to wear, to more serious life-changing decisions like whether to move into a care home or undergo major surgery.

The MCA sets out that every adult has the right to make their own decisions and must be assumed to have the capacity to do so unless proven otherwise. This means that all practicable help must be given to support a person to make their own decisions, and they should not be treated as lacking capacity just because they have a particular medical condition or disability, or because they make an unwise decision.

The Act outlines that when a person lacks capacity, any decisions made on their behalf must be in their best interests. It also establishes the role of an Independent Mental Capacity Advocate (IMCA), who can support and represent individuals who lack capacity and do not have family or friends to advocate for them.

Under the MCA, individuals can also grant a Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA) to another person or people to make decisions about their health and welfare, including consent to medical treatment, as well as decisions about property and financial affairs.

The Court of Protection oversees the operation of the MCA and deals with issues related to financial and healthcare matters for those lacking mental capacity. The court also resolves disputes between carers, healthcare workers, and social workers regarding a person's best interests.

Frequently asked questions

Family law grants parents the right to make decisions for their minor children. Both parents are typically required to participate in making important decisions about their children, such as their education, religion, and medical care.

Family members can make decisions for their adult relatives if they are granted power of attorney or are appointed as deputies by the Court of Protection.

The Mental Capacity Act 2005 is a UK government law that provides information on how decisions are made on behalf of someone without mental capacity. It outlines that a decision must be made in the person's "best interests".

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment