How To Change Zoning Laws: A Guide

who can change zoning laws

Zoning laws are a municipality's mechanism for controlling land use and are enacted primarily at the state and local levels. When a property owner or developer wants to change the zoning of their property, they can apply for rezoning or a nonconforming use permit. The process for changing zoning laws varies from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, but it generally involves submitting a rezoning request or application, which includes an explanation of the desired change and data about the area. This may be supported by surveys, drawings, photographs, and models. The request is then considered by the governing body, and if approved, the change is effected in law. In some cases, zoning changes may be initiated by the local government planning commission to fulfill responsibilities relating to the orderly growth, improvement, and future development of the city.

Characteristics Values
Who can change zoning laws? The government, local government planning commission, or municipality
Who can request a change? Property owners, real estate owners, or buyers
What is the process? Submit a rezoning request or application, get support from neighbouring property owners, present the request and reasons for change, and gain approval from the City Planning Commission and City Council
What are the alternatives to changing zoning laws? Variances, special-use permits, conditional reviews, nonconforming use permits, or alternative development codes
What factors are considered? Public interest, public infrastructure support, and negative impacts on surrounding land and the environment

lawshun

Property owners can apply for a nonconforming use permit

Zoning laws are a complex area of real estate law, and each jurisdiction has its own rules and regulations. Generally, zoning laws are changed by local government planning commissions or municipal officials. However, property owners can apply for a nonconforming use permit if their land use or structure was legal when it was established but no longer conforms to current zoning standards.

A nonconforming use is a 'vested' property right that has some protections. It is a use that was allowed when it came into existence but is no longer permitted under the current zoning laws. For example, an apartment in a single-family dwelling, two dwellings on one lot, or a commercial business operating in a residential district. To maintain a nonconforming use, landowners must often register it with the local Office of Planning and Zoning, providing evidence of its continuous operation, such as sales receipts, bills, rental leases, and building permits.

Property owners may need to submit a site plan drawn to an engineering scale, showing all existing structures, their dimensions, and their distance from property lines. This process allows the Office of Planning and Zoning to determine the lawful use and extent of that use. Failing to register a nonconforming use can result in citations for zoning violations, fines, and difficulties in obtaining building permits or buying and selling the property.

It is important to note that resumption of a nonconforming use after it has been abandoned or destroyed may be prohibited in some states. The term "abandonment" is generally defined by a period of non-use, usually between six months and a year. Some states also require evidence of an "intent to abandon" for a nonconforming use to be considered terminated. To prevent nonconforming uses from becoming blighted properties, routine maintenance and repairs are typically allowed, provided they do not constitute expansion or enlargement.

In some cases, property owners may apply for a variance, which is a request to deviate from current zoning requirements. A variance is not a change in the zoning law itself but a waiver of specific requirements. Variances are typically granted when property owners can demonstrate practical difficulties in using their property due to existing zoning regulations. For example, a landowner in a commercially zoned area may be granted a variance to construct accessory dwelling units to promote affordability.

lawshun

Local land-use planners may propose changes

Local land-use planners play a crucial role in proposing changes to zoning laws, and their expertise is vital in shaping the development of communities. These professionals are responsible for understanding the complex dynamics of land usage and proposing modifications that align with the needs and vision of the local area.

One of the key aspects of their role is evaluating the current zoning regulations and identifying areas where updates or revisions are necessary. This involves a comprehensive analysis of the existing land-use patterns, community needs, and future development goals. By staying attuned to the pulse of the community, local land-use planners can propose changes that reflect the evolving nature of the area.

For example, a local land-use planner might propose a mixed-use zoning change to accommodate the New Urbanist vision of walkable communities that combine residential, commercial, and retail spaces. Such a proposal would encourage the development of vibrant, compact neighbourhoods where people can live, work, and socialise within close proximity.

Additionally, local land-use planners may identify opportunities for incentive zoning, which offers property developers the chance to build more intensively in exchange for providing public benefits. This could include the creation of affordable housing units, the preservation of open spaces, or the enhancement of walkability within the community. By proposing such changes, local land-use planners can foster a more flexible and rewarding development environment.

Furthermore, local land-use planners are often at the forefront of ensuring zoning laws protect the health, safety, and general welfare of the community. This may involve proposing changes to historic districts to preserve structures of historical, architectural, or cultural significance. Their proposals can also address practical considerations, such as granting variances to property owners who face difficulties in using their land due to existing zoning regulations.

lawshun

The government may alter zoning for affordable housing

Zoning laws dictate where housing can be built and what type of housing it can be. Local governments have the power to alter zoning laws to promote affordable housing. For example, the local government planning commission may alter a zoning district for affordable housing units.

In 1926, a landmark U.S. Supreme Court case, Village of Euclid v. Ambler Realty Co., established the validity of zoning ordinances as constitutional under the police power of local governments as long as they have some relation to public health, safety, morals, or general welfare. "Euclidian Zoning" is the most common type of zoning in the U.S. and allows one kind of land use per zone. However, this type of zoning has acted as a barrier to affordable housing for nearly a century, with most local governments that adopted it dedicating most residential land to single-family-only zoning.

Local governments are increasingly recognizing that restrictive zoning and outdated land-use regulations can suppress housing supply, drive up housing costs, and widen racial and economic disparities. States can play a role in driving zoning reform and removing barriers to denser development. For example, California has passed laws allowing duplexes and small multifamily developments in areas previously zoned exclusively for single-family homes.

To promote affordable housing, local governments can allow by-right housing approvals or publish pre-approved housing designs that can bypass discretionary approval processes. They can also reduce or remove parking minimums, which can lower developer costs and allow for alternate uses of land. Additionally, revising height restrictions can increase density and the supply of housing by allowing taller multifamily buildings.

lawshun

Zoning changes can be legislative actions

Zoning changes are often necessary to accommodate and guide development in a community. They can take the form of an amendment to the zoning map, the zoning text, or both. A zoning map amendment changes the designation of a parcel from one zone district to another, while a text amendment alters the definition of a zoning district. These changes are legislative actions that can be proposed by anyone, including individuals or the city.

The process for changing zoning laws can vary depending on the jurisdiction, but some standard steps are generally followed. Firstly, a rezoning request or application is submitted, explaining the reasons for the desired change and providing supporting data. This is typically followed by a hearing where the owner presents their request and may use surveys, drawings, photographs, or models to convey their proposed plan. Engineers or lawyers are often hired to assist with the rezoning process.

In the case of a zoning map amendment, a formal public review process called the Uniform Land Use Review Procedure (ULURP) is initiated. This process sets time frames for public participation in local and citywide reviews of land-use actions. The amendment must then be approved by the City Planning Commission and adopted by the City Council. Text amendments follow a similar process, with the City Planning Commission and City Council approval required. However, there is no time limit for the City Planning Commission's review in this case.

Zoning changes can have significant implications for a community's development and the environment. They may be approved if they are supported by adequate public infrastructure and will not produce negative impacts on surrounding land uses or the environment. If an approval vote is denied, the applicant may propose a different amendment, wait a given period and return with the same proposal, or take legal action.

While zoning changes can open up new possibilities for property owners, they can also have unintended consequences. It is essential to carefully consider the potential impacts and consult with professionals, such as land use and zoning attorneys, before initiating any zoning changes.

lawshun

Variances allow for deviations from zoning requirements

Zoning laws are typically changed by local government planning commissions, which may alter zoning districts to meet demands, such as the need for affordable housing units. However, this can be a complex process, and it may be necessary to consult a local land use and zoning attorney for advice.

Variances are a way to deviate from zoning requirements without changing the zoning law itself. They are a waiver of the requirements of the zoning ordinance. There are two types of variances: area variances and use variances. Area variances allow property owners to construct buildings that do not meet the physical requirements of zoning ordinances, such as square-footage restrictions. Use variances, on the other hand, allow landowners to use their property in ways that are typically restricted by zoning laws. For example, a use variance could allow a business to operate in a residential area.

Use variances are more difficult to obtain than area variances. To obtain a use variance, a property owner must demonstrate that the existing zoning regulations present a practical difficulty in using their property. They must show that they are experiencing a unique hardship or practical difficulty that justifies the need for a variance. This could be due to the current zoning regulations impeding the realisation of a reasonable return on their investment. The variance must also be consistent with the spirit, purpose, and intent of the ordinance, such that public safety is secured and substantial justice is achieved.

Area variances are often sought when property owners wish to make physical alterations or additions that fall outside the prescribed zoning dimensions. Common applications include home extensions, fences along property boundaries, and off-street parking facilities.

The process of obtaining a variance typically involves filing an application and paying a fee. The zoning board will then perform a comprehensive analysis to determine if the variance could be granted without harming the surrounding community. This process may involve the use of surveys, drawings, photographs, and models to convey the proposed plan.

Frequently asked questions

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment