Texas Abortion Law: Who Bears The $10,000 Cost?

Texas' abortion law, which bans abortions after six weeks of pregnancy, has sparked widespread controversy and criticism. A key aspect of this law is the provision that allows private citizens to sue anyone who aids and abets an abortion and receive a minimum reward of $10,000 if they win the lawsuit. This has raised concerns about incentivizing vigilantes or bounty hunters to target not only abortion providers but also individuals who may have indirectly supported someone seeking an abortion, such as friends, family members, or even Uber drivers. The defendant, regardless of their role, is responsible for paying the $10,000 in damages, in addition to legal fees, creating a financial burden and a chilling effect on abortion access in the state.

Who can be sued under the Texas abortion law?

The Texas abortion law, known as Senate Bill 8 (SB 8), allows private citizens to sue anyone who knowingly "aids or abets" an abortion. This includes abortion providers, doctors, and those who help fund or facilitate the procedure, such as by providing transportation to a clinic. The law instructs courts to award plaintiffs a minimum of $10,000 in damages if they succeed in their lawsuit. It is important to note that the patient who obtains an abortion cannot be sued under this law.

The law's enforcement scheme is unprecedented, as it is designed to evade federal court review by authorizing only private citizens to bring civil lawsuits. State officials, who are typically responsible for enforcing state laws, cannot be sued under SB 8. This unique aspect of the law has raised concerns about the potential for similar laws to restrict other constitutional rights.

In addition to SB 8, there are several other Texas abortion-related statutes that allow for legal action. For example, the Texas Family Code allows the Attorney General to impose civil fines on doctors who perform abortions on unemancipated minors. The Texas Health and Safety Code includes provisions for civil fines and lawsuits against physicians who do not properly report abortion complications or who perform partial-birth abortions. It also allows third parties to bring lawsuits against those who perform, aid, or abet an abortion.

The Texas abortion law has been challenged in court, but these challenges have largely been unsuccessful. The Supreme Court refused to block the law, and it remains in effect, with private citizens empowered to enforce it through civil lawsuits.

Who pays the $10,000 in damages?

The Texas abortion law, also known as SB 8, offers a $10,000 bounty to any private citizen who successfully sues another person for helping to make an abortion possible. This could include the pregnant person's doctor, nurses, therapist, pastor, partner, friend, or even an Uber driver who drove them to the clinic. The law applies to abortions that may take place as early as two weeks after a missed period or six weeks of gestation, before many people realize they are pregnant.

Under SB 8, any private citizen can sue someone for "aiding or abetting" an abortion, regardless of their personal connection to the person. If the plaintiff wins the case, they are awarded a minimum of $10,000, plus attorney's fees. On the other hand, the defendant would not qualify for legal fee relief, regardless of the outcome of the case. This has raised concerns about the potential for frivolous and baseless lawsuits that could overwhelm the court system.

The law, which went into effect on September 1, 2024, has been criticized for infringing on a woman's constitutional right to privacy and for interfering with the ability of faith leaders, doctors, and others to provide support and counsel to pregnant individuals. It represents a new strategy in the anti-abortion movement, aiming to circumvent previous legal challenges by empowering private citizens to enforce abortion restrictions.

While the law sets a minimum award of $10,000 for successful plaintiffs, it is important to note that this penalty is in addition to any other civil liabilities the defendant may face. The law also does not provide legal fee relief for defendants, even if they are found not guilty, creating a financial burden and further deterring abortion assistance.

Who is exempt from being sued?

Texas' abortion ban exempts women who seek abortions from criminal charges. The law does not criminalize self-managed abortions. However, abortion providers can face severe penalties, including criminal charges, license revocation, and civil suits with a minimum penalty of $100,000, plus attorney's fees and court costs.

Under Texas' abortion ban, physicians and healthcare professionals who perform, induce, or attempt an abortion are subject to criminal and civil penalties. The law allows for criminal charges ranging from a first-degree to a second-degree felony, depending on whether the abortion resulted in the death of the fetus. Additionally, each violation carries a civil penalty of at least $100,000, and medical professionals can have their licenses or permits revoked.

The Texas abortion ban also enables private citizens to sue abortion providers for a minimum of $10,000 under the state's six-week abortion ban. This provision has been referred to as creating "bounty hunters."

While the law exempts women who seek abortions from criminal charges, it provides for enforcement through private civil actions or criminal statutes. This means that anyone who aids or abets a woman in obtaining an abortion can be held responsible and face severe consequences, including substantial financial penalties.

It is important to note that the abortion ban in Texas includes certain exceptions, such as when the life or health of the pregnant patient is at risk. In such cases, a licensed physician must perform the abortion, and specific criteria must be met to qualify for this exception.

What constitutes a 'section 170A.002' violation?

Section 170A.002 of the Texas Health and Safety Code prohibits abortions outright, except in certain circumstances. A violation of this section occurs when a person knowingly performs, induces, or attempts an abortion. This includes abortions that result in the death of the fetus.

There are, however, exceptions to this prohibition. Firstly, the person carrying out the abortion must be a licensed physician. Secondly, the pregnant woman must have a life-threatening physical condition that is aggravated by, caused by, or arising from a pregnancy that places her at risk of death or serious risk of substantial impairment of a major bodily function. In this case, an abortion can be performed, but it must be done in a way that provides the best opportunity for the unborn child to survive. If this manner increases the risk of death or serious impairment to the pregnant woman, the abortion cannot be performed.

It is important to note that medical treatment provided to the pregnant woman that results in the accidental or unintentional injury or death of the unborn child does not constitute a violation of this section.

The penalties for violating Section 170A.002 are outlined in Chapter 170A. A person who performs an abortion in violation of this section commits a criminal offense, which is a felony. If the abortion results in the death of the fetus, it is a first-degree felony; otherwise, it is a second-degree felony. In addition to criminal penalties, there is also a civil penalty of at least $100,000 for each violation, as well as attorney's fees and court costs. The physician or healthcare professional in violation will also have their license or permit revoked.

What are the consequences of aiding an abortion?

Texas has a law that bans abortions after six weeks of pregnancy, with certain exceptions. The law mobilizes private citizens to sue anyone they believe aided in an abortion in any way. If the plaintiff wins the case, they could be awarded a minimum of $10,000, plus attorneys' fees. The defendant, on the other hand, would not qualify for legal fee relief, no matter the outcome of the case. This has been referred to as a ''vigilante economy', incentivizing widespread prosecution and with no disincentive for baseless claims.

The law states that anyone who "aids or abets" an abortion could be sued. This could include:

• Doctors and nurses
• A therapist or pastor who offered moral support
• A partner who helped pay for the procedure
• A friend or Uber driver who gave the patient a ride to the clinic
• Teachers, parents, clergy, and friends

The consequences of aiding an abortion in Texas, therefore, could include being taken to court and forced to pay a minimum of $10,000, plus legal fees. This could apply to a wide range of people, and there is an increased risk of frivolous lawsuits being filed.

Frequently asked questions