Legislative Gridlock: Few Bills, Fewer Laws

The process of a bill becoming a law is long and complicated, with many steps and hurdles to overcome. In the US, a bill must pass both houses of Congress and be signed into law by the President. It may be introduced at any time, but it must be passed during the same congressional session in which it was proposed, which lasts for one year. If it does not complete the process, it is dropped and can only be revived by reintroducing it and starting the process again.

There are many opportunities to kill a bill before it becomes law. In each house, a bill must survive three stages: committee consideration, floor debate, and conference committees. Most bills die in committee or subcommittee, where they are pigeonholed or simply forgotten and never discussed. If a bill survives, hearings are set up, and the bill is marked up or revised until the committee is ready to send it to the floor.

In the House, a bill goes from committee to a special Rules Committee that sets time limits on debate and rules for adding amendments. In the Senate, rules for debate are much looser, and there are no restrictions on amendments. This lack of rules has led to the occasional filibuster, where a senator talks a bill to death.

Other reasons why so few bills become laws include the fact that lawmakers sometimes introduce bills they know have no chance of becoming law. Additionally, the process itself is very long and complicated, with many steps, and sponsors must be willing to bargain and compromise.

Bills must pass both houses of Congress and be signed by the President

For a bill to become a law, it must pass both houses of Congress and be signed by the President. This is a multi-step process, and each house has its own rules for how a bill is passed.

In the House of Representatives, a bill goes from committee to a special Rules Committee that sets time limits on debate and rules for adding amendments. The Rules Committee can impose a "gag rule" if time limits are short and no amendments are allowed from the floor. After this, the bill goes to the House floor for debate and a vote.

In the Senate, the rules for debate are much looser, and Senators are allowed to talk for as long as they like about each bill. No restrictions on amendments are allowed in the Senate, and this lack of rules has led to the occasional filibuster, where a Senator talks a bill to death. If a bill passes both houses, it is then sent to the President for signing.

The process for a bill to become a law is intentionally long and complicated and was designed by the Founding Fathers to ensure that laws are well-considered and deliberate.

Bills must be passed within the same congressional session of their proposal

The legislative process is long and complicated, with many steps. A bill must survive three stages in each house: committee consideration, floor debate, and conference committees. Most bills die in the committee stage, where they are pigeonholed or forgotten. If a bill survives, hearings are set up, and the bill is marked up or revised until the committee is ready to send it to the floor.

The process is intentionally designed to be difficult. The founders believed that efficiency was the hallmark of oppressive government and wanted to ensure that laws were well-considered and deliberate.

Bills can be killed by not acting on them during the last 10 days of Congress

The legislative process is a complex and lengthy one, with many steps and procedures that a bill must go through before it can become a law. One of the most important phases of this process is the action by committees. Committees provide the most intensive consideration of a proposed bill and are also the forum where the public is given the opportunity to be heard.

The Speaker of the House may refer a bill to multiple committees for consideration of those provisions of the bill within the jurisdiction of each committee concerned. The Speaker may also place time limits on committees, but usually, time limits are placed only on additional committees to which a bill has been referred following the report of the primary committee.

If a committee fails to act on a bill, it is effectively killed. This is known as a "pocket veto". Bills in the House can only be released from committee without a proper committee vote by a discharge petition signed by a majority of the House membership (218 members).

Bills can be pigeonholed or forgotten in committee

The legislative process is long and complicated, with many steps for a bill to go through before it can become a law. One of the reasons why so few bills become laws is that they can be pigeonholed or forgotten in committee.

The term "pigeonholed" comes from the old-fashioned roll-top desks with slots or "pigeonholes" into which papers were put and often soon forgotten. In the context of lawmaking, when a bill is pigeonholed, it is set aside and no longer considered, signalling the end of its legislative journey. This can happen when a bill is referred to the wrong committee by mistake, or when it is simply put away and never acted upon.

Committees play a crucial role in deciding the fate of bills. Once a bill is introduced, it is referred to the appropriate committee, which has the power to determine whether it will move forward or not. Due to the high volume of bills introduced in each session of Congress and limited resources, many bills end up being pigeonholed or forgotten within these committees.

The committee system, with its power to decide which bills proceed, can lead to bills being buried or dying in committee. This is often a result of time constraints and the sheer number of bills that need to be addressed. Committees have to prioritise and, as a result, some bills may be left behind.

The committee stage is a critical phase in the legislative process, where bills receive intensive consideration and the public is given the opportunity to be heard. Committees seek input from relevant departments, agencies, and sometimes the Government Accountability Office, to help inform their decisions. However, with a large volume of work, this phase can be easily overlooked by the public.

In conclusion, the pigeonholing of bills in committees is a significant factor in the low number of bills that become laws. The term refers to bills being set aside and forgotten, often due to the high volume of legislation and the limited resources of committees. This stage of the legislative process, though crucial, can be complex and time-consuming, contributing to the low success rate of bills.

Bills can be filibustered in the Senate

The filibuster is a method of delaying or blocking the progression of a bill through the Senate by prolonging speeches. The filibuster has been used by senators on a variety of issues, including civil rights and voting rights bills. For example, in 1891, the Federal Elections Bill, which would have provided federal oversight of state elections to ensure that Black men in the south were able to vote, was filibustered by Democratic senators. In 1922, 1923 and 1924, Senate Democrats filibustered the Dyer Anti-Lynching Bill, which was introduced to outlaw the use of lynching to suppress Black votes. In 1942, a bill targeting the poll tax, which required citizens to pay a tax before they could vote, was also filibustered by southern senators.

In the Senate, a filibuster can be overcome when 60 out of 100 senators vote to end debate and proceed to a vote. This has effectively set a supermajority requirement for passing legislation in the Senate. The use of the filibuster has escalated in recent years, slowing down business in the chamber. Between 1917 and 2014, there have been 161 exceptions to the filibuster's supermajority requirement.

Frequently asked questions